[odamex-bug-reporter] [Bug 886] mouse vs keyboard binds
- From: odamex-bugtracker@xxxxxxxxxx
- To: odamex-bug-reporter@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Sun, 29 Jul 2012 18:21:52 +0000
http://odamex.net/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=886
--- Comment #4 from Amateur Spammer <ijgjgr@xxxxxxx> 2012-07-29 18:21:52 UTC ---
[2012.07.29, 21:46:26] JKist3 so its not just sr50
[2012.07.29, 21:46:32] JKist3 regular keys repeat actions
[2012.07.29, 21:46:35] JKist3 mice keys dont
[2012.07.29, 21:46:46] JKist3 mice keys should repeat as well
[2012.07.29, 21:47:00] HeX9109 you mean if you fire with mouse1 it doesnt
rapid fire?
[2012.07.29, 21:47:11] JKist3 no it does...
[2012.07.29, 21:47:14] JKist3 just do this
[2012.07.29, 21:47:29] JKist3 bind "k" "echo keyboard"
[2012.07.29, 21:47:44] JKist3 bind "mouse2" "echo mouse"
[2012.07.29, 21:47:49] JKist3 and u will see the issue
[2012.07.29, 21:47:57] Ralphis_ try using + on the command?
[2012.07.29, 21:47:59] Ralphis_ + and -
[2012.07.29, 21:48:01] JKist3 mouse and keyboard buttons behave
differently and this is not good
[2012.07.29, 21:48:24] JKist3 yeah ralphis thats not really the issue
[2012.07.29, 21:48:31] JKist3 i submitted a bug report on it last night
[2012.07.29, 21:48:57] mnbvzxc but why is it needed
[2012.07.29, 21:49:13] JKist3 http://odamex.net/bugs/show_bug.cgi?id=886
[2012.07.29, 21:49:28] JKist3 mnbvzxc do you actually code odamex at all
[2012.07.29, 21:50:37] mnbvzxc nope
[2012.07.29, 21:51:31] JKist3 well its important to have mouse and
keyboard keys behave the same so ppl dont get confused
[2012.07.29, 21:51:43] JKist3 liek if you bound something to mouse2
[2012.07.29, 21:51:53] JKist3 ud expect it to function the same way as if
u bound it to k right
[2012.07.29, 21:54:29] mnbvzxc yes, but the keyboard repeating is nod
handled in odamex code, odamex just requests the key to be repeated from SDL
[2012.07.29, 21:54:48] mnbvzxc and btw it was me who talked with you on
the bug
[2012.07.29, 21:56:45] mnbvzxc can be done of course, would be nice to
have, but u still haven't explained how it breaks sr50
[2012.07.29, 21:58:54] JKist3 it depends on how u bind it
[2012.07.29, 21:59:07] Ralphis_ why don't you show how you are trying to
bind it
[2012.07.29, 21:59:10] Ralphis_ on the bug
[2012.07.29, 21:59:17] -->| TheSpider
(~TheSpider@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx) has joined #odamex
[2012.07.29, 21:59:24] JKist3 Ralphis this is not for me u know...
[2012.07.29, 21:59:32] JKist3 hang on ill show u
[2012.07.29, 21:59:53] Ralphis_ well then have the person who you are
helping explain their bind
[2012.07.29, 21:59:59] JKist3 alias "+sr50l" "+strafe\;+left\; echo
+sr50l"
[2012.07.29, 22:00:00] JKist3 alias "+sr50r" "+strafe\;+right\; echo
+sr50r"
[2012.07.29, 22:00:01] JKist3 alias "-sr50l" "-strafe\;-left\; echo
-sr50l"
[2012.07.29, 22:00:02] JKist3 alias "-sr50r" "-strafe\;-right\; echo
-sr50r"
[2012.07.29, 22:00:21] JKist3 bind "mouse2" "+sr50r"
[2012.07.29, 22:00:28] JKist3 bind "s" "+sr50l"
[2012.07.29, 22:00:31] Ralphis_ you should put that in the bug (unless
you already have today)
[2012.07.29, 22:00:52] JKist3 no i didnt... but its really irrelevant...
i mean there are many other binds that could do something totally different
[2012.07.29, 22:00:54] JKist3 and still fuck up
[2012.07.29, 22:01:05] JKist3 it doesnt have to be sr50
[2012.07.29, 22:01:09] Ralphis_ except it gives the team a way to test
exactly your problem
[2012.07.29, 22:01:16] JKist3 sure
[2012.07.29, 22:01:20] Ralphis_ so it is useful
[2012.07.29, 22:01:39] Ralphis_ what is the echo for
[2012.07.29, 22:01:50] JKist3 so show you whats happening
[2012.07.29, 22:02:05] JKist3 has no in game behavior
[2012.07.29, 22:02:13] JKist3 just prints to the console which command is
being called
[2012.07.29, 22:02:28] JKist3 which is why i said
[2012.07.29, 22:02:29] JKist3 12:47 <JKist3> bind "k" "echo keyboard"
[2012.07.29, 22:02:30] JKist3 12:47 <JKist3> bind "mouse2" "echo
mouse"
[2012.07.29, 22:02:39] JKist3 that will show u the problem clearly
[2012.07.29, 22:02:46] JKist3 if u just test that out in a game
[2012.07.29, 22:03:19] mnbvzxc aha, so when you want to switch from left
sr50 to right, and first press the mouse button, then release "s", it doesn't
work?
[2012.07.29, 22:03:41] JKist3 yeah it starts turning u in a circle
[2012.07.29, 22:03:51] mnbvzxc i have an idea
[2012.07.29, 22:04:18] Ralphis_ is this even something that can be fixed
prior to sending the input to sdl
[2012.07.29, 22:04:33] JKist3 i have no clue...
[2012.07.29, 22:04:42] JKist3 all i know is it u hold down a keyboard key
[2012.07.29, 22:04:48] JKist3 the action gets sent over and over and over
again
[2012.07.29, 22:04:53] JKist3 with a mouse it only gets sent once
[2012.07.29, 22:05:20] mnbvzxc er, ralphis. Input is what odamex *gets*
from sdl
[2012.07.29, 22:05:23] JKist3 this bind works on zdaemon.... but not on
odamex bc of this behavior
[2012.07.29, 22:05:42] mnbvzxc and as I said, I have an idea
[2012.07.29, 22:05:45] mnbvzxc let me try
[2012.07.29, 22:07:36] Ralphis_ that's what I meant
[2012.07.29, 22:07:45] Ralphis_ I'm off my rocker atm
[2012.07.29, 22:09:02] JKist3 is there any reason why mouse commands cant
be repeated?
[2012.07.29, 22:09:12] JKist3 you had submitted the original bug for the
keyboard repeating ralphis
[2012.07.29, 22:09:55] Ralphis_ If there is a reason why it couldn't be
repeated, my gut tells me it would be an sdl limitation
[2012.07.29, 22:10:06] Ralphis_ but I don't have the technical background
to be able to answer that off the top of my head
[2012.07.29, 22:10:15] JKist3 yeah
[2012.07.29, 22:10:22] JKist3 hpefully its just an easy fix
[2012.07.29, 22:19:25] |<-- JohnZombie has left quakenet (Quit: Quitting)
sorry for the badly formatted log
--
Configure bugmail: http://odamex.net/bugs/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug.
Other related posts:
