I agree with Brush. I am not contesting your bird either, Bob, but I spend a lot of time with Swainson recordings on my Shelby Co. land (habitat seems perfect for that species) and I get Lo. Waterthrushes responding and singing. The Waterthrushes do add a "sputter" sometimes to the end of their song so it helps to distinguish the two species. Sue Orwig On Mon, Jun 24, 2013 at 1:09 PM, Brush Freeman <brushfreeman@xxxxxxxxx>wrote: > Bob: Very interesting. Before the park was opened and in its > formative stages I was able to make some birding visits to the > property, I have not been back since. This was likely around 15 years > ago or so, I really don't remember and I assume we are talking about > the same property as it had no real name then. > There were oodles of La. Waterthrushes there at that time in the > spring.......Now I can not contest the bird as you actually saw it, > but I can not begin to tell you how many times I have been fooled by > the song of a LWTH that sounded like a SWWA....Heck even at times > Hoodeds have tried hard to fool me....If indeed there are Swainson's > there, it should be something to interest folks as it would be the > westernmost breeding population in the US I believe...The contenders > being Bastrop Co.and extreme eastern Aransas Co.....If this can be > confirmed/doccumented very quickly, I mean like within a week it may > be something that could be added to the new TOS Handbook which is set > to go to the publisher within just a few more days. > ********************************************************************** > Brush Freeman > 361-655-7641 Cell > http://texasnaturenotes.blogspot.com/ > Finca Alacranes., Utley,Texas > > > On Mon, Jun 24, 2013 at 12:50 PM, <doefamily@xxxxxxx> wrote: > > On Sunday, I was at Medina River Natural Area in south Bexar County > where I heard a loud, thin song reminiscent of Swainson's Warbler, although > I could not locate the bird. Overnight, I listened to many recordings of > Swainson's Warbler and found one that is virtually identical to what I > heard. Go to www.xwno-cantu.org, search for Swainson's Warbler and > listen to file xc103760. At the end of this recording is a 5 note song > virtually identical in tone, timing, and emphasis to what I heard at Medina > River. Being basically non-musical, I interpret the song as something like > "zeet, zeet, zeet, zook, zook", with the "Zeet, Zeet, Zeet" all being the > same tone and evenly spaced, and the "Zook. Zook" being lower in tone and > slightly faster. > > > > I went back to the site this morning and had more song, at one point 3 > birds singing simultaneously. The birds sang infrequently. In the > approximately 1 1/2 hours I was there, there were 3 song sessions. But when > one bird would begin to sing, others would join in. During a song session, > an individual bird would sing repeatedly over several minutes. > Interestingly, almost all of the songs were the same 5 note song, However, > during one session, 1 bird added a sixth note to the end, softly and > seemingly hesitantly, as if the bird wasn't sure the note belonged. Most of > the songs at xeno-cantu include this sixth slurred note. > > > > Question: Do juvenile Swainson's give an abbreviated song? Or is there > a "post breeding" abbreviated song? Almost all of the songs I heard were 5 > note calls, and almost all of the recordings have a slurred 6th note. > > > > The birds were VERY difficult to see. I never did see a singing bird, > but was fortunate to see one bird fly to the opposite side of the river and > land for a few seconds on an exposed branch. First Swainson's Warbler I > have seen in Texas (saw several while I was in coastal Mississippi). I > believe the bird I saw was a juvenile, as it seemed duller than breeding > birds I remember from Mississippi, but Swainson's is never very bright. > > > > DESCRIPTION: Chunky appearing warbler, approximately the size of > Carolina Wren, which were very common at the site. Overall dull color. Back > and wings were dull grayish brown, no wingbars. Underparts were dull > grayish or grayish white, no obvious streaking. Noticeable dull white > eyebrow stripe, crown a dull slightly reddish brown. Bill long, straight, > stout. > > > > Location, if anyone wants to try for these birds: Medina Rivera Natural > Area is located in south Bexar County, off of Highway 16, just north of the > Medina River. From the headquarters, drop down to the river and take the > Rio Medina trail. Continue on the Rio Medina trail about 1/4 mile past the > junction with the Nogales Trail (total distance from headquarters about 1 > 1/4 to 1 1/2 miles). There will be a large downed tree on the left (trail > passes it on the right). Immediately past the downed tree is a fishing > access to the right and immediately past the fishing access is a mud puddle > in the trail (only wet spot on the trail today). Swainson's Warblers have > been in the vicinity of the downed tree, on both sides of the river. If you > go about 150 yards too far, the trail will turn left and begin to loop back > toward the headquarters. WARNING: It is very hot and humid down under the > trees, The breeze doesn't work down through the foliage very often. Also, > poison ivy/poison oak i > s > > VERY common in the area. Watch where you step and put your hands and be > aware of overhanging branches along the trail. > > > > > > Bob Doe > > Spring Branch > > > > Edit your Freelists account settings for TEXBIRDS at > > //www.freelists.org/list/texbirds > > > > Reposting of traffic from TEXBIRDS is prohibited without seeking > permission > > from the List Owner > > > > > Edit your Freelists account settings for TEXBIRDS at > //www.freelists.org/list/texbirds > > Reposting of traffic from TEXBIRDS is prohibited without seeking permission > from the List Owner > > > Edit your Freelists account settings for TEXBIRDS at //www.freelists.org/list/texbirds Reposting of traffic from TEXBIRDS is prohibited without seeking permission from the List Owner