White-winged Scoter Bill Grigsby 5 Dec 2014 white patch.jpg White-winged Scoter Bill Grigsby 5 Dec 2014.jpg White-winged Scoter Bill Grigsby 5 Dec 2014 third photo.jpg Bill Grigsby, birding at Patrick Henry Lake, Sullivan County, TN Friday, 5 December 2014. He was able to capture several scoter images from the overlook at the dam looking towards the Hemlock Park housing area across the lake. Bill was satisfied that he had photographed a White-winged Scoter. As we looked at the images together and talked on the phone, we both became fairly certain that at least two different White-winged Scoters were photographed. The bird in the top image shows the white wing marking that is expected in many White-winged Scoters. The eye has only a slight white marking slanting upwards towards the back of the crown. The bird(s) in both the middle and bottom image shown here, have the white downward curved white marking behind the eye as expected in many White-winged Scoters and not in the other two scoter species. The perplexing aspects of taking these photos was that Bill did not think he was dealing with more than one bird while observing and capturing photo images. The suspicion was raised by studying these images which suggest at least two individuals. It seems evident from the head markings that these photos are of White-winged Scoters. At least one image shows the white in the wing. We do not think there is any concern that no white wing markings are apparent in two photos. We would like for you to post opinions on whether we have at least two different White-winged Scoters. We are inclined to believe that the bottom two photos above are of the same bird. Bill Grigsby, Kingsport, TN Wallace Coffey, Bristol, TN (composed this post) FOOTNOTE: Bill also had 6 Horned Grebes at the same location.