[haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog?
- From: David McPaul <dlmcpaul@xxxxxxxxx>
- To: haiku@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Tue, 16 Jun 2009 11:18:20 +1000
2009/6/16 Ryan Leavengood <leavengood@xxxxxxxxx>: > When you change resolutions in the Screen preference application, the > "Keep" button is the default button for the "Do you wish to keep these > settings?" dialog. Since this dialog is primarily for the case when an > unsupported resolution is selected I wonder if the "Undo" button > should be the default. In the case of a garbled screen I could imagine > someone hitting Enter in desperation, which would keep the bad > resolution. Of course the Esc key will dismiss the dialog and undo the > changes, but I'm not sure if that would be everyone's first instinct. > > So I am thinking it might make sense to make Undo the default button. > Now that makes this panel slightly more annoying in the normal case > when everything is fine (you can't just hit enter to dismiss it and > keep the new settings), but I think that is a reasonable compromise to > avoid trapping users in a bad resolution. > > I figured I would ask before making such a change. > > Thoughts? Do we have the timout where it automatically reverts if no input is selected? I think Undo should be the default anyway since it is one of those situations where a positive action could be harmfull. -- Cheers David
- Follow-Ups:
- References:
Other related posts:
- » [haiku] Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Ryan Leavengood
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - David McPaul
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Ryan Leavengood
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Axel Dörfler
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - DarkWyrm
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Stephan Assmus
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Humdinger
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Matt Madia
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Rene Gollent
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Humdinger
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Urias McCullough
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Gerald Zajac
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Axel Dörfler
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Joseph Prostko
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Urias McCullough
- » [haiku] Re: Screen preferences usability question: default button for keep settings dialog? - Axel Dörfler