[pskmail] Re: Polish PSKmail network
- From: Robert Krasowski <rkrasowski@xxxxxxxxx>
- To: pskmail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Mon, 30 Apr 2012 16:04:04 -0700 (PDT)
Thanks for comments, I will make sure that he update his data into the server,
that maybe reason. I will let you know how it went.
Robert
KB2PNM
--- On Sun, 4/29/12, Pär Crusefalk <per@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
From: Pär Crusefalk <per@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: [pskmail] Re: Polish PSKmail network
To: pskmail@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
Date: Sunday, April 29, 2012, 4:16 AM
Hi,
No server I know of requires any intermar address.
Franz is correct in that servers that use gmail will have the from
address rewritten by gmail. That is why the reply-to address is added to
the email and that makes private addresses work also through gmail (if
the receiver wants to reply then the correct address will be used).
One issue he can run into is if he sends an email without uploading his
email data to the server. If the server does not know the from-address
then that field will be empty when it reaches the smtp server. I use my
own postfix smtp server and messages without a from address are normally
treated as spam and rejected.
If I would use gmail then the from field will be rewritten to the logged
on users address. So, the message that lacks a from field automatically
gets a from-field (but an incorrect one) and the reply-to field is only
optional so the message will get sent.
I guess that is the issue here, pse have him try again but make sure he
uploads some email data (at least an email address) before.
We could also discuss wether we should send the from field with every
message, it would help avoid situations like these. But, for pskaprs
email we do need that users email address. We could also have the server
reject messages when the server has no data about the user.
73 de Per, sm0rwo
sön 2012-04-29 klockan 07:25 +0200 skrev Franz Rohrauer:
> Hy Robert,
>
> tnx for your mail, very interesting!
>
> the only difference in the configuration of oe5rtl to other
> pskmail-servers may be the smtp-server. My server uses an austrian
> smtp-server, but many others use gmail.com.
>
> the reason is, that, using gmail.com, mail-clients show the servers
> address (oe5rtl@xxxxxxxxx) as sender-address but using the austrian
> smtp-server causes, that mail-clients show the correct mail-sender
> address. But, so I also can see, using the austrian smtp-server may
> result in SPAM-alerts at recipient's incoming-server or mail-client
>
> If it's better, I move to an other smtp-server, but I wouldn't like to
> move to gmail.com (redundance, because if gmail.com stops service,
> pskmail is stopped also!).
>
> Any idea?
>
> vy 73 de
>
> Franz, oe5rtl
>
> Am Samstag, den 28.04.2012, 19:16 -0700 schrieb Robert Krasowski:
> > I am in contact with Tadeusz SP8DXZ, who as far as I can see is the
> > only Polish user of PSKmail. He started discussion forum about
> > PSKmail, and as expected has a lot of questions:
> >
> > The one that I can not answer is:
> > "Servers 9A1CRA, DL4OAH-8 i SA6BQZ-1 accept "private" email address,
> > but SM0RWO, DK4XI-3 i 8, OE5RTL i PI4TUE does not...so that servers
> > probably required address assign by Inretmar like
> > callsign@xxxxxxxxxx ."
> >
> > Hmm that is strange I am not sure if that is correct. He said that if
> > he try to set up his private address as return address he gets error
> > message. I asked him to send ma a copy of his log and we will see what
> > is the problem.
> > Does that make sens to you??
> > Robert
> > KB2PNM
> >
>
>
>
Other related posts:
