Re: [ADM] Fortsat fejlmeldinger
- From: "Frank Larsen" <frank@xxxxxxxxxx>
- To: astrolist@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Fri, 10 Dec 2010 09:20:24 +0100
Hej Torben (og Andre)
Jeg har gravet lidt i fejlkoden.(som Flemming gjorde tidligere)
Det handler om at modtagernes mailserver (i dette tilfælde TDC) afviser
en mail fordi den ikke lever op til mailformaterings standarden angivet
i RFC2822 section 2.2.
Det handler om at alle datalinier i mailbody i SMTP kommunikation skal
afsluttes med "CRLF" som er to ASCII tegn.
ER de ikke det kan det KAN mailserveren retteligt afvise den.
Jeg ser at fejlen er hidrørende den 6/11 og der gik der helt klart noget
galt med et indlæg. Jeg skrev et kort indlæg "SV: NGC891 - ny version"
kl 21.25 og da jeg selv modtog den astrolist fra var den bare ren
volapyk -- ellere rettere tilfældige ASCII tegn. HVIS der i mailteksten
har været et eller flere "CR" eller "LF" ville det fremprovokere fejlen.
Det kan også være der er gået kuk i SMTP kommunikationen så headeren til
mailen ikke er korrekt termineret.
Men den burde være blevet afvist af astrolist's server i første omgang
http://www.experts-exchange.com/Networking/Protocols/Application_Protoco
ls/Email/SMTP/Q_25139390.html
Denne angiver et lignende problem OGSÅ vedrørende mails til TDC kunder
(mail.dk)
http://www.webwiz.co.uk/forums/lone-cr-in-signature_topic28666.html
kravet om sammenhørende CR/LF skyldes et sikkerhul i SMTP standarden som
blev lukket for 5-6 år siden. Dengang betød det at op mod 1 ud 10 mails
blev afvist da de færreste systemer sendte RFC2822 gyldige mails.
Frank Larsen
On 08/12/2010 23:09 "Torben Taustrup" <ttau@xxxxxxxxxx>
<ttau@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> Hej folkens
>
> Som jeg tidligere har informeret om, så modtager jeg
> fejlmeldinger på en del mailadresser.
> Jeg er ikke i stand til at gøre noget ved dette problem, så
> hvis en eller flere af nedenstående ejere af fejlbehæftede
> mailadresser vil kontakte sin udbyder og informere om
> fejlmeldingen, så er der måske en chance for, at problemet
> kan blive rettet.
> Det lader til at være et TDC-relateret problem.
>
> mvh
> Torben
>
>
> These users have returned errors and are being watched for
> the list astrolist.
>
> Action Trans Fatal Error span User
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <Reib@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <bogk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <bwinkler@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> NotSub 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <j-kartin@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <lars_spatzek@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <fam.herbst@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <hans.slotsbo@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <jocl@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <spatzek@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <snf@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <loevenholt@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <oeng@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <skaar@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <svaneeng@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <carfra@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <luh@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <novot@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <otlastro@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <sorenvh@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <aldrich@xxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <gemini@xxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <gunnar.tyrsted@xxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <oz2jb@xxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <bozz@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <hmkilde@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <cilla@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <mcma@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <vernols@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <friis@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <bjaras@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <astro.soren@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <senedergaard@xxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <fohbr@xxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <thorsbro@xxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <andersfb.holm@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <hrjo@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <ib_jansen@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <jtoft@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <krja@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <a.e.petersen@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <hansleth@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <jacobfriis@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <lwras@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <m.simonsen@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <pedermose@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <sap@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <vagnl@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <wega@xxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <kursch@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <lemon@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 jgp@xxxx
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 morten.brix@xxxx
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <vgydesen@xxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <frank123@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <preben@xxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <tandplejen@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <hugo@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <hieracium@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <cujla@xxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <hauge.pedersen@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06 <hjfo@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> Expired 0 1 Nov 06 - Nov 06
> <wibniels@xxxxxxxxxxx>
> 550 5.6.0 Lone CR or LF in body (see RFC2822
> section
> None 1 0 Nov 26 - Nov 26 <ca.str@xxxxxxxx>
> conversation with
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Key to actions:
> None - No action taken, user left in watchfile.
> Vacation - User's VACATION flag was set.
> User reached 7 transient errors.
> NOTE: This list is configured so users who
> would
> be set VACATION will be Unsub'd instead.
> Unsub - User was unsubscribed.
> User reached 2 fatal errors.
> Expired - User has not had a bounce for 30 days,
> watch has been expired.
> Admin - User is administrator, no action taken.
> Protect - User is flagged PROTECTED, no action taken.
> Manual - There was no default action taken, handle
> manually.
> NotSub - Bounce message received for user not
> subscribed
> to this list. This is caused when someone
> is
> forwarding to another address and their
> mailserver
> reports the wrong one, or if someone has
> been
> unsubscribed from the list but not expired
> from
> the watches yet.
>
>
> Torben Taustrup
> TOC Observatory homepage
> <http://tocobs.org>
> "Just do it"
>
Other related posts:
