Good article.
In my opinion, protest should be practiced whenever there are
differing positions on any given subject. But when the protest
attempts to shut down the opposition during public forums, they are
no better than those they are protesting against.
Rather than spending time and energy attempting to block another from
expressing their opinion, we would be better served by organizing
efforts to assure free access to public forums by any who have a
position they want to share.
When I stumbled across Mike Savage some years back, I did not try to
have his rants blocked. Why drive people like this underground? I
spent time writing sponsors and asking them if they actually listened
to this man's rants. I wrote stations that carried the program,
asking them if they really wanted the sort of world this man was
promoting. And I quit listening to the negative, divisiveness being
spewed by Savage. I also suggested to both sponsors and stations that
they consider allowing time for other opinions. That never happened.
And I knew that those backing Savage would do all they could to block
any opposing discussion. Still, we need to practice what we preach.
If we want our position spread before the public, then we must defend
the right of those who disagree with us to have equal access. Of
course the current deck is stacked against those of us holding
positions contrary to those favored by our Corporate Masters. And we
do need to remember that even as they shout out that we are blocking
open discussion, they are controlling the Mass Media and the Laws in
many communities that are quietly blocking our freedom of expression.
But if we fall into the trap of countering by blocking their shills
from speaking, then we are no better than they.
Carl Jarvis
On 3/20/16, Roger Loran Bailey <dmarc-noreply@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
http://themilitant.com/2016/8012/801203.html
The Militant (logo)
Vol. 80/No. 12 March 28, 2016
(front page)
Socialist candidate gets hearing at Trump event
Militant/Dan Fein
Socialist Workers Party presidential candidate Alyson Kennedy, left,
talks with Jordan Strange about fight to win jobs and higher wages in
line for Donald Trump rally March 11 in Chicago.
BY DAN FEIN
CHICAGO — The organized disruption that forced the cancellation of
Republican candidate Donald Trump’s campaign rally here March 11 “was a
blow to free speech,” Socialist Workers Party candidate for president
Alyson Kennedy said. “Shutting down political expression is inevitably
turned against workers.”
Kennedy’s statement stands in stark contrast to the celebration of the
disruption on the left and among liberals who are increasingly shrill in
charging Trump with being the spearhead of a rising racist and fascist
movement. This could be “remembered as the dawn of the resistance,”
declared Washington Post columnist Eugene Robinson March 14.
Republican rivals Ted Cruz, Marco Rubio and John Kasich said they
opposed the disruptions, but argued they are Trump’s own fault,
suggesting his politics encourage violence.
None of this has derailed Trump’s campaign. He won four of the five
primary elections held March 15. Rubio, a senator from Florida,
suspended his campaign after losing to Trump in his home state by a wide
margin. Trump’s loss to Ohio Gov. Kasich in Ohio was expected. In all
these states Trump won a big vote from working people.
Far from representing a rising rightist movement, Trump gets a hearing
from workers and others who have been battered by the effects of years
of the world capitalist economic crisis, and who are looking for
something different from “establishment” politicians they know offer no
solutions.
It’s for similar reasons that Bernie Sanders continues to get a
substantial response. He got nearly half the vote in both Illinois and
Missouri, even as the media is declaring that Hillary Clinton has the
Democratic nomination virtually sewn up.
On the day of Trump’s rally, several thousand people demonstrated
outside while others entered the meeting room. Their goal was “for
Donald to take the stage and to completely interrupt him. The plan is to
shut Donald Trump all the way down,” Quovadis Green told the Associated
Press.
When a campaign staffer announced that due to safety concerns the rally
was canceled, those who organized to disrupt it erupted in cheers,
celebrating their victory over free speech. Some chanted “Bernie,
Bernie,” waving Sanders campaign signs. A few Trump supporters
confronted them. The big majority of those who had come to hear Trump
looked incredulous, upset he wouldn’t be speaking.
Fight for unions, jobs, wages
SWP candidate Kennedy had wide-ranging discussions with many workers and
young people who came hoping to hear Trump. She handed a campaign flyer
to Jordan Strange, an 18-year-old student from Naperville, as they
waited in line to get in. The Socialist Workers Party campaign “is part
of the struggles of working people,” she said, “including the fight for
$15 an hour and a union at McDonald’s and Walmart.”
“But McDonald’s is not a job for life, it’s a job for teenagers,”
Strange said. “Shouldn’t we concentrate on creating jobs instead?”
“We need both,” Kennedy replied. “Workers of all ages make low wages and
work part time or are unemployed. I took a leave from my job at a
Walmart to run in this election. We must fight to increase wages for
everyone, and also fight for a government-funded public works program to
create jobs, build schools and medical facilities, child care and
recreation centers, replace crumbling infrastructure and other things
working people need. And unions are essential, a first step to relying
on our own strength as a class.”
Fernando Garcia, an engineer at a local sheet metal factory, came to the
rally with his son Eric, a brake press operator at the same plant. “I
don’t know who I’ll vote for,” Fernando Garcia said. Like many there he
came to hear what Trump had to offer.
“Trump is not a politician. He is not bought off,” said Eric Garcia, who
was wearing a Trump campaign button.
Kennedy responded, “No Democrat, Republican or other capitalist
candidate will do anything about the attacks against the working class.
They talk about getting the ‘best deal’ to ensure profits keep flowing
to the U.S. capitalists.”
Fernando Garcia agreed. “Under Obama the border crossings are more
dangerous, resulting in many deaths” of immigrants, he said. “The
government has increased its border patrols.”
After the rally was cancelled, Kennedy saw the Garcias walking to their
car. “I don’t agree with Trump,” she told them, “but I don’t agree with
what happened tonight. Freedom of speech protects the right of workers
to speak out and organize.”
“This will just mean more votes for Trump,” Eric Garcia said.
The next day Kennedy campaigned door to door in the Chicago suburb of
Elmhurst. While much of the discussion was about Trump’s rally being
broken up, topics ranged from police brutality to Syria to the effects
on working people of the breakup of Yugoslavia.
Kennedy told Derek Dedman, a 20-year-old broker for a logistics company,
about the fight against the cold-blooded police killing of cattle
rancher Jack Yantis in Idaho, and showed him an article about it in the
Militant. “You hear about the police killing Blacks, but you never hear
about things like this,” Dedman said.
Police killings are a class question, Kennedy said. “The police protect
the interests of the wealthy by keeping workers in their place. But
because of the protests more cops are being charged. This shows we can
have an impact.”
Bojka Milanovich told Kennedy about the devastation her country, the
former Yugoslavia, faces today. Rival fragments of the disintegrating
Stalinist regime went to war in the 1990s, using nationalist demagogy to
grab territory and resources. Washington and its imperialist competitors
in Europe intervened militarily to advance their interests, adding to
the carnage.
“The Socialist Workers Party campaigned against the U.S. bombing assault
on your country,” Kennedy said, “and we oppose their intervention in
Syria today. They don’t care what happens to us or the Syrian workers,
they’re only protecting their imperial power in the Middle East.”
“We should get out of Syria,” Milanovich replied.
“I work in a hospital and see the abuse of workers, especially
immigrants,” she said. She made a $10 donation to the campaign and got a
copy of New International magazine with the article “Capitalism’s Long
Hot Winter Has Begun,” which describes the roots of the growing
capitalist conflicts and depression conditions that mark the world today.
Related articles:
Breakup of Trump rally sets back working class
Socialist Workers Party campaign statement
Socialist Workers Party launches state campaigns
Front page (for this issue) | Home | Text-version home
