https://www.wsws.org/en/articles/2015/10/24/arge-o24.html
The Argentine general elections and the Workers’ Left Front
By Rafael Azul
24 October 2015
Argentines will vote for president and the legislature this Sunday,
October 25. The election takes place in the context of a collapsing
social safety net; political, economic, and inflationary crises;
increasing unemployment and a looming attack on basic medical and
welfare institutions.
In an article published last Sunday, the Financial Times argued that the
Argentine economy is at a turning point. A slump in commodity prices is
pummeling Brazil and is beginning to affect Argentina. In addition, US
vulture funds suing for payment of $1.3 billion left over from the
2001-2002 Argentine debt crisis have locked Argentina out of Wall Street
financial markets.
The leading contenders to succeed president Cristina Fernandez de
Kirchner (restricted under Argentine law to two consecutive four-year
terms) are Daniel Scioli (of the ruling Peronist faction “Front for
Victory,” FPV), Buenos Aires Mayor Mauricio Macri (Republican Proposal),
and Sergio Massa (Renewal Front, Peronist). All are running on
pro-business programs to attract foreign investment, settle with the
vulture funds at the expense of workers and gut energy subsidies and
other social programs.
The three main candidates represent factions of the bourgeois
establishment. In the byzantine structure of Argentine politics, there
have been eight decades of alternating governments between corporatist
Peronism, the traditional bourgeois Radical Party, and the military,
with each change in regime assisted by the Peronist trade union
bureaucracy, Stalinism and various pseudo-left organizations, which have
worked to block an independent movement of the working class.
The ruling “Kirchnerista” wing of the Peronist movement, the FPV, is
spent, discredited and moving to the right. Scioli represents the FPV’s
most neo-liberal wing. He is banking on increasing oil and gas
production in an effort to resolve Argentina’s economic stagnation and
increase government resources. To do that, he must settle with Wall
Street and, with the aid of the Peronist union bureaucracy, discipline
the working class to accept austerity measures.
Under these conditions, the Argentine pseudo-left is seeking to lend its
services to the ruling class.
Among the political parties competing in this Sunday’s vote is the
Workers’ Left Front (Frente de Izquierda y de los Trabajadores, FIT),
which is running over 1,500 candidates in provincial and national
elections. The FIT is an electoral coalition formed in 2011 by various
pseudo-left organizations that claim to be Trotskyist. Its main
components are the Socialist Workers Party (Partido de Trabajadores por
el Socialismo, PTS), the Workers Party (Partido Obrero, PO), and the
Socialist Left (Izquierda Socialista, IS). Its presidential candidates,
Nicolás del Caño and Myriam Bregman, were chosen in national state-run
primaries held on August 9. Both are PTS members.
Its left rhetoric notwithstanding, the FIT does not represent a
revolutionary socialist alternative for the working class. It has come
forward to fill the political space left by the lurch to the right of
the ruling Peronist party. As has been the case with such parties so
many times throughout Latin American history, it seeks to subordinate
the interests of the working class to the requirements of the national
bourgeoisie.
The organizations from which the current FIT members descended were
complicit in politically disarming the Argentine working class over the
latter half of the 20th century, fostering illusions in Perón, then in
Fidel Castro, followed by the Sandinistas and Stalinism. Many of their
young working class followers were among the 30,000 tortured and
murdered under the military junta.
The PTS and IS originated in the breakup of the Movement Towards
Socialism (Movimiento al Socialismo, MAS), in the aftermath of the death
of its leader, Nahuel Moreno in 1987. Moreno, a one-time supporter of
the Fourth International who broke with Trotskyism and internationalism
in the 1960s, had been a proponent of subordinating the independent
movement of the working class to the bourgeois and petty-bourgeois
forces: Peronism in the 1950s, Castroism in the 1960s, Social Democracy
in the 1970s and Stalinism in the 1980s.
