- Climate scientist says 'Kyoto' [was] barred - Justice Scalia warns against 'bureaucrat' judges Patrice McDermott, Director OpenTheGovernment.org 202-332-OPEN (6736) www.openthegovernment.org - CLIMATE SCIENTIST SAYS 'KYOTO' BARRED - INVESTIGATORS EYE CENSORSHIP CLAIMS ABOUT WHITE HOUSE http://www.rockymountainnews.com/drmn/local/article/0,1299,DRMN_15_5205550,00.html By Jim Erickson, Rocky Mountain News December 11, 2006 A federal climate scientist in Boulder says his boss told him never to utter the word Kyoto and tried to bar him from using the phrase climate change at a conference. The allegations come as federal investigators probe whether Bush administration officials tried to block government scientists from speaking freely about global warming and attempted to censor their research. [...] "We were under instructions not to use the word Kyoto, which of course is absurd," said Tans, who measures levels of carbon dioxide at NOAA's Global Monitoring Division. He has worked for the agency since 1990. Tans said the order was issued verbally by his boss, David Hofmann, the division director. Another senior researcher at the Boulder laboratory, NOAA physicist James Elkins, said Hofmann told him the same thing. Elkins studies greenhouse gases and has worked at NOAA for more than 20 years. He said he can't remember when the directive was issued, but it was "probably in 2000 or 2001." "When I asked why we weren't supposed to use Kyoto, I was told that we're not supposed to use it in the policy context," Elkins said. "I'm not supposed to be talking about policy." Hofmann, however, called the allegations "nonsense" and said there was no ban on using the word Kyoto. "I never said it specifically in those words," Hofmann said. "I probably said that since the Kyoto Protocol is not ratified - is not part of the U.S. program - stay away from talking about Kyoto when you give a presentation." "It has nothing to do with the science we're doing here," Hofmann said of Kyoto. The Kyoto Protocol was negotiated in Kyoto, Japan, in December 1997 and went into effect in February 2005, following ratification by Russia. Elkins said the prohibition against using the word was lifted after Russia ratified the protocol. "Once Russia signed Kyoto, it was a done deal," he said. Last month, Sen. Frank Lautenberg, D-N.J., announced that inspectors general from NASA and the Commerce Department - NOAA's parent agency - had launched "coordinated, sweeping investigations of the Bush administration's censorship and suppression" of federal research into global warming. Auditors from the inspector general's office at Commerce have been interviewing NOAA employees, agency spokesman Jordan St. John said Thursday. At the same time the Government Accountability Office, the investigative arm of Congress, is conducting a separate review, St. John said. [...] In February, congressional leaders asked NASA to guarantee its scientific openness. They complained that an agency public affairs officer changed or filtered information about global warming and tried to limit reporters' access to James Hansen, a prominent NASA climate scientist. The public affairs officer, George Deutsch, resigned. Hansen said his NOAA colleagues were experiencing even more severe censorship. "It seems more like Nazi Germany or the Soviet Union than the United States," he told a New School University audience in New York, according to The Washington Post. In response, NOAA Administrator Conrad C. Lautenbacher Jr. sent an agencywide e-mail to employees stating, in part, "I encourage our scientists to speak freely and openly." [...] In September, the journal Nature said that NOAA officials on the East Coast blocked the release of a fact sheet that discussed purported links between global warming and stronger hurricanes. NOAA denied the allegation. That prompted New Jersey's Lautenberg and 13 other Democratic senators to request that the inspectors general from the Commerce Department and NASA take a look. Hofmann said that he and other NOAA division directors were asked last month to provide the inspector general's office with information about the agency's news media policy, climate-related news releases, and the allegedly suppressed hurricane fact sheet. "It was basically information related to NOAA's policies or procedures related to media issues, whether there were any difficulties with doing press releases on certain subjects," Hofmann said. "And quite a few requests for information on the hurricane fact sheet." The Associated Press contributed to this report. *** - JUSTICE SCALIA WARNS AGAINST 'BUREAUCRAT' JUDGES http://www.govexec.com/dailfed/1206/121306d1.htm December 13, 2006 By David Perera dperera@xxxxxxxxxxx Low pay for federal judges threatens to undermine the U.S. judiciary system by letting it become the domain of provincially minded career judges, Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia said Wednesday. [...] The career climbers are "going to be beady-eyed, cause-y people, more willing to take the veil," Scalia said. [...] Scalia also said he favors televising Supreme Court proceedings, if for nothing else than to show the American people that most of the workload centers around "Internal Revenue code, the [Employee Retirement Income Security Act], the bankruptcy code -- really dull stuff." [...] Growing intensity around the confirmation of Supreme Court justices in the Senate is a sign that theories other than originalism are destructive, Scalia said. If the high court is central in affirming rights, such as the right to privacy, then politicians find that the most important qualification for a new judge "is that this guy write the kind of constitution I like."