Hi=20Chris, As=20always,=20the=20short=20answer=20is=20it=20depends. If=20you=20are=20talking=20about=20a=20through=20hole=20component then=20this=20is=20a=20real=20concern.=20=20If=20you=20set=20the=20wave profile=20for=20the=20signal=20pin=20attach,=20odds=20are=20 you=20are=20going=20to=20have=20a=20cold=20solder=20joint=20on=20plane=20c= onnects=20=20 If=20in=20fact=20you=20have=20a=20large=20multilayer=20backplane with,=20for=20the=20sake=20of=20argument,=2010=20=20-=201oz=20gnd=20 planes=20with=20dead=20shorts,=20you=20might=20have=20to=20put so=20much=20heat=20into=20the=20board=20to=20get=20solder=20flow that=20you=20risk=20delamination.=20=20One=20needs=20to=20take=20 a=20look=20at=20the=20design=20to=20come=20up=20with=20the=20best=20 solution.=20=20Perhaps=20two=20spoke=20thermals=20on=20every layer=20is=20preferable=20to=20leaving=20certain=20layers=20 out.=20=20It=20is=20design=20dependent. One=20way=20to=20avoid=20this=20is=20in=20this=20situation=20is=20to make=20use=20of=20press=20fit=20connectors.=20=20In=20many=20cases this=20may=20be=20a=20preferable=20avenue=20for=20your=20manufacturing=20 folks.=20=20You=20get=20a=20solid=20via/plane=20attach=20and=20they get=20reliable=20component=20to=20board=20attach. If=20you=20are=20talking=20a=20surface=20mount=20component=20than the=20argument=20doesn't=20hold=20a=20whole=20lot=20of=20water=20and there=20are=20numerous=20studies=20to=20support=20this.=20The=20fanout should=20provide=20enough=20thermal=20relief=20for=20a=20reliable solder=20joint,=20even=20with=20dead=20shorts=20on=20all=20planes.=20 Best=20Regards, Michael=20Greim Platform=20Engineering Newisys,=20Inc. 512-634-5553=20=20=20=20(V) 512-740-9097=20=20=20=20(C) We=20will=20either=20find=20a=20way=20or=20make=20one=20=20=20=20=20-Hanni= bal The=20time=20is=20gone,=20the=20email's=20over Thought=20I'd=20something=20more=20to=20say....... -----Original=20Message----- From:=20si-list-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20[mailto:si-list-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxx= g] On=20Behalf=20Of=20Chris=20Padilla=20(cpad) Sent:=20Tuesday,=20July=2025,=202006=2010:44=20AM To:=20si-list@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject:=20[SI-LIST]=20Re:=20Current=20Return=20Vias I=20get=20push=20back=20all=20the=20time=20in=20trying=20to=20connect=20al= l=20"gnd"=20planes=20in multi-layer=20stackups=20(say=2018=20layers=20+...and=20usually=20at=20our= =20limit=20of=2026 layers).=20=20The=20reason=20is=20provide=20by=20the=20manufacturing=20fol= ks=20in=20that=20they cannot=20solder=20or=20get=20good=20solder=20flow=20because=20the=20mulitp= le=20gnd=20planes act=20like=20heat=20sinks.=20=20Therefore,=20I=20am=20forced=20to=20used=20= thermal=20reliefs=20and even=20in=20a=20lot=20of=20cases,=20I=20cannot=20even=20connect=20some=20g= nd=20planes=20to=20the=20gnd vias! Any=20thoughts=20on=20this=20subject? Thanks, Chris=20Padilla Cisco=20Systems San=20Jose,=20CA=3D20 -----Original=20Message----- From:=20si-list-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20[mailto:si-list-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxx= g] On=20Behalf=20Of=20Lee=20Ritchey Sent:=20Monday,=20July=2024,=202006=203:44=20PM To:=20Joel=20Brown Cc:=20Kenny=20Frohlich;=20si-list@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject:=20[SI-LIST]=20Re:=20Current=20Return=20Vias Joel, First,=20you=20should=20have=20stitched=20your=20ground=20planes=20to=20ea= ch=20other=20every where=20there=20is=20a=20ground=20pin=20on=20a=20device,=20so=20these=20gr= ound=20planes=20should be=20well=20tied=20to=20each=20other=20every=20place=20you=20have=20a=20co= mponent=20whether=20it be=20a=20bypass=20capacitor=20or=20an=20IC.