Thank you Babette--that worked! I'm a little embarrassed to have had this confusion. I thought the category showed one account if money was coming in and the other if money was going out. In any case I have cleared it up, and my balance in both accounts is now correct. Sorry if I had sent this to the wrong address--I had just replied to an earlier post. Thanks, Irma ----- Original Message ----- From: "GGCSQUICKSIG" <ggcsquicksig@xxxxxxxxxxx> To: "SIGLIST" <ggcsquicksig@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Sent: Wednesday, August 24, 2011 5:47 PM Subject: [ggcsquicksig] Transfer from one account to another - IN REPLY TO IRMA > IRMA messaged the following to me at another Email address: > Hi Babette, > > When I try to save a transaction, a transfer of $2000 from my savings to > my > checking account, I get the message: you are recording a transfer back > into > the same account. Do you want to continue? This is puzzling, because in > the category field in the savings register I have "savings". In the payee > field I have "to checking". > > Also, the total in my savings is already correct. If I successfully > record > this transfer from my savings account, then that account will not show the > correct total. > > Irma...if you transfer funds from Savings to Checking, you must put the > name of the CHECKING account in the Category field (with square > parentheses around it; The transaction would look something like this: > > Txf 8/24/2012 Transfer to Checking 200.00 > [Checking Account] > > In other words, if you are working in the Savings account register and > want to transfer money to checking account, the Catgory line will show the > name of the account TO WHICH you transfer the money. > > It sounds to me, from your description, that you were in the Savings > account register to transfer money and put in the name of the SAVINGS > account itself. Which is why you got the message about "transfer back > into the same account" > > After you complete and enter the transfer to checking correctly, the > Savings account should show a balance that reflects the transfer out of > Savings to Checking. I'm not sure what you mean about the Savings account > showing the correct balance. > > Hope this makes sense for you. > > Babette > GGCSQUICKSIG is the Email list for members of the Golden Gate Computer > Society's Quicken Special Interest Group. > > TO SEND A MESSAGE TO SIGLEADER BABETTE BLOCH "OFFLIST" - > Email to: ggcsquicksig@xxxxxxxxxxx > > TO UNSUBSCRIBE: Send an Email Message to: > ggcsquicksig-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx > In the "Subject": line, type "unsubscribe" (without the quotes). > > > > > > GGCSQUICKSIG is the Email list for members of the Golden Gate Computer Society's Quicken Special Interest Group. TO SEND A MESSAGE TO SIGLEADER BABETTE BLOCH "OFFLIST" - Email to: ggcsquicksig@xxxxxxxxxxx TO UNSUBSCRIBE: Send an Email Message to: ggcsquicksig-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx In the "Subject": line, type "unsubscribe" (without the quotes).