The PO, also a nationalist tendency, had its origins in Silvio
Frondizi’s Movement of the Revolutionary Left (Movimiento de Izquierda
Revolucionaria, MIR-Praxis), which emerged in the 1960s, then under the
name of Política Obrera. Frondizi, a radical sociologist and brother of
Argentina’s Radical Party President Arturo Frondizi, was murdered by the
“Triple A” death squads in 1974. He had been a strong supporter of the
Cuban Revolution and a proponent of “Guevaraism” as an “Indoamerican”
form of Marxism.
Under the influence of the Yugoslavian, Algerian and Cuban revolutions
(particularly the latter in the 1960s) Politica Obrera, though critical
of Moreno, evolved along the same lines as MAS and the PTS,
subordinating the interests of the working class to those of the radical
petty bourgeoisie. PO’s current leader, Jorge Altamira, is a master at
using the language of revolutionary socialism to justify the PO’s
opportunist alliances with pseudo-left parties in France, Italy, Greece
and elsewhere, as well as its membership in the FIT (which Altamira
defends as a “united front”).
The PO is formally allied to the Greek EEK (Workers Revolutionary Party)
of Savas Michael-Matsas. When the British Workers Revolutionary Party
split with the International Committee of the Fourth International in
1985, the EEK was the only section that supported WRP leader Gerry
Healy. Michael-Matsas refused any discussion with the other sections of
the ICFI, declaring that a “New era for the Fourth International” had
dawned, which quickly found expression in support for Mikhail
Gorbachev’s perestroika as the beginning of the “political revolution”
in the Soviet Union. Since then, Michael-Matsas has maneuvered between
Pasok, Syriza and the Stalinist KKE.
Relations between the PO and the EEK have been largely frozen since
2012, when the PO’s Altamira called for a “government of the left” in
Greece based on Syriza. This was contrary to the EEK’s own policy, which
was to provide Syriza with a “left” cover while seeking to unite with
the collection of Maoists and various pseudo-left groups in the Antarsya
coalition.
The PO’s attitude towards the events in Greece provides the clearest
insight into the intended role of the FIT in Argentina itself, which is
to seek a similar “government of the left,” i.e., a “left” government of
the Argentine bourgeoisie with the task of imposing the dictates of
international finance capital against the working class.
The FIT currently has three representatives in Argentina’s federal House
of Deputies, as well as representatives in some of the Argentine Provinces.
Its stated goal in the October ballot is to increase the number of
representatives in national and provincial legislatures. On Thursday, at
an event in Buenos Aires closing the campaign, del Caño called for a
vote for the FIT to “elect new legislators that will be the pivot of
every fight [of workers, women and youth].” Every pseudo-left grouping
around the world would agree with such an empty formula.
The FIT is part of an international phenomenon: parties and coalitions
that promote the interests of middle class layers whose privileges
derive from capitalism and financial parasitism.
FIT places particular emphasis on the demographics of its candidates:
youth, women and workers from the various struggles for which the PTS,
IS and PO have been cheerleaders (in auto, oil, the food industry, among
public employees, part-time workers, etc.). This is consistent with its
concentration on politics of sexual and other forms of identity
politics, the hallmark of pseudo-left parties the world over. Underlying
it is a perspective that rejects the essential and revolutionary role of
the working class in society and reduces the working class to just one
more identity group.
The FIT program is a lowest common denominator of reformist demands.
While calling for the independence of the trade unions, union democracy
and the expulsion of the bureaucracy, it provides no indication of a
revolutionary strategy for the conquest of power by the working class.
Lacking that, its demand for a workers government provides a big enough
umbrella to accommodate regimes led by the likes of Syriza in Greece,
Podemos in Spain, and many others, to manage the crisis for the banks,
regulate the class struggle and in the process subordinate the working
class to the interests of better off sections of the middle class.
Like Syriza, Podemos, the New Anti-Capitalist Party in France, the
German Left Party, the Italian Workers Communist Party and the Greek
EEK, the FIT functions as an instrument of the capitalist class. Their
role is to throw up political obstacles to the resolution of the crisis
of revolutionary leadership, advancing the illusion that the insoluble
crisis of world capitalism can be answered with a program of national
reforms.
Such politics pose a deadly danger under conditions in which imperialism
and the Argentine bourgeoisie are once again confronting an insoluble
economic crisis for which their ultimate answer is the return of a
brutal dictatorship to atomize the working class and destroy living
standards and democratic rights.
The building of revolutionary internationalist working class political
parties in Latin America involves an intransigent struggle against
formations such as the FIT and their pseudo-left components. The
decisive question in Argentina and internationally is the building of a
new independent revolutionary party of the working class based upon a
socialist and internationalist program. This requires the building of
sections of the International Committee of the Fourth International.
Share this article:
Facebook
Twitter
Digg
Reddit
Delicious
StumbleUpon
Blogger
E-Mail
Commenting Discussion Rules »
New Today
US deploys F-15s to Syria, targeting Russian jets
Turkey after the elections
UAW seeks to ram through Ford deal as results at GM show split vote
“Positive” US jobs report belied by mass layoffs
Russia halts flights to Egypt after air disaster
more articles »
Argentina
Argentine election goes to run-off in blow to ruling Peronist faction
The Argentine general elections and the Workers’ Left Front
Argentina charges US interference in crisis over prosecutor’s death
Political conflict between Argentinian president and intelligence
agencies intensifies
Cables document relations between Castro and Argentine junta
more articles »
Mehring Books
The Truth Behind the Bankruptcy of Detroit
undefined
By the Socialist Equality Party
Get Involved!
Donate to the WSWS
About the ICFI
Join the IYSSE
Join the SEP
Socialist Equality Parties United States Germany Australia United
Kingdom Sri Lanka Canada
Follow the WSWS
Facebook
Twitter
Youtube
RSS Feed
Daily Podcast
WSWS Newsletter
Listen to part one
Listen to part two
The political struggle against war and the tasks of the Socialist
Equality Party (Sri Lanka)
The IYSSE’s campaign against war and historical falsification at
Humboldt University
The return of German militarism and the tasks of the Partei für Soziale
Gleichheit
The Fight Against War and the Political Tasks of the Socialist Equality
Party
Capitalist breakdown and the drive to war
Seventy-five years since the outbreak of World War II
Oppose the Israeli invasion of Gaza
Who is responsible for the catastrophes in the Middle East?
One hundred years since Sarajevo
Australian imperialism and the Obama administration’s “pivot to Asia”
Does Washington want war with Russia?
More on imperialism and war »
Socialism and historical truth
--A lecture delivered by David North at the Leipzig Book Fair
The IYSSE’s campaign against war and historical falsification at
Humboldt University
Berlin IYSSE protests Professor Jörg Baberowski’s suppression of
democratic discussion at Humboldt University
Appearance of Robert Service in Berlin ends in fiasco
The philosophical and political foundations of historical falsification
Leon Trotsky and the defense of historical truth
Lecture by David North
More on Leon Trotsky and the defense of historical truth »
SEP/ICFI
Four-part series from Sri Lanka: The LSSP’s Great Betrayal
Resolutions of the SEP (US) Third National Congress
2014 International May Day Rally
Resolutions of the Second National Congress of the SEP (US)
Socialist Equality Party (Australia) holds Second National Congress
The Historical and International Foundations of the Socialist Equality
Party (Sri Lanka)
Socialist Equality Party (UK) holds First National Congress
The Historical and International Foundations of the Socialist Equality
Party (Britain)
The Historical Fondations of the Partei für Soziale Gleichheit (SEP Germany)
Report to the Second National Congress of the Socialist Equality Party
by David North
more ICFI documents »
Fund
DVD
Lectures and Reports
A tribute to Dave Hyland
US imperialism and the proxy war in Syria
Seventy-five years of the Fourth International
Twenty years since the dissolution of the USSR
The capitalist crisis and the radicalization of the working class in 2012
25 years since Keerthi Balasuriya’s death
South Asia’s foremost Marxist of the second half of the 20th century
by Wije Dias
The enduring significance of the life and work of Comrade Keerthi
Balasuriya
In Memory of Keerthi Balasuriya
by David North
more documents »
.
About the WSWS | Contact Us | Privacy Statement | Top of page
Copyright © 1998-2015 World Socialist Web Site - All rights res