[torontocbm] Hard Drive Solution

  • From: Derek Dresser <nostalgiacafe@xxxxxx>
  • To: "torontocbm@xxxxxxxxxxxxx" <torontocbm@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Tue, 06 Dec 2011 18:27:24 -0500

Hello everyone, I thought I would try to start a discussion about Hard 
Drive/mass storage solutions for the Commodore line of computers. 20 years ago 
we had few choices, there was the Lt. Col. or the CMD hard drives but not much 
else. 

Today we have lots of options, I would like to hear what others think is the 
best solution and why. I have recently purchased my first one but hope to add 
another choice in the future. 

Let me start off with a list of the options with a few comments - feel free to 
and any that I miss:

64 IDE http://www.ide64.org/ - one of the first mass storage solutions using 
inexpensive IDE devices along with CF reader as well. However it ties up the 
cartridge port and therefore is restrictive with software compatibility. 

1541 Ultimate 2 http://www.1541ultimate.net/ - this is the one I believe is the 
clear winner why? Full 1541 emulation including REU and cartridge emulation as 
well all in one small package
 
64 HDD http://www.64hdd.com/index_en.html - this was my favorite for a long 
while since it used the PC for all the grunt work. However the software costs 
are too high in opinion however costing more then stand alone hardware readers. 

uIEC/SD http://www.go4retro.com/category/hw/ - this one from Jim Brain is the 
one I currently have.  - this list could include any of the other CF/SD card 
readers 

CMD HD if the ever come back on the market. - this one was the holy grail for 
many years however I wonder if there is still a need for this one with the 
newer solid state options that are available. 

-Others??

My bias is a solution that takes up little space, is easy to use and is 
compatible with the widest range of software while requiring the least amount 
of modifications to the computer. 

Well there it is my first big post to this list I hope it opens up some lively 
debate. 

Derek

Other related posts: