Hi Walter: I have some wrap-up remarks on the TLP to make, but just haven't had the time; we're trying to buy some property in the Sierra foothills right now, and I'm half-crazy from driving across the state every weekend. The Tractatus is a particularly difficult and inaccessible text. I saw a lot of things in this read that I hadn't before, and that will probably happen about the same way for the next six times I read it. Anyway, I think it's good that we hammered at a few of the central issues and even got to the end of it, albeit by great leaps and bounds. As a candidate Next Up, how about Kripke's "Naming and Necessity"? A classic modern text with some very flashy and controversial conclusions. Quick Philosophy not Quit Philosophy. And, what would it say if after we read the TLP, and Wittgenstein has shown thereby that all philosophy is utterly pointless, that we give up the discussion group? Let's not abandon ship just yet. Then too, maybe some tail-ender discussions on the TLP will arise. Thanks! --Ron --- On Tue, 8/17/10, walto <calhorn@xxxxxxx> wrote: From: walto <calhorn@xxxxxxx> Subject: [quickphilosophy] Next Up To: quickphilosophy@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Date: Tuesday, August 17, 2010, 3:54 PM If nobody has anything further to say about the Tractatus, I will tomorrow make my suggestions for possible a second read, and also ask for (i) additional suggestions, and (ii) whether this group should continue at all or be deep-sixed. It may be that we have not hit a "tipping point" in members or that the members we have are already over-committed to other groups, or that the Tractatus was simply not interesting enough or too well understood already to sustain much confab. But if I'm going to have to make 3/4 or more of the posts on every book and so few comments (regardless of who makes them) get any response at all, my sense is that we don't have critical mass or sufficient interest to continue. If any of you DO want to continue with community reads of philosophy books in which you have some interest, I recommend that you try to get a philosophy friend or two (who is/are not either nuts or overly aggressive) to sign up! Best, W