=20=20(This=20argues=20for=20sp= reading=20your=20bypass capacitors=20=20evenly=20around=20the=20planes=20as=20has=20been=20advocat= ed=20by=20a=20number of=20members=20of=20this=20forum=20in=20the=20past.)=20=20Only=20where=20y= ou=20might=20change layers=20in=20an=20empty=20part=20of=20the=20PCB=20is=20this=20not=20so.=20= Second,=20when=20you engineer=20your=20PDS=20you=20need=20to=20insure=20that=20the=20impedance=20= is=20a=20few milliohms=20across=20all=20of=20the=20frequencies=20in=20your=20signals,=20= so=20the=20Vdd planes=20are=20"shorted"=20to=20these=20ground=20planes=20by=20this=20meth= od.=20=20(=20To achieve=20this=20low=20impedance=20across=20the=20broad=20range=20of=20fre= quencies=20in=20your signals,=20you=20will=20be=20using=20plane=20capacitance=20as=20well=20as=20= a=20variety=20of different=20values=20of=20capacitors.=20=20When=20done=20right,=20all=20of= =20the=20planes=20are "shorted"=20to=20each=20other=20and=20return=20currents=20have=20all=20the= =20paths=20they need.=20=20If=20the=20PDS=20isn't=20properly=20designed=20you=20can=20wind= =20up=20with=20EMI problems=20and=20unstable=20logic=20operation. >=20[Original=20Message] >=20From:=20Joel=20Brown=20<joel@xxxxxxxxxx> >=20To:=20<leeritchey@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> >=20Cc:=20Kenny=20Frohlich=20<kenny_frohlich@xxxxxxxxx>;=20<si-list@freeli= sts.org> >=20Date:=207/23/2006=2012:25:04=20PM >=20Subject:=20[SI-LIST]=20Re:=20Current=20Return=20Vias > >=20=20I=20am=20currently=20working=20on=20board=20that=20has=2012=20layer= s. >=20Ground=20planes=20are=20layers=202,=205,=208,=20and=2011.=3D20=20If=20= a=20high=20speed=20signal=20 >=20changes=20from=20layer=203=20to=20layer=209=20then=20its=3D20=20refere= nce=20planes=20change=20 >=20from=20layers=202=20&5=20to=20layers=208=20&11. >=20Since=20the=20return=20current=20flows=20under=20the=20signal=20trace=20= on=20the=20reference plane >=20,=20this=20return=20current=20has=20jump=20from=20from=20one=20set=20o= f=20planes=20to=20the=3D20=20 >=20other set >=20at=20the=20point=20signal=20changes=20layers=20through=20a=20via.=20Th= e=20return=20 >=20current=3D20=20could=20jump=20through=20interplane=20capacitance=20or=20= through=20a=20 >=20ground=20via=3D20=20located=20next to >=20the=20signal=20via.=20So=20in=20this=20situation=20I=20don't=20see=20w= hy=20having=20a=20 >=20ground=3D20=20via=20nextto=20a=20signal=20would=20not=20be=20beneficia= l?=20Does=20the=20 >=20interplane=3D20=20capacitance=20provide=20a=20lower=20impedance=20path= =20than=20the=20 >=20ground=20via=20for=20the >=20return=20current method=20to >=20jump=20planes?=20Please=20enlighten=20me. >=20Joel > > >=20Lee=20Ritchey=20wrote:=20Kenny,=20It=20is=20not=20true=20that=20you=20= need=20a=20"return current" >=20vianext=20to=20each=20layer=20changing=20signal=20via.=20I=20continue=20= to=20be=20amazed=3D20=20 >=20that=20engineers=20who=20are=20looked=20upon=20as=20SI=20experts=20say= =20such=20things.=3D20=20 >=20Imagine=20you=20havea=204=20layer=20PCB,=20such=20as=20the=20mother=20= board=20in=20a=20PC,=20where >=20there=20are=20only=20twoplanes,=20one=20Vdd=20and=20one=20ground,=20wh= ere=20would=20such=3D20=20 >=20vias=20connect?=20There have >=20been=20billions=20of=20these=20made=20to=20date=20that=20work=20just=20= fine=20and=20have=20 >=20very=3D20=20fast=20signals=20on=20them.=20The=20return=20currents=20yo= u=20are=20concerned=20 >=20about=20find >=20their way >=20from=20plane=20to=20plane=20through=20the=20collection=20of=20decoupli= ng=20capacitors=3D20 >=20and=20interplane=20capacitance=20that=20you=20had=20to=20engineer=20in= to=20the=20power=3D20=20 >=20delivery=20system=20in=20order=20to=20make=20it=20stable.