Looking through my bird book - Richard Taranto's bird indeed does not appear to be a goshawk. It does not have the distinctive white stripe on the head, and it does not have the red eye. In fact, this hawk's light grayish eye does not match anything I see in Sibley's. So I Googled images of various hawks. It does not seem to be a red-tailed hawk because it does not have enough red in it. Maybe it is a Cooper's hawk as in http://www.pbase.com/image/52570588 . This picture shows a lightish eye. I expect the lack of stripes in its upper breast is a photographic effect. So what kind of hawk is it? Jim Blowers _____ From: Adam D'Onofrio [mailto:bigadfromlb@xxxxxxxxxxx] Sent: Tuesday, 2011 April 26 10:54 To: jimvb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: Re: [va-richmond-general] FW: Northern Goshawk Jim. The bird in the photos appears to be a Red-tailed Hawk. Goshawks are very rare in the Richmond area. I guess your best chance to see one would be in fall migration. An immature goshawk would show streaking on the breast, not just on the belly like the bird in the photos. The belly streaking on a red-tail is often referred to as a "belly band" and is a good field mark for that species. A goshawk would also have a long tail, although you can't see the tail in the photos, and a prominent white eyebrow. Red-tails are also more likely to show up in residential neighborhoods and feast on squirrels, etc. Identifying perched hawks can be challenging. Enjoy the spring. Adam D'Onofrio Dinwiddie Co. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Jim Blowers" <jimvb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> To: "RAS Listserv" <va-richmond-general@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Sent: Tuesday, April 26, 2011 9:03:57 AM Subject: [va-richmond-general] FW: Northern Goshawk I got this from someone at my church (The First UU Church of Richmond - the one where we met last week). How common are goshawks around here? And I wonder if the bird should be named squirrelhawks instead. Jim Blowers _____ From: Richard Taranto [mailto:rktaranto@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] Sent: Monday, 2011 April 25 23:07 To: Jim Blowers Subject: Northern Goshawk Jim, I know you like birds. Here's an unusual one. What appears to be an immature northern goshawk was perched in a tree in the 2400 block of E. Grace St. in Church hill this evening. He had a squirrel in his talons. He/she sat there for over half an hour enjoying his dinner seemingly oblivious to spectators and local photographers. Apparently goshawks are rarely seen in this area.. Richard Taranto