Re: [ADM] Fortsat fejlmeldinger
- From: Oluf Engelstoft <oeng@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- To: astrolist@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Fri, 10 Dec 2010 11:32:12 +0100
I de efterhånden godt 25 år jeg har rumsteret lidt med datateknik til
husbehov har jeg nærmest anset det som en selvfølge - næsten en naturlov
- at Carriage Return og Line Feed (Vogn Retur og Linjeskift) - ASCII 13
og ASCII 10 - normalt hører sammen. De illustrerer bevægelsen af vognen
på en gammeldags skrivemaskine under skrivning, når der ikke er mere
plads på linjen.
Og Astrolist burde selv have fanget fejlen.
Men alting ændrer sig jo, så ........................
Oluf E.
---------------------------------
Frank Larsen wrote:
>Hej Torben (og Andre)
>Jeg har gravet lidt i fejlkoden.(som Flemming gjorde tidligere)
>
>Det handler om at modtagernes mailserver (i dette tilfælde TDC) afviser
>en mail fordi den ikke lever op til mailformaterings standarden angivet
>i RFC2822 section 2.2.
>Det handler om at alle datalinier i mailbody i SMTP kommunikation skal
>afsluttes med "CRLF" som er to ASCII tegn.
>ER de ikke det kan det KAN mailserveren retteligt afvise den.
>
>Jeg ser at fejlen er hidrørende den 6/11 og der gik der helt klart noget
>galt med et indlæg. Jeg skrev et kort indlæg "SV: NGC891 - ny version"
>kl 21.25 og da jeg selv modtog den astrolist fra var den bare ren
>volapyk -- ellere rettere tilfældige ASCII tegn. HVIS der i mailteksten
>har været et eller flere "CR" eller "LF" ville det fremprovokere fejlen.
>Det kan også være der er gået kuk i SMTP kommunikationen så headeren til
>mailen ikke er korrekt termineret.
>
>Men den burde være blevet afvist af astrolist's server i første omgang
>
>http://www.experts-exchange.com/Networking/Protocols/Application_Protoco
>ls/Email/SMTP/Q_25139390.html
>
>Denne angiver et lignende problem OGSÅ vedrørende mails til TDC kunder
>(mail.dk)
>http://www.webwiz.co.uk/forums/lone-cr-in-signature_topic28666.html
>
>kravet om sammenhørende CR/LF skyldes et sikkerhul i SMTP standarden som
>blev lukket for 5-6 år siden. Dengang betød det at op mod 1 ud 10 mails
>blev afvist da de færreste systemer sendte RFC2822 gyldige mails.
>
>Frank Larsen
>
>
>
>On 08/12/2010 23:09 "Torben Taustrup" <ttau@xxxxxxxxxx>
><ttau@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>
>
>
>>Hej folkens
>>
>>Som jeg tidligere har informeret om, så modtager jeg
>>fejlmeldinger på en del mailadresser.
>>Jeg er ikke i stand til at gøre noget ved dette problem, så
>>hvis en eller flere af nedenstående ejere af fejlbehæftede
>>mailadresser vil kontakte sin udbyder og informere om
>>fejlmeldingen, så er der måske en chance for, at problemet
>>kan blive rettet.
>>Det lader til at være et TDC-relateret problem.
>>
>>mvh
>>Torben
>>
>>
>>These users have returned errors and are being watched for
>>the list astrolist.
>>
>>Action Trans Fatal Error span User
>>----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><Reib@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><bogk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><bwinkler@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>NotSub 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><j-kartin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><lars_spatzek@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><fam.herbst@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><hans.slotsbo@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <jocl@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><spatzek@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><snf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><loevenholt@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><oeng@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><skaar@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><svaneeng@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><carfra@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <luh@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><novot@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><otlastro@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><sorenvh@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><aldrich@xxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <gemini@xxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><gunnar.tyrsted@xxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <oz2jb@xxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><bozz@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><hmkilde@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <cilla@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <mcma@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><vernols@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><friis@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><bjaras@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><astro.soren@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><senedergaard@xxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <fohbr@xxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <thorsbro@xxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><andersfb.holm@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><hrjo@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><ib_jansen@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><jtoft@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><krja@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><a.e.petersen@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <hansleth@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><jacobfriis@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <lwras@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><m.simonsen@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><pedermose@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <sap@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <vagnl@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <wega@xxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><kursch@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <lemon@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 jgp@xxxx
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 morten.brix@xxxx
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <vgydesen@xxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><frank123@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <preben@xxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><tandplejen@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <hugo@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><hieracium@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <cujla@xxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><hauge.pedersen@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <hjfo@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
>><wibniels@xxxxxxxxxxx>
>>550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
>>section
>>None 1 0 Nov 26 - Nov 26 <ca.str@xxxxxxxx>
>>conversation with
>>----------------------------------------------------------------------
>>
>>Key to actions:
>>None - No action taken, user left in watchfile.
>>Vacation - User's VACATION flag was set.
>>User reached 7 transient errors.
>>NOTE: This list is configured so users who
>>would
>>be set VACATION will be Unsub'd instead.
>>Unsub - User was unsubscribed.
>>User reached 2 fatal errors.
>>Expired - User has not had a bounce for 30 days,
>>watch has been expired.
>>Admin - User is administrator, no action taken.
>>Protect - User is flagged PROTECTED, no action taken.
>>Manual - There was no default action taken, handle
>>manually.
>>NotSub - Bounce message received for user not
>>subscribed
>>to this list. This is caused when someone
>>is
>>forwarding to another address and their
>>mailserver
>>reports the wrong one, or if someone has
>>been
>>unsubscribed from the list but not expired
>>from
>>the watches yet.
>>
>>
>>Torben Taustrup
>>TOC Observatory homepage
>><http://tocobs.org>
>>"Just do it"
>>
>>
>>
>
>
>
>
Other related posts:
