#17685: Connecting to 'Haiku' depot fails if IPv6 inactive
--------------------------------------+--------------------------
Reporter: kumba | Owner: axeld
Type: bug | Status: new
Priority: normal | Milestone: Unscheduled
Component: Network & Internet/Stack | Version: R1/beta3
Keywords: | Blocked By:
Blocking: | Platform: x86-64
--------------------------------------+--------------------------
At least I am pretty sure it's due to IPv6 being disabled.
Currently, I have, or I think I have, IPv6 disabled on my Haiku VM. In
the Network preferences dialog, it is impossible to change "IPv6" to
"Disabled" -- the dropdown forces to "Automatic". Nonetheless, I edited
/system/settings/network/interfaces and removed any references to IPv6 to
make sure IPv6 was fully disabled.
However, It appears that Haiku still tries to use IPv6 addressing before
IPv4 if a DNS lookup returns BOTH formats, but sends AAAA responses ahead
of A responses.
In this instance, if I try to run 'pkgman update', with the following
repository configuration:
Haiku: https://eu.hpkg.haiku-os.org/haiku/r1beta3/x86_64/current
HaikuPorts: https://eu.hpkg.haiku-os.org/haikuports/r1beta3/x86_64/current
Then pkgman will resolve "eu.hpkg.haiku-os.org" and receive an IPv6
address followed by an IPv4 address. Because I have disabled IPv6, pkgman
fails to connect and gives up on the 'Haiku' depot. It then tries
HaikuPorts, but appears to have walked down to the next DNS response,
which is an IPv4 address, and that succeeds, so it fetches repository
information for 'HaikuPorts' and can apply any updates.
I make an assumption that pkgman is failing on the IPv6 address because I
believe an IPv6 address is being returned first in the DNS response data.
I tried to wget the 'current' file for the 'Haiku' repo and wget shows
that the DNS resolution for that EU URL returns an IPv6 address first,
then an IPv4 address:
[[Image(https://imgur.com/a/iXFD9hY)]]
The workaround I used was to change to the US version of the URL (hosted
by CloudFlare it looks) at https://us.hpkg.haiku-
os.org/haiku/r1beta3/x86_64/current, and while a DNS resolution for that
address returns both IPv4 and IPv6 responses, the IPv4 responses are sent
first, so pkgman succeeds in connecting and fetching the repo file to
check for updates.
However, it looks like the US URL does not hold current updates for
HaikuPorts fot 'r1beta3' (it only has 'master'), so I have to leave that
at the EU URL address. So far, this doesn't seem to affect pkgman pulling
down updates for HaikuPorts.
It seems that there needs to be several fixes here:
1. Fix the dropdown in Network preferences to support disabling IPv6
2. Add the ability for the user to specify network stack preference (in
FreeBSD, this is done via setting ip6addrctl_policy to an appropriate
value, like "ipv4_prefer").
3. Fix how pkgman handles receiving/connecting to an address family that
is disabled in the system (or fix the DNS response for this URL to return
IPv4 answers before IPv6 answers).
4. Consider syncing the HaikuPorts 'r1beta3' data to the US URL hosted by
CloudFlare IPFS.
--
Ticket URL: <https://dev.haiku-os.org/ticket/17685>
Haiku <https://dev.haiku-os.org>
The Haiku operating system.
