Geary of course doesn’t really mean “Who gives a flying fuck why the Civil War was fought?” Having lived most of his life in the South he knows perfectly well that huge numbers of Southerners are still interested in the Civil War. Equal numbers of Northerners are as well. I once interfaced with a civilian working at Wright Patterson Air Force Base in Ohio. He once told me he wouldn’t be available for a while inasmuch as he was taking leave to participation in a battle re-enactment. I questioned him in amazement as he described to me his uniform and the other things he’d carry about with him and do during that reenactment. I don’t have the impression that blood is shed during these reenactment outings, except accidentally as when someone forgets to remove his rifle-rod from his muzzle loader during target practice but Southerners dress up as Confederate soldiers and Northerners dress up as Union soldiers. Here in California we have an American Civil War Society which does reenactments when everyone walks about in Civil War garb looking cool: See <http://www.acws.net/units.htm> http://www.acws.net/units.htm I don’t know how sides are chosen. So what does Geary really mean? I invariably guess wrong but perhaps Speranza can help us out a little more. Speculating about what Geary means is one of his favorite hobbies. Lawrence On Fri, Jun 8, 2012 at 2:27 AM, <Jlsperanza@xxxxxxx> wrote: In a message dated 6/7/2012 4:08:41 A.M. UTC-02, jejunejesuit.geary2@xxxxxxxxx writes: Who gives a flying fuck why the Civil War was fought? Note that the question is rhetoric, seing that L. Helm is sharing with the list his interpretation, in counterfactive terms, of why and how the Civil War was fought. Plus, what does _flying_ to do with it? Cheers, Speranza