I will post more substantive comments when I have time after work, but I stand by my response to Ed that, in my opinion, this is quite clearly a Common Yellowthroat for a number of reasons. Chris Sloan Nashville, TN http://www.chrissloanphotography.com On Fri, Jun 29, 2012 at 12:01 PM, Richard Knight <rknight8@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>wrote: > > A few days back Ed Schneider posted a photo of a warbler for which he was > unsure of > the ID. In an off-list email conversation, he said the the consensus > opinion was for > female Common Yellowthroat. There has been no public discussion of the > ID, so I am > weighing in. > > I believe it is a Nashville Warbler. > My reasoning: > 1) the head is too gray for female Com. Yellowthroat, which should be > brownish-olive. > 2) the eye-ring is a little too bold, but head color & eye-ring are right > for Nashville. > 3) the yellow underneath is too extensive & even-toned for yellowthroat, > which should > be shaded from fairly bright in throat to dull yellow on lower breast. > 4) culmen shape appears to be straight, unlike slightly down-curved for > yellowthroat. > The amount of yellow underneath & bill shape are good for Nashville. > > While Nashville Warblers in spring migration usually occur higher up in > trees than the > bird in the photo, which is in blackberry brambles, I often see fall > migrant Nashvilles > in low shrubby stuff including goldenrod & ragweed. So habitat shouldn't > be an issue. > > Photo IDs are sometimes harder than in-life IDs, since there is only one > angle per photo, > no vocalizations or behavioral clues, etc. However, you can stare at the > photo for as > long as you want & analyze visible details. > > Apparently this would be the first summer record of a Nashville Warbler in > TN, as > Robinson (1990) lists none & I don't recall any since then. It could be a > very late > spring migrant or, more likely, an early fall migrant (perhaps a failed > breeder) or > a wandering non-breeder. Nashvilles do nest as far south as northern West > Virginia. > > Comments welcome. > > Rick Knight > Johnson City, TN > > > ----- Original Message ----- > *From:* Ed Schneider <ed.schneider@xxxxxxxxxxx> > *To: *tn bird <tn-bird@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> > *Sent:* 6/23/2012 3:39:54 PM > *Subject:* [TN-Bird] Nashville Warbler (???) > > Bells Bend Park, Davidson Co. > 23 June, 2012 > > I realize there are no summer records for this bird, and I wouldn't expect > there to be. I of course thought I was > photographing a female Common Yellowthroat, but the eye ring seemed WAY to > strong compared to the female > and first year yellowthroats I've seen. > > That being said, the bill shape doesn't scream Oreothylpis to me at all, > and the habitat is of course all wrong for > Nashville even in migration. > > Anyone care to share some thoughts on a bird that threw me for a small > loop this morning? I imagine COYE can > be extremely variable, and I'm still an advanced novice at best... always > nice to get a photo of a questionable bird, > however. > > > Thanks, > Ed Schneider > Davidson Co. > >