Trahanone@xxxxxxx: A while back we discussed editors and the board had to make a decision. The person that was elected has greatly improved our Review but how did this editor let this article get out without thinking about the consequences. There is freedom of speech but an editor has responsibility also of printing material that is factual and has legal obligations. Many legal suits are filed everyday regarding defamation of character and as an editor you must be aware of those issues. That's why it was important to hire a firm/company that does this for a living versus what we did........again possible a decision the board made that possible has now led to not so good results. ------------------------------------------------------------ I have been trying to read between the lines on what has been happening at this meeting. While I agree that some of what has been reported sounds extremely bad -- until I'm able to talk to several people who were there, I'm holding off on getting my knickers in a knot. (They say turning 40 does this to people, and I'm proof positive). However -- I have to say this... The BIGGEST PROBLEMS our club has at this time on the Board level -- are the fact we have TOO MANY BOARD MEMBERS who don't have a personal fiddlers fig of an idea how: 1) Roberts Rules of Order work and their use. This is the absolute biggest problem we have. These guys get voted in because of "name" recognition, or how nice they are on the list, or how "they're going to change things" when they get there with no real fundamental knowledge of how to make motions, which motions can't be retracted, which ones can, when they can press for discussion, when the president can be told they're out of line, when a lot of things. This whole "AH" (I like that acronym -- it's a good one ... instead of his name, figure the other part out LOL) thing is a result of poor procedure and not following the original bylaws & P/P that says we need two sponsors -- DUH. And gee... WHO WERE THE PEOPLE WHO LET THAT HAPPEN????? How come there's no roasting spit for them??? 2) Business -- Several good working board members really haven't got a a real clue of an idea how to run a business. This is fundamental, because I'm sorry -- the GSDCA is a corporation with some fairly decent assets. Just because someone has been a successful dog person doesn't mean they have a clue about running a business; conversely, just because a person is just because someone is in business, means they are good at running a company. A certain level of success in both venues, with a stress on the business aspects should be the people who even consider running for a Board position. Additionally, just because someone is a lawyer, teacher, dentist, certified salesperson, whatever, doesn't mean they are good -- I'll steal a phrase from Christine Grainger -- "You can be a doctor -- some graduate at the top of their class and there are those who graduate at the bottom of their class, and there's no way to know because they are all titled Doctor and it doesn't mean they are skilled." 3) Probably most important --- POLITICAL B*LLSH*T that has colored this and previous boards. This fragmentation of the Board has been the cause of a lot of strife over the years, but when you add the other two issues to it -- viola' we have chaos. Right now -- this type of cross-purpose bildgewater is causing us a lot of issue. People have been using their Board Positions for stepping stones for Judging assignments, including the National, or for more their own personal "stature". I'm sick of all of this --- Corporation or not --- this is supposed to be a DOG CLUB -- About the dogs -- not about this other crappola. Kathaleen ============================================================================ POST is Copyrighted 2007. All material remains the property of the original author and of GSD Communication, Inc. NO REPRODUCTIONS or FORWARDS of any kind are permitted without prior permission of the original author AND of the Showgsd-l Management. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. ALL PERSONS ARE ON NOTICE THAT THE FORWARDING, REPRODUCTION OR USE IN ANY MANNER OF ANY MATERIAL WHICH APPEARS ON SHOWGSD-L WITHOUT THE EXPRESS PERMISSION OF ALL PARTIES TO THE POST AND THE LIST MANAGEMENT IS EXPRESSLY FORBIDDEN, AND IS A VIOLATION OF LAW. VIOLATORS OF THIS PROHIBITION WILL BE PROSECUTED. For assistance, please contact the List Management at admin@xxxxxxxxxxxx VISIT OUR WEBSITE - www.showgsd.org ============================================================================