GOP Debate Civil? Candidates Urged Torture, Child-Murder, Backing Bloody
Dictatorships
Published on
Friday, March 11, 2016
by
Informed Comment
GOP Debate Civil? Candidates Urged Torture, Child-Murder, Backing Bloody
Dictatorships
by
Juan Cole
Presidential candidates Marco Rubio, Donold Trump, Ted Cruz, and John Kasich
put on a display about what "civility" looks like in the today's Republican
Party. (Image: Fox News)
The headlines Friday about the GOP debate in Miami stressed how relatively
civil it was, with less name-calling and pissing matches among the remaining
candidates.
Those editors have a weird definition of civility.
So here is Marco Rubio:
"Let me give you an example of a Muslim for example, we ought to be standing
with, President el-Sisi of Egypt, a president of a Muslim country who is
targeting radical.
(BELL RINGS)
. Islamic terrorist. HEWITT: Senator Rubio.
CRUZ: He's hunting them down and stomping them."
Gen. Abdel Fattah al-Sisi took advantage of massive popular demonstrations
against Muslim Brotherhood leader and elected Egyptian president Mohammed
Morsi in summer of 2013 to make a brutal military coup. His soldiers used
unnecessary force to clear largely peaceful Muslim Brotherhood sit-ins,
killing hundreds with live ammunition. Al-Sisi then declared the former
ruling party, the Muslim Brotherhood, a terrorist organization and had his
corrupt judiciary sentence thousands of its members and leaders to death. In
fact, the Muslim Brotherhood renounced violence in the 1970s, and while I am
critical of the way it tried to rule Egypt in 2012-2013, I consider painting
it as a terrorist organization to be mere propaganda.
It is not only the Muslim Brotherhood that has suffered. The al-Sisi
military junta is now the world's second-biggest jailer of journalists for
doing their job. Peaceful civil society movements such as April 6 have been
forcibly disbanded and banned. Activists like Ahmad Maher, Mahinour al-Masri
and Alaa Abdel Fattah, heroes of the 2011 youth protests, are behind bars
being mistreated. Egypt's newspapers are assiduously self-censoring. The
country is a political and intellectual dead zone, with creepy secret police
spying on everyone who makes a peep.
Even foreign academic researchers are not safe, with a young Italian
academic at Cambridge, Giulio Regeni, having been kidnapped, tortured and
his burned body dumped in the desert. Observers say these are the hallmarks
of the secret police. The European Parliament has just urged the EU to cease
military cooperation with Egypt over the young man's murder:
So let's get this straight. The European Parliament is so disturbed at the
human rights situation that it has urged an EU cut off of military
cooperation with the Egypt of Gen. al-Sisi. But this is the regime that
Marco Rubio demands we admire and support.
Ironically, Rubio's family fled a similar right wing military dictatorship,
that of Fulgencio Batista, in Cuba in 1956. Batista abrogated the 1940
constitution and ruled ruthlessly, as al-Sisi does. To now have Rubio pimp
for a regime just like the one his family ran away from in the 1950s is
surely among the most disgusting displays in a political season full of
disgusting displays.
Then there was the nauseating display of far rightwing propaganda against
the poor Palestinians, many of whom were ethnically cleansed from their
homes in what is now Israel by Zionist forces in 1948 and again in 1967.
They have been deprived of their property and any claim to the rights of
citizenship in a state by ongoing Israeli theft and confined to cantons that
best resemble those imposed by Apartheid South Africa. All resistance they
offer to Israeli military rule and Israeli further encroachments on what
little they have left is assiduously branded as terrorism. Anyone who so
much as sympathizes with the plight of the world's largest group of
stateless people is branded an inciter to terrorism. Actual terrorism
(violence committed by an organized non-state group against innocent
civilians for political purposes) is always wrong, and some desperate
Palestinians have engaged in it (as have Israeli Jews). But people do have a
right to resist occupation, and you would think from the GOP debate that it
was the Palestinians who were in power and oppressing the Israelis rather
than the other way around.
Rubio again attacked Donald Trump for saying he wanted to restart a peace
process between Israel and the Palestinians, and that he would try to be
neutral, i.e. a good faith mediator:
"The policy Donald has outlined, I don't know if he realizes, is an
anti-Israeli policy. Maybe that's not your intent but here's why it is an
anti-Israeli policy. There is no peace deal possible with the Palestinians
at this moment. There just isn't."
Rubio is of course being told to say this by wealthy far-right Jewish donors
to his campaign. The idea that Palestinians should just be left under
military rule or under blockade, and should continue to have their territory
stolen from them by the Israelis, and that all this is their own fault, is
just obscurantism in the service of the Israeli expansionists on the far
right. It will one day explode on Israel with extremely unpleasant
consequences, and people like Rubio will bear a good deal of the blame.
Ted Cruz menaced us with a non-existent Iranian nuclear weapons program. Any
old demon will do.
Trump again defended his plans to torture prisoners and to murder their
women and children.
The candidates didn't talk so much last night about the four new wars they
had proposed last week.
The poor CNN moderators were often visibly uncomfortable with the bizarre
and bloodthirsty answers they got to their sober foreign policy questions.
C 2014 Juan Cole
Juan Cole
Skip to main content
//
. DONATE
. SIGN UP FOR NEWSLETTER
Friday, March 11, 2016
. Home
. World
. U.S.
