Thanks for the reply, My brother is a very good mechanic but not a VW mechanic; I'm not a mechanic but I have owned several VWs in my time and have some (not a lot) experience with the quirkiness of the breed. He was very concerned that the shaft was a little lose, he said "If this was a ford Transmission I'd be very worried and would recommend we fix this." I told him that it has always been this way, even before it had been rebuilt and as far back as I could remember my past VWs were the same. I told him just to be safe that I would ask the group. On another subject, In order to replace the main shaft oil seal we had to remove the throw-out bearing. The spring clips that hold the bearing in place had a fine piece of wire strapping them to the throw-out bearing leaver. Is this necessary, just good practice, wouldn't bother? I'm not sure but I think Lyle Cherry did this when he rebuilt my engine. ----- Original Message ----- From: "Mark Sawyer" <mechmark@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> To: <tcb@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> Sent: Wednesday, October 27, 2004 9:28 PM Subject: [tcb] Re: Main Shaft >I agree with sammy, there should be some play in the input shaft. > > > Sammie Smith <slsmith@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > Fred: > My experience is that it has lots of play. > > At 04:24 PM 10/27/2004, you wrote: >>Hay everyone, >>I'm in the middle of replacing the seal around the main driveshaft as it >>exits the transmission. I have a question, Should the driveshaft be >>absoultly stiff or does it tend to have a little movement? > > > > > >