Don't think so Mo, the same effect was experienced on both my Dell and non-Dell desktops. Phil -----Original Message----- From: vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Mobeen Iqbal Sent: 23 May 2014 13:43 To: vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [vi-tech-testers] Re: no sound when booting arch Hi phil. It will be interesting to see what experience other users have. Dell use their own hardware for sound, so it could be to do with that perhaps? I will have to see if I can test on a dell at this end. Keep us posted. I hope I can find a machine that's flakey in terms of sound like yours so I can test it and try to resolve the bug... Mo. Agent Orange <agentorange@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote: Booted four further times on Win XP machine. Experienced 3 failures of speech, and 1 success. When it works I can hear it with speakers at normal levels, and no message about multiple sound cards. I'll proceed with a backup on the basis that it appears that with enough reboots the CD will eventually launch speech. Phil -----Original Message----- From: Agent Orange [mailto:agentorange@xxxxxxxxxxxx] Sent: 23 May 2014 13:00 To: 'vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx' Subject: RE: [vi-tech-testers] Re: no sound when booting arch Hi Mo, Just tried booting from the Cd on my Win XP machine. On the fourth boot I have speech. I did jam the volume right up on this occasion but I did not receive a message about multiple sound cards. Also, when I turn the volume back down I can still hear speakup. So I'm not sure that volume was actually the issue. Saying that, I did not do anything else different on the fourth boot so not sure why it worked this time and not previously. I'll try booting off the CD a few more times and see whether I continue to experience any failures. Phil -----Original Message----- From: vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Mobeen Iqbal Sent: 23 May 2014 12:11 To: vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [vi-tech-testers] Re: no sound when booting arch Hello Phil. I've just tried this on my desktop. i had to turn my speakers up to full, i could hear a very quiet voice speaking initially. after i turned my speakers up, a message informed me that multiple sound cards were apparently present, and to select which one i wanted to use. when the relevant sound card b eeped. i waited for the beep and pressed enter just after it. this is a strange message to be displayed especially since my computer only has 1 sound card. could you try turning your speakers up to full and seeing if the same things happens for you? if others experience issues like this it may be that we have to get rid of that script which for some reason is launched everytime arch thinks you have multiple sound cards... Mo. On 23/05/2014 11:58, Mobeen Iqbal wrote: Hi Phil. This is very interesting! I will shortly try this on my desktop. what hardware are you running it on? laptop or desktop? do you have any other accessories? USB headsets, amplifiers, etc? i'm just wondering what would be different between your setup and mine... Mo. On 23/05/2014 11:37, Agent Oran ge wrote: Having successfully created a bootable CD from Mo's ISO image, I prepared my target PC by deleting loads of data to make the backup and restore process faster. The target PC is running Win XP Home SP3. I then inserted the bootable CD into the CD ROM drive and rebooted whilst holding down F12 to bring up my list of boot options, then cursored down twice to select the option to boot from the CD ROM Drive. This seems to happen fine and the CD ROM Drive makes all the correct noises. I then hear a bleep. I arrow down once to what I believe is the 32 bit version of Talking Arch and press Enter. Again, more positive noises from the CD ROM Drive indicating plenty of activity. However, once all activity from the CD ROM Drive has stopped, at the point I would expect to hear speakup announce root@archISO, all I receive is a stony silence. I believe Arch has loaded correctly as I can type the poweroff and the reboot commands at this point, and the PC will respond with the appropriate action. So it is clear that Linux is operational. But no speech. I have tried increasing the volume using Caps 2 (that is 2 on the number row not on the numpad). But no change. Thinking that this could be an issue with the sound card on my Win XP machine, I repeated the above process by booting from the same CD but this time using my Windows 7 PC which has different hardware (just 4 months old). Unfortunately I receive an identical result - no speech, but Linux appears to be executing the reboot / poweroff commands. Bit of a stone wall really .... Any thoughts? Phil -----Original Message----- From: Agent Orange [mailto:agentorange@xxxxxxxxxxxx] Sent: 23 May 2014 10:03 To: 'vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx' Subject: RE: [vi-tech-testers] types of feedback wanted? Mo, problem solved. The ISO has now burned to a blank CD after I downloaded it again. Phil -----Original Message----- From: Agent Orange [mailto:agentorange@xxxxxxxxxxxx] Sent: 23 May 2014 09:35 To: 'vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx' Subject: RE: [vi-tech-testers] types of feedback wanted? Thanks Mo. I'd be interested in committing some time towards a project aiming to test hardware and software with the goal of improving accessibility. Take your point re feed back, thanks for clarifying that for me. On the specifics of testing the Talking Arch backup and recovery disc, I have downloaded the file: TalkingArch-2014.05.02-dual.iso I obtained this from the link you provided. I downloaded it using Firefox 29 to a Win 7 Pro 64bit PC. I have just tried using the Win 7 Image Burner to burn the ISO file to a blank CD but have received the following message under the Status indicator: The selected disc image file isn't valid. I have used JFW to virtualise the content of the Windows Image burner and copy out the full text below: Windows Disc Image Burner Disc image file: TalkingArch-2014.05.02-dual.iso Disc burner: BD-RE Drive (D:) Status The selected disc image file isn't valid. Verify disc after burning Burn Cancel I will try downloading it again in case it has become corrupted. Phil -----Original Message----- From: vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Mobeen Iqbal Sent: 22 May 2014 23:00 To: vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [vi-tech-testers] types of feedback wanted? Hello Phil. I should've clarified, to be honest i hadn't mentioned the type of feedback specifically. its mainly objective feedback that i'm after, if we can refine the process of people being able to backup their systems it would be fantastic to make it as fool proof as possible. i'm also waiting for someone to test this on a windows 8 system. so far i haven't found anyone with a windows machine i can junk *evil chuckle*. personally i hate windows8 it was just like windows vista. i haven't been asked to install it once hahahaha windows7 still remains the most popular operating system. if people want to comment on the guide as well its fine, but all the editing will be done at the end once feedback's been collected. there may still be significant changes to be made. many thanks to all of you f or your responses. perhaps we should make a habbit on this list of facing different challenges, i'm still trying to work out the specific goals and the reasons i created this list. can it become something more? i.e should we take on testing and improving various products hardware or software? its an interesting concept and i think viable if people pool resources/experience but it would all depend on how much time people have. all the best, Mo. Mo. On 22/05/2014 13:48, Agent Orange wrote: Hi Mo, Still here. I've read the guide and have downloaded the ISO. I'll be testing it in the next day or so. Apologies if you have already explained this. What sort of comments / feedback are you hoping to get? Would you like comments of a technical nature, eg, the process failed, or the steps in the guide do not accurately reflect the steps I had to go through, or there was an error, etc? Or would you like comments on the text of your guide which are of a more editorial nature, eg, whether there is too much or too little detail, whether you might consider re-phrasing a sentence, etc? The former is more objective and in many ways easier for folks to provide. The latter is potentially more subjective, more time consuming, and perhaps depends on whether the tester understands your views about the target audience for the guide and shares your style of writing. If you could offer some thoughts / guidance on the sort of feedback you are, or are not, looking for, I would find that helpful in targeting my thoughts to those areas you are particularly interested in. Another question: your guide currently specifies a command line process (fdisk) for the tester to 'break' their hard disc installation of Windows. Obviously this section will be omitted in the final user guide as it is for testing purposes only! However, for those of us more comfortable in Windows, I assume you would be happy for the disc to be reformatted using other means, eg, via the command prompt or using a Windows utility? Or would you prefer us to stick with the program and use fdisk? Happy to do the latter if you prefer. Cheers Phil -----Original Message----- From: vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:vi-tech-testers-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Mobeen Iqbal Sent: 22 May 2014 13:35 To: vi-tech-testers@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [vi-tech-testers] is anyone awake? Hi everyone. its very quiet on list, just wondering if you're all still around? don't forget to recommend this list to others who you think may be interested in testing the guide. unfortunately i'm not subscribed to any of the US mailing lists, but its probably worth spreading the word... Mo. -- Sent from my Android phone with K-9 Mail. Please excuse my brevity.