Hi Graeme,
Graeme Gill wrote:
No, I don't think so, I think it is pretty similar. I get the impression
that this behaviour is not typical, and may be a result of the particular
device characteristic, but haven't run any tests to confirm this impression.
I've got a small (126-patch) testcase, which is attached.
The command I used is: profile -v -c3 -d0 -S sRGB\ Color\ Space\ Profile.icm R300_7DayShop_20050829
The difference between the two profiles once they're generated is minimal.
All the best, -- Alastair M. Robinson
CTI3 DESCRIPTOR Argyll Calibration Target chart information 3 ORIGINATOR Argyll printread CREATED Sat Aug 06 15:15:34 2005 KEYWORD DEVICE_CLASS DEVICE_CLASS OUTPUT KEYWORD MULTI_DIM_STEPS MULTI_DIM_STEPS 2 KEYWORD COLOR_REP COLOR_REP RGB_XYZ NUMBER_OF_FIELDS 7 BEGIN_DATA_FORMAT SAMPLE_ID RGB_R RGB_G RGB_B XYZ_X XYZ_Y XYZ_Z END_DATA_FORMAT NUMBER_OF_SETS 126 BEGIN_DATA 1 0 0 0 0.423718 0.413443 0.488655 2 100 49.933 13.295 46.3871 41.9245 5.36026 3 66.022 83.481 59.554 47.4137 55.7781 52.2377 4 70.586 51.024 48.7 40.1991 39.497 33.9375 5 100 0 0 26.4806 13.7958 4.21308 6 0 100 0 2.42194 6.66857 4.17734 7 100 100 0 58.6113 63.2873 2.76434 8 0 0 100 3.46311 1.98368 13.6133 9 100 0 100 27.4031 12.3478 16.6081 10 0 100 100 9.90403 12.0819 50.778 11 100 100 100 75.7485 79.3286 91.1022 12 52.101 52.964 49.324 31.9241 34.3506 37.4057 13 6.236 34.717 50.607 4.85043 5.58864 22.0967 14 41.382 9.4563 69.24 12.0358 6.27884 19.7205 15 28.998 50.355 92.55 19.83 20.5569 58.9925 16 52.924 24.71 9.6916 17.7524 13.7664 3.37155 17 26.086 91.735 52.327 17.3995 28.5806 37.6482 18 94.58 26.849 51.21 38.4781 26.1463 23.8697 19 49.123 71.118 9.1691 25.7363 34.6062 5.07129 20 81.443 51.939 100 51.9915 44.7535 72.36 21 89.092 82.015 51.712 59.0234 64.2706 44.8112 22 0 0 0 0.409407 0.394945 0.477903 23 48.113 92.849 89.585 41.4595 50.4295 78.5238 24 4.647 48.074 0.32706 2.39504 5.32883 4.17725 25 34.038 0 39.479 6.39751 3.52109 7.47489 26 2.3359 68.384 80.036 8.54971 10.3891 42.9354 27 63.076 99.854 39.221 43.0348 57.2987 29.5305 28 82.592 2.1757 25.718 21.792 11.0742 3.83357 29 31.759 68.755 36.214 17.0265 26.7762 21.6634 30 9.6568 8.5164 68.711 3.59967 1.94931 15.3312 31 51.056 31.391 91.126 26.7662 19.9068 48.9167 32 0.18603 32.278 83.575 5.71419 4.48994 29.3987 33 0 0 0 0.407682 0.385489 0.485206 34 4.0029 86.827 33.915 4.49616 11.0088 15.5655 35 64.443 1.426 72.829 17.5776 8.3707 13.8626 36 30.15 32.092 61.947 13.7328 12.3851 33.9389 37 90.004 65.715 68.813 57.7079 55.9452 58.6756 38 23.186 99.847 24.44 11.2247 24.138 12.4122 39 36.113 67.233 71.905 26.8051 32.1111 58.5298 40 71.134 36.399 33.511 32.478 28.0835 15.9261 41 30.306 23.056 22.319 7.65819 7.26681 6.69443 42 80.746 71.444 42.065 49.7786 54.231 31.3596 43 66.032 7.264 95.178 21.5945 10.4245 24.326 44 96.444 34.629 92.408 48.4597 34.1489 54.8139 45 0.57701 9.6284 37.936 2.35105 1.81618 9.42809 46 71.486 28.375 67.28 33.9614 23.7528 37.9103 47 83.622 73.77 0 45.1975 47.4455 2.78742 48 50.228 43.798 21.966 23.4449 25.3289 9.8195 49 24.459 89.282 85.43 21.4546 28.9407 65.0351 50 86.217 27.065 11.857 31.9105 22.6467 3.47705 51 32.017 7.3053 3.3407 5.10739 3.63257 2.94531 52 100 70.093 83.154 65.0469 61.9537 71.1247 53 20.466 78.453 7.5808 7.41587 16.5485 4.22713 54 48.802 75.016 33.72 29.7175 40.5231 21.7043 55 4.1764 93.554 66.867 8.58551 13.6242 39.0148 56 56.801 60.977 90.605 40.9178 41.6839 71.5141 57 33.658 7.3399 91.34 9.26049 4.4163 21.6064 58 3.4328 63.923 96.172 9.67325 10.8946 48.6791 59 89.054 99.278 35.79 58.2683 69.1004 27.9177 60 65.738 94.936 11.689 39.9945 52.15 6.67667 61 94.539 19.792 23.503 32.6958 21.0083 6.48609 62 52.929 17.897 48.151 19.3766 12.3665 18.2763 63 88.861 94.968 67.497 64.4577 71.3477 63.6583 64 67.606 6.6232 3.2712 18.0101 10.1856 3.01619 65 67.066 48.304 0 30.3005 29.1971 2.94672 66 76.603 83.649 92.759 59.3299 62.5895 82.4925 67 18.137 52.855 68.019 12.4564 15.5557 44.6625 68 89.616 0.56394 45.613 23.8077 11.6274 7.05659 69 32.963 38.65 45.517 15.7201 16.6972 27.8061 70 75.668 23.179 95.769 34.6014 21.901 44.541 71 29.691 45.363 0 9.1336 12.8938 3.09879 72 100 74.02 18.79 54.8197 57.8638 10.7626 73 94.839 51.851 39.77 49.3818 46.1061 25.8512 74 27.588 79.317 97.366 23.5925 29.6713 71.0098 75 17.103 34.784 100 11.0161 9.50305 45.3511 76 12.928 26.458 14.176 2.31163 3.75776 3.78586 77 50.499 100 71.216 40.9171 53.4316 63.2971 78 55.468 9.6854 22.347 15.113 8.91575 4.56035 79 53.73 37.796 72.47 30.2297 25.5425 47.1187 80 19.577 12.836 47.685 4.68761 3.17382 14.228 81 35.761 98.193 11.579 18.9191 32.6958 6.16426 82 91.665 5.2709 74.438 27.9961 13.466 18.4765 83 73.296 62.794 19.086 40.092 44.3151 9.65661 84 12.912 18.641 85.384 6.38314 3.95108 27.771 85 6.6747 44.532 34.139 4.11323 7.42716 15.4833 86 32.448 74.133 60.224 22.9881 31.0624 48.1231 87 6.45 71.719 17.047 3.36406 9.63194 7.07596 88 0 0 0 0.404531 0.381533 0.501985 89 17.662 6.2798 17.429 1.55262 1.19081 2.10293 90 76.177 94.408 91.282 61.1821 67.2942 84.0658 91 65.765 67.892 72.272 47.3866 49.6002 65.1017 92 67.677 10.204 47.319 21.6274 11.7923 12.6014 93 8.3695 63.825 52.495 7.52717 12.3927 30.9725 94 82.799 89.331 22.116 50.8951 60.5348 13.8802 95 81.747 41.569 81.151 46.6643 37.4248 56.6488 96 94.1 38.356 68.596 47.5878 36.9981 44.5875 97 49.542 86.044 40.356 33.2039 46.1194 29.7464 98 23.786 37.832 81.016 13.1018 12.5341 44.9475 99 28.561 58.373 20.853 11.8141 19.9715 9.91435 100 4.8 6.3 5.8 0.643106 0.669367 0.905232 101 9.6 9.6 9.6 0.820259 0.830414 1.12895 102 14.4 16.4 14.4 1.75772 1.98959 2.39891 103 21.7 19.2 22.2 4.49074 4.43279 6.05698 104 27 26.5 24 7.43995 7.87515 8.42184 105 28.8 28.8 30.8 9.50999 9.79637 13.6597 106 37.1 33.6 33.6 16.0094 16.2208 18.1862 107 38.4 40.9 40.4 19.3442 20.7382 25.7228 108 43.2 43.2 43.2 23.7665 24.7814 29.461 109 50 48 50.5 29.91 30.5824 38.6288 110 54.8 53.8 52.8 34.1878 36.0357 42.4248 111 57.6 57.6 60.6 38.427 40.0105 51.6091 112 64.4 62.4 62.4 43.7232 45.3772 54.6425 113 67.2 69.7 70.2 48.758 51.0424 64.0291 114 72 72 72 52.3918 54.4418 66.6438 115 78.8 76.8 78.3 58.0785 59.8248 72.7866 116 83.6 84.1 81.6 62.799 65.6499 76.7844 117 86.4 86.4 89.9 66.82 69.4521 84.1478 118 94.2 91.2 91.2 70.1199 72.7493 84.1719 119 96 96.7 96.7 73.0126 76.6777 88.8948 120 80 60 55 49.3972 49.3759 44.0712 121 71 40 38 34.9169 31.5199 21.415 122 95 82 78 66.462 67.8653 71.7388 123 84 60 59 52.0077 50.6705 48.3864 124 74 45 50 40.5622 37.0581 34.2253 125 95 82 81 67.1894 68.3194 74.5995 126 84 61 72 55.3172 52.5956 61.6083 END_DATA