Clinton Visits a Seattle High School, and Student Resentments Surface
Thursday, 07 April 2016 00:00 By Ifrah Abashir, Occupy.com | Op-Ed
Hillary Clinton, Democratic presidential hopeful, speaks during a campaign
appearance Tuesday night at Rainier Beach High School in Seattle, March 22,
2016. (David Ryder / The New York Times)
It was a typical Monday at Rainier Beach High School. Classes were quiet as
usual at the start of the school week. Most students, including myself, were
dragging our feet from class to class, counting down the minutes until 2:50
p.m.
Then, during third period, a classmate of mine shouted from the back of the
room, "Hillary Clinton is coming to Rainier Beach tomorrow!" Instantly, the
class swarmed to her, asking for her sources. At our school we are very
politically aware and have discussions about presidential candidates nearly
every week.
The news made us act as if we were two-year-olds force-fed several bottles
of energy drinks. After about five minutes of yelling and pushing and
begging for more info, we discovered that our classmate had received the
news through Twitter. We instantly went to several other teachers asking for
validation, but no one could confirm. They were all just as clueless as we
were. Eventually a teacher asked the front office, and learned that it was
true: Hillary was on her way.
Besides the administration, nobody in our school had been privy to this
knowledge until it was too late to act on it. We, as students, should have a
right to decide whether our school is used as a stage for a political
candidate, especially if a lot of the students and staff do not think that a
particular candidate has their best interests at heart.
At Rainier Beach, we share a genuine interest in politics, largely because
we have to. Being a school with over 90% students of color and more than 70%
on free and reduced lunch, most of the things being said in the political
world right now affect us directly.
For instance, Donald Trump has publicly insulted Mexicans, Muslims,
immigrants, and those who are less affluent. Essentially, he is insulting
nearly all of our student population. He has also proposed several policies
infringing on our rights as Americans which he threatens to implement if he
becomes president. This incites fear in our hearts and forces us to watch
the campaigns while praying that certain personalities do not get elected.
Which is why a lot of our students hold animosity towards Mrs. Clinton.
Ahlaam Ibraahim, a senior, said, "I don't trust her because of her policies
and how she's always switching up. Something in my gut says she isn't about
what she states she is. It's like she's putting on a show for us."
Another student, Naima Yusuf, said, "I'm still hung over her calling [gangs
of kids in urban areas] 'super predators' and then saying they needed to be
brought to heel. This was and is still super insulting to me."
Still another student said, "I'm not really cool with her foreign policies
and how she supports Israel indefinitely. The conflict in Palestine was a
problem caused by western interference and by continuing to support the
occupation, we are causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of
Palestinians."
On the subject of race, another said, "We are in a moment in time right now
where the conversations we are having about race and identity are becoming
prominent and necessary. I feel like Clinton doesn't do a good enough job of
stepping out of her comfort zone to address those problems. She's really
good at pointing fingers and acknowledging there is a problem, but not
describing solutions that are intersectional."
If so many of our students feel this way about Clinton, how do you expect
they felt knowing that she was coming to our school the next day? We felt
that using Rainier Beach over other high schools in Seattle was a strategic
PR stunt by the Clinton campaign, considering most of our students are young
people of color.
Yet despite all of our internal feelings and desire to act upon them, we got
the news so late that there was nothing we could do but attend the rally and
see what Hillary was about.
The next day, after school was over, we waited for hours to get into our own
gym for the rally. We were tired, coming off a full school day, and our
spirits were low because we felt like we were being sold for publicity
without our consent. To add to that, in line we had offensive comments
directed toward us. One woman approached us and said, "Can I take a photo
with you guys so I can show people that I'm not afraid of Muslims?"
Another man and woman were snickering behind us, talking mess about our
school and neighborhood. In that moment we felt like we did not belong
because we were some of the only people of color in that long line, which
wrapped three times around in the parking lot and onto the front of the
school. Can you imagine feeling like you don't belong in your own school?
After waiting for roughly three and a half hours, we realized there was a
priority line for other people to get in first. So we waited even longer for
them to get situated, then we finally made our way in and looked around.
People from Mrs. Clinton's campaign were picking out the few people of color
in attendance and asking them to stand in the bleachers behind Hillary so
the crowd would look more diverse then it really was. It looked as if most
people there had never stepped foot in the south end, let alone Rainier
Beach.
In Clinton's speech, given to students and staff, it was not about what she
said but rather what she did not say. She didn't mention what she would do
for schools like ours. She didn't talk about the school-to-prison pipeline.
She didn't talk about high incarceration rates. Rather, she talked about
holistic ideals she had for the country.
Exactly as our students feared, Mrs. Clinton had a lot of filler talk, but
not the hardcore conversations that are needed. She didn't even allow for a
question and answer session, and the only people that got to talk to her and
take pictures were those in the priority line.
This explains why a lot of our students and staff appreciate Bernie so much:
Sanders actually talks about things that matter to us. He has those
uncomfortable conversations because he knows they're needed. We appreciate
Bernie because he knows our political and economic system right now only
helps the rich get richer and the poor get poorer; that it only continues to
be punitive and inconsiderate. This explains why he won the Washington state
caucus on Mar. 26 by a sweeping majority.
You would have assumed that somebody from Hillary's campaign might have
informed her about our school before she chose to attend. They might have
informed her about how socially active we are. How we continue to fight to
achieve equity across our school district, the city and beyond. And how we
aren't afraid of calling things how we see them.
Maybe then she would have changed her speech to better address our concerns,
and possibly even shifted our minds to get our vote.
This piece was reprinted by Truthout with permission or license. It may not
be reproduced in any form without permission or license from the source.
IFRAH ABASHIR
Ifrah Abshir is a senior attending Rainier Beach High School. She was
featured in Gov. Jay Inslee's "State of the State" address. Inspiring young
girls to code, she addressed inequality in the computer science industry.
She's a newspaper editor and published writer.
RELATED STORIES
Clinton vs. Sanders: Who Do Progressives Choose?
By Amy Goodman, Democracy Now! | Video Report
Hillary Clinton Has Big Night; Media Move to Silence Bernie Sanders'
Campaign
By Amy Goodman, Democracy Now! | Video Report
Black Liberation: The Ghosts of the Past, the Potential of the Future
By Angela Y. Davis, Haymarket Books | Book Excerpt
________________________________________
Show Comments
Hide Comments
<a href="http://truthout.disqus.com/?url=ref";>View the discussion
thread.</a>
Error! Hyperlink reference not valid.
Clinton Visits a Seattle High School, and Student Resentments Surface
Thursday, 07 April 2016 00:00 By Ifrah Abashir, Occupy.com | Op-Ed
. font size Error! Hyperlink reference not valid. Error! Hyperlink
reference not valid.Error! Hyperlink reference not valid. Error! Hyperlink
reference not valid.
. Hillary Clinton, Democratic presidential hopeful, speaks during a
campaign appearance Tuesday night at Rainier Beach High School in Seattle,
March 22, 2016. (David Ryder / The New York Times)
. It was a typical Monday at Rainier Beach High School. Classes were
quiet as usual at the start of the school week. Most students, including
myself, were dragging our feet from class to class, counting down the
minutes until 2:50 p.m.
Then, during third period, a classmate of mine shouted from the back of the
room, "Hillary Clinton is coming to Rainier Beach tomorrow!" Instantly, the
class swarmed to her, asking for her sources. At our school we are very
politically aware and have discussions about presidential candidates nearly
every week.
The news made us act as if we were two-year-olds force-fed several bottles
of energy drinks. After about five minutes of yelling and pushing and
begging for more info, we discovered that our classmate had received the
news through Twitter. We instantly went to several other teachers asking for
validation, but no one could confirm. They were all just as clueless as we
were. Eventually a teacher asked the front office, and learned that it was
true: Hillary was on her way.
Besides the administration, nobody in our school had been privy to this
knowledge until it was too late to act on it. We, as students, should have a
right to decide whether our school is used as a stage for a political
candidate, especially if a lot of the students and staff do not think that a
particular candidate has their best interests at heart.
At Rainier Beach, we share a genuine interest in politics, largely because
we have to. Being a school with over 90% students of color and more than 70%
on free and reduced lunch, most of the things being said in the political
world right now affect us directly.
For instance, Donald Trump has publicly insulted Mexicans, Muslims,
immigrants, and those who are less affluent. Essentially, he is insulting
nearly all of our student population. He has also proposed several policies
infringing on our rights as Americans which he threatens to implement if he
becomes president. This incites fear in our hearts and forces us to watch
the campaigns while praying that certain personalities do not get elected.
Which is why a lot of our students hold animosity towards Mrs. Clinton.