. Canada
. Climate
. War & Peace
. Economy
. Rights
. Solutions
. Sanders vs. Clinton
. Supreme Court Obstructionism
. Apple vs. FBI
. Trump-mentum?
. Election 2016
. Water Crisis in Flint
GOP Debate Civil? Candidates Urged Torture, Child-Murder, Backing Bloody
Dictatorships
Published on
Friday, March 11, 2016
by
Informed Comment
GOP Debate Civil? Candidates Urged Torture, Child-Murder, Backing Bloody
Dictatorships
by
Juan Cole
. 4 Comments
.
. Presidential candidates Marco Rubio, Donold Trump, Ted Cruz, and
John Kasich put on a display about what "civility" looks like in the today's
Republican Party. (Image: Fox News)
. The headlines Friday about the GOP debate in Miami stressed how
relatively civil it was, with less name-calling and pissing matches among
the remaining candidates.
. Those editors have a weird definition of civility.
. So here is Marco Rubio:
. "Let me give you an example of a Muslim for example, we ought to be
standing with, President el-Sisi of Egypt, a president of a Muslim country
who is targeting radical.
(BELL RINGS)
. Islamic terrorist. HEWITT: Senator Rubio.
CRUZ: He's hunting them down and stomping them."
Gen. Abdel Fattah al-Sisi took advantage of massive popular demonstrations
against Muslim Brotherhood leader and elected Egyptian president Mohammed
Morsi in summer of 2013 to make a brutal military coup. His soldiers used
unnecessary force to clear largely peaceful Muslim Brotherhood sit-ins,
killing hundreds with live ammunition. Al-Sisi then declared the former
ruling party, the Muslim Brotherhood, a terrorist organization and had his
corrupt judiciary sentence thousands of its members and leaders to death. In
fact, the Muslim Brotherhood renounced violence in the 1970s, and while I am
critical of the way it tried to rule Egypt in 2012-2013, I consider painting
it as a terrorist organization to be mere propaganda.
It is not only the Muslim Brotherhood that has suffered. The al-Sisi
military junta is now the world's second-biggest jailer of journalists for
doing their job. Peaceful civil society movements such as April 6 have been
forcibly disbanded and banned. Activists like Ahmad Maher, Mahinour al-Masri
and Alaa Abdel Fattah, heroes of the 2011 youth protests, are behind bars
being mistreated. Egypt's newspapers are assiduously self-censoring. The
country is a political and intellectual dead zone, with creepy secret police
spying on everyone who makes a peep.
Even foreign academic researchers are not safe, with a young Italian
academic at Cambridge, Giulio Regeni, having been kidnapped, tortured and
his burned body dumped in the desert. Observers say these are the hallmarks
of the secret police. The European Parliament has just urged the EU to cease
military cooperation with Egypt over the young man's murder:
So let's get this straight. The European Parliament is so disturbed at the
human rights situation that it has urged an EU cut off of military
cooperation with the Egypt of Gen. al-Sisi. But this is the regime that
Marco Rubio demands we admire and support.
Ironically, Rubio's family fled a similar right wing military dictatorship,
that of Fulgencio Batista, in Cuba in 1956. Batista abrogated the 1940
constitution and ruled ruthlessly, as al-Sisi does. To now have Rubio pimp
for a regime just like the one his family ran away from in the 1950s is
surely among the most disgusting displays in a political season full of
disgusting displays.
Then there was the nauseating display of far rightwing propaganda against
the poor Palestinians, many of whom were ethnically cleansed from their
homes in what is now Israel by Zionist forces in 1948 and again in 1967.
They have been deprived of their property and any claim to the rights of
citizenship in a state by ongoing Israeli theft and confined to cantons that
best resemble those imposed by Apartheid South Africa. All resistance they
offer to Israeli military rule and Israeli further encroachments on what
little they have left is assiduously branded as terrorism. Anyone who so
much as sympathizes with the plight of the world's largest group of
stateless people is branded an inciter to terrorism. Actual terrorism
(violence committed by an organized non-state group against innocent
civilians for political purposes) is always wrong, and some desperate
Palestinians have engaged in it (as have Israeli Jews). But people do have a
right to resist occupation, and you would think from the GOP debate that it
was the Palestinians who were in power and oppressing the Israelis rather
than the other way around.
Rubio again attacked Donald Trump for saying he wanted to restart a peace
process between Israel and the Palestinians, and that he would try to be
neutral, i.e. a good faith mediator:
"The policy Donald has outlined, I don't know if he realizes, is an
anti-Israeli policy. Maybe that's not your intent but here's why it is an
anti-Israeli policy. There is no peace deal possible with the Palestinians
at this moment. There just isn't."
Rubio is of course being told to say this by wealthy far-right Jewish donors
to his campaign. The idea that Palestinians should just be left under
military rule or under blockade, and should continue to have their territory
stolen from them by the Israelis, and that all this is their own fault, is
just obscurantism in the service of the Israeli expansionists on the far
right. It will one day explode on Israel with extremely unpleasant
consequences, and people like Rubio will bear a good deal of the blame.
Ted Cruz menaced us with a non-existent Iranian nuclear weapons program. Any
old demon will do.
Trump again defended his plans to torture prisoners and to murder their
women and children.
The candidates didn't talk so much last night about the four new wars they
had proposed last week.
The poor CNN moderators were often visibly uncomfortable with the bizarre
and bloodthirsty answers they got to their sober foreign policy questions.
C 2014 Juan Cole