=20Focus=20on= =20this=20and=20the=3D20=20 >=20return=20currents=20takecare=20of=20themselves.=20EMI=20is=20minimized= =20he=20same=20way.. >=20[Original=20Message] >=20From:=20Kenny=20Frohlich=20<kenny_frohlich@xxxxxxxxx>[1]=20To: >=20<si-list@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>[2]Date:=207/22/2006=206:45:56=20AM=20Subject:=3D= 20=20 >=20[SI-LIST]=20Current=20Return=20Vias=20Dear=20Experts,=20I=20understand= =20that=20I=20 >=20need=3D20=20to=20provide ground >=20vias=20next=20to=20via=20explictly=20for=20the=20purpose=20of=20lettin= g=20return=20 >=20currents=3D20=20jump=20between=20layers.=20I=20know=20it's=20a=20requi= rement=20for=20high=20 >=20speed=20signals, especially >=20differrential=20signals.=20Is=20this=20also=20required=20for=20low=20s= peed=3D20=20 >=20single-ended=20signals=20(133Mhz=20or=20slower)?=20If=20this=20is=20a=20= requirement,=3D20=20 >=20what=20would=20be=20a=20good=20signal=20via=20to=20ground=20via=20rati= o?=20For=20example,=3D20=20 >=20there=20are=20five=20signal=20vias=20within=20a=201=20inch=20area,=20h= ow=20many=20ground=20 >=20vias=3D20=20do=20I=20need?=20Thank=20you=20Kenny=3D20=20 >=20__________________________________________________=20Do=20You=20Yahoo!= ?=3D20=20 >=20Tired=20of=20spam?=20Yahoo!=20Mail=20has=20the=20best=20spam=20protect= ion=20around > http://mail.yahoo.com[3]------------------------------------------------ ---- >=20--------------=20To=20unsubscribe=20from=20si-list: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx[4] >=20with=20'unsubscribe'=20in=20the=20Subject=20field=20or=20to=20administ= er=20your=3D20=20 >=20membership=20froma=20web=20page,=20go=20to:=3D20=20 >=20//www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list[5]=20For help: >=20si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx[6]=20with=20'help'=20in=20the=20Subject=20= field=20List >=20FAQ=20wiki=20page=20is=20located=20at:=3D20 >=20http://si-list.org/wiki/wiki.pl?Si-List_FAQ[7] List >=20technical=20documents=20are=20available=20at:=20http://www.si-list.org= [8]=20 >=20List=3D20=20archivesare=20viewable=20at:=20 >=20//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list[9]=3D20 >=20or at >=20our=20remote=20archives:=3D20 >=20http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages[10] Old >=20(prior=20to=20June=206,=202001)=20list=20archives=20are=20viewable=20a= t: >=20http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu[11] >=20------------------------------------------------------------------=20 >=20To=3D20=20unsubscribe=20from=20si-list:=20si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxx= g[12]=20 >=20with=3D20=20'unsubscribe'=20in=20the=20Subject=20field=20or=20to=20adm= inister=20your=20 >=20membership=3D20=20from=20a=20web=20page,=20go=20to:=20 >=20//www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list[13] For=20help: >=20si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx[14]=20with=20'help'=20in=20the=20Subject= =20field=3D20=20 >=20List FAQ >=20wiki=20page=20is=20located=20at:=3D20 >=20http://si-list.org/wiki/wiki.pl?Si-List_FAQ[15] >=20Listtechnical=20documents=20are=20available=20at:=20 >=20http://www.si-list.org[16]=3D20=20List=20archives=20are=20viewable=20a= t:=3D20=20 >=20//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list[17]=20or=20atour=20remote=3D= 20 >=20archives:=20http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages[18] >=20Old(prior=20to=20June=206,=202001)=20list=20archives=20are=20viewable=20= at: >=20http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu[19] > >=20---=20Links=20--- >=20=20=20=201=20mailto:kenny_frohlich@xxxxxxxxx >=20=20=20=202=20mailto:si-list@xxxxxxxxxxxxx >=20=20=20=203=20http://mail.yahoo.com >=20=20=20=204=20mailto:si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx >=20=20=20=205=20//www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list >=20=20=20=206=20mailto:si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx >=20=20=20=207=20http://si-list.org/wiki/wiki.pl?Si-List_FAQ >=20=20=20=208=20http://www.si-list.org >=20=20=20=209=20//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list >=20=20=2010=20http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages >=20=20=2011=20http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu >=20=20=2012=20mailto:si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx >=20=20=2013=20//www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list >=20=20=2014=20mailto:si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx >=20=20=2015=20http://si-list.org/wiki/wiki.pl?Si-List_FAQ >=20=20=2016=20http://www.si-list.org >=20=20=2017=20//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list >=20=20=2018=20http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages >=20=20=2019=20http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu > >=20--=20Binary/unsupported=20file=20stripped=20by=20Ecartis=20-- >=20--=20Type:=20text/x-vcard >=20--=20File:=20joel.vcf > > >=20------------------------------------------------------------------ >=20To=20unsubscribe=20from=20si-list: >=20si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20with=20'unsubscribe'=20in=20the=20Subj= ect=20field > >=20or=20to=20administer=20your=20membership=20from=20a=20web=20page,=20go= =20to: >=20//www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list > >=20For=20help: >=20si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20with=20'help'=20in=20the=20Subject=20f= ield > >=20List=20FAQ=20wiki=20page=20is=20located=20at: >=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20http://si-list.org/wik= i/wiki.pl?Si-List_FAQ > >=20List=20technical=20documents=20are=20available=20at: >=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20http://www.si-list.org= > >=20List=20archives=20are=20viewable=20at:=20=20=20=20=3D20 >=20=09=09//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list >=20or=20at=20our=20remote=20archives: >=20=09=09http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages >=20Old=20(prior=20to=20June=206,=202001)=20list=20archives=20are=20viewab= le=20at: >=20=20=09=09http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu >=20=20=3D20 ------------------------------------------------------------------ To=20unsubscribe=20from=20si-list: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20with=20'unsubscribe'=20in=20the=20Subject=20= field or=20to=20administer=20your=20membership=20from=20a=20web=20page,=20go=20t= o: //www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list For=20help: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20with=20'help'=20in=20the=20Subject=20field= List=20FAQ=20wiki=20page=20is=20located=20at: =20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20http://si-list.org/wiki/wi= ki.pl?Si-List_FAQ List=20technical=20documents=20are=20available=20at: =20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20http://www.si-list.org List=20archives=20are=20viewable=20at:=20=20=20=20=3D20 =09=09//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list or=20at=20our=20remote=20archives: =09=09http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages Old=20(prior=20to=20June=206,=202001)=20list=20archives=20are=20viewable=20= at: =20=09=09http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu =20=3D20 ------------------------------------------------------------------ To=20unsubscribe=20from=20si-list: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20with=20'unsubscribe'=20in=20the=20Subject=20= field or=20to=20administer=20your=20membership=20from=20a=20web=20page,=20go=20t= o: //www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list For=20help: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx=20with=20'help'=20in=20the=20Subject=20field= List=20FAQ=20wiki=20page=20is=20located=20at: =20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20http://si-list.org/wiki/wi= ki.pl?Si-List_FAQ List=20technical=20documents=20are=20available=20at: =20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20=20http://www.si-list.org List=20archives=20are=20viewable=20at:=20=20=20=20=20 =09=09//www.freelists.org/archives/si-list or=20at=20our=20remote=20archives: =09=09http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages Old=20(prior=20to=20June=206,=202001)=20list=20archives=20are=20viewable=20= at: =20=09=09http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu =20=20 ________________________________________________________________________ _____ Scanned=20by=20Sanmina-SCI=20eShield ________________________________________________________________________ _____ CONFIDENTIALITY This=20e-mail=20message=20and=20any=20attachments=20thereto,=20is=20intend= ed=20only=20for=20use=20by=20the=20addressee(s)=20named=20herein=20and=20m= ay=20contain=20legally=20privileged=20and/or=20confidential=20information.= =20If=20you=20are=20not=20the=20intended=20recipient=20of=20this=20e-mail=20= message,=20you=20are=20hereby=20notified=20that=20any=20dissemination,=20d= istribution=20or=20copying=20of=20this=20e-mail=20message,=20and=20any=20a= ttachments=20thereto,=20is=20strictly=20prohibited.=20=20If=20you=20have=20= received=20this=20e-mail=20message=20in=20error,=20please=20immediately=20= notify=20the=20sender=20and=20permanently=20delete=20the=20original=20and=20= any=20copies=20of=20this=20email=20and=20any=20prints=20thereof. ABSENT=20AN=20EXPRESS=20STATEMENT=20TO=20THE=20CONTRARY=20HEREINABOVE,=20T= HIS=20E-MAIL=20IS=20NOT=20INTENDED=20AS=20A=20SUBSTITUTE=20FOR=20A=20WRITI= NG.=20=20Notwithstanding=20the=20Uniform=20Electronic=20Transactions=20Act= =20or=20the=20applicability=20of=20any=20other=20law=20of=20similar=20subs= tance=20and=20effect,=20absent=20an=20express=20statement=20to=20the=20con= trary=20hereinabove,=20this=20e-mail=20message=20its=20contents,=20and=20a= ny=20attachments=20hereto=20are=20not=20intended=20to=20represent=20an=20o= ffer=20or=20acceptance=20to=20enter=20into=20a=20contract=20and=20are=20no= t=20otherwise=20intended=20to=20bind=20the=20sender,=20Sanmina-SCI=20Corpo= ration=20(or=20any=20of=20its=20subsidiaries),=20or=20any=20other=20person= =20or=20entity. __________________________________________________________________________= ___ Scanned=20by=20Sanmina-SCI=20eShield=20=20________________________________= _____________________________________________ ------------------------------------------------------------------ To unsubscribe from si-list: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with 'unsubscribe' in the Subject field or to administer your membership from a web page, go to: //www.freelists.org/webpage/si-list For help: si-list-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with 'help' in the Subject field List FAQ wiki page is located at: http://si-list.org/wiki/wiki.pl?Si-List_FAQ List technical documents are available at: http://www.si-list.org List archives are viewable at: //www.freelists.org/archives/si-list or at our remote archives: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/si-list/messages Old (prior to June 6, 2001) list archives are viewable at: http://www.qsl.net/wb6tpu