Ahlaam Ibraahim, a senior, said, "I don't trust her because of her policies
and how she's always switching up. Something in my gut says she isn't about
what she states she is. It's like she's putting on a show for us."
Another student, Naima Yusuf, said, "I'm still hung over her calling [gangs
of kids in urban areas] 'super predators' and then saying they needed to be
brought to heel. This was and is still super insulting to me."
Still another student said, "I'm not really cool with her foreign policies
and how she supports Israel indefinitely. The conflict in Palestine was a
problem caused by western interference and by continuing to support the
occupation, we are causing the deaths of hundreds of thousands of
Palestinians."
On the subject of race, another said, "We are in a moment in time right now
where the conversations we are having about race and identity are becoming
prominent and necessary. I feel like Clinton doesn't do a good enough job of
stepping out of her comfort zone to address those problems. She's really
good at pointing fingers and acknowledging there is a problem, but not
describing solutions that are intersectional."
If so many of our students feel this way about Clinton, how do you expect
they felt knowing that she was coming to our school the next day? We felt
that using Rainier Beach over other high schools in Seattle was a strategic
PR stunt by the Clinton campaign, considering most of our students are young
people of color.
Yet despite all of our internal feelings and desire to act upon them, we got
the news so late that there was nothing we could do but attend the rally and
see what Hillary was about.
The next day, after school was over, we waited for hours to get into our own
gym for the rally. We were tired, coming off a full school day, and our
spirits were low because we felt like we were being sold for publicity
without our consent. To add to that, in line we had offensive comments
directed toward us. One woman approached us and said, "Can I take a photo
with you guys so I can show people that I'm not afraid of Muslims?"
Another man and woman were snickering behind us, talking mess about our
school and neighborhood. In that moment we felt like we did not belong
because we were some of the only people of color in that long line, which
wrapped three times around in the parking lot and onto the front of the
school. Can you imagine feeling like you don't belong in your own school?
After waiting for roughly three and a half hours, we realized there was a
priority line for other people to get in first. So we waited even longer for
them to get situated, then we finally made our way in and looked around.
People from Mrs. Clinton's campaign were picking out the few people of color
in attendance and asking them to stand in the bleachers behind Hillary so
the crowd would look more diverse then it really was. It looked as if most
people there had never stepped foot in the south end, let alone Rainier
Beach.
In Clinton's speech, given to students and staff, it was not about what she
said but rather what she did not say. She didn't mention what she would do
for schools like ours. She didn't talk about the school-to-prison pipeline.
She didn't talk about high incarceration rates. Rather, she talked about
holistic ideals she had for the country.
Exactly as our students feared, Mrs. Clinton had a lot of filler talk, but
not the hardcore conversations that are needed. She didn't even allow for a
question and answer session, and the only people that got to talk to her and
take pictures were those in the priority line.
This explains why a lot of our students and staff appreciate Bernie so much:
Sanders actually talks about things that matter to us. He has those
uncomfortable conversations because he knows they're needed. We appreciate
Bernie because he knows our political and economic system right now only
helps the rich get richer and the poor get poorer; that it only continues to
be punitive and inconsiderate. This explains why he won the Washington state
caucus on Mar. 26 by a sweeping majority.
You would have assumed that somebody from Hillary's campaign might have
informed her about our school before she chose to attend. They might have
informed her about how socially active we are. How we continue to fight to
achieve equity across our school district, the city and beyond. And how we
aren't afraid of calling things how we see them.
Maybe then she would have changed her speech to better address our concerns,
and possibly even shifted our minds to get our vote.
This piece was reprinted by Truthout with permission or license. It may not
be reproduced in any form without permission or license from the source.
Ifrah Abashir
Ifrah Abshir is a senior attending Rainier Beach High School. She was
featured in Gov. Jay Inslee's "State of the State" address. Inspiring young
girls to code, she addressed inequality in the computer science industry.
She's a newspaper editor and published writer.
Related Stories
Clinton vs. Sanders: Who Do Progressives Choose?
By Amy Goodman, Democracy Now! | Video ReportHillary Clinton Has Big Night;
Media Move to Silence Bernie Sanders' Campaign
By Amy Goodman, Democracy Now! | Video ReportBlack Liberation: The Ghosts of
the Past, the Potential of the Future
By Angela Y. Davis, Haymarket Books | Book Excerpt
Show Comments
