Care Beyond Cure
* ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ *
! September 2018 !
* ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ *
August 31, 2018
IN AUGUST, THE STATE OF KERALA IN INDIA SAW UNPRECEDENTED FLOODS, DESTROYING
NUMEROUS HUMAN LIVES AND DISLOCATING OVER ONE MILLION PEOPLE.
People who already have serious health related suffering, and who now
developed health issues, are particularly vulnerable in this situation. So are
those with disabilities, and children and the elderly. Many were rescued, but
without their essential medicines, and with no access to them. Some lost their
health documents. There is also the possibility of communicable diseases that
may ravage our people in the coming weeks. The task of long-term rehabilitation
of patients who need palliative care is tremendous. Pallium India is making
special efforts to reach out to them, as much as we can.
We can achieve this only by working closely with the government
machinery, which, we are proud to say, has been doing an excellent job. We also
shall work closely with the civil society (again, a matter of pride to us, the
people of Kerala have been simply magnificent in reaching out to those to need
WE NEED MANPOWER – NURSES, DOCTORS, SOCIAL WORKERS AND VOLUNTEERS, PARTICULARLY
WITH TRAINING IN PALLIATIVE CARE. AND WE NEED MONEY.
PLEASE READ HOW YOU CAN HELP: LET US NOT LEAVE THEM ADRIFT
Thank you, everyone who has chipped in to help. And thank you, Mr
Unnikrishnan from Save the Children, who are helping us by sharing their
experience and helping us with advice and technical knowhow.
A MONTH OF LOSSES [HTTPS://PALLIUMINDIA.ORG/2018/08/A-MONTH-OF-LOSSES/]
_Dr. M. R. Rajagopal, Chairman of Pallium India, writes:_
What a month for losses!
First, the shock of the worst floods in a century in Kerala with about
1 million people in relief camps. And then came the news of the death of two
people, who had for many years enriched my life as well as that of numerous
people in palliative care.
One was Subair – Subair who came to us as a patient some 23 years back
with a broken life and a story of stepwise amputations of his lower limb due to
cancer; the financial destruction which sent his children to an orphanage;
agonising pain which could be controlled on fairly high doses of morphine;
rehab with a coffee vending machine which gave him back his life and
livelihood, reuniting the whole family. A tower of strength, he inspired other
patients and families and all he came across.
This man demonstrated with his life
, how to overcome adversities. When he found that his experience with pain
management and with morphine could be a learning point for others, he always
went out of his way to tell his story to those who needed that learning,
including doctors and medical students. Much has been written about him; he was
also filmed by Moonshine Agencies in Australia and by others. He finally
succumbed to his ailments on 25th August, 2018.
Soon afterwards, we heard about the sudden demise of another of our
fellow-travellers, Rahna from Nilambur.
She too had been our friend for about 20 years. She had pain from a
cruel disease called chronic calcific pancreatitis.
_(Image: Rahna [in green] with her mother Sainaba)_
Rahna taught us forbearance and her whole family taught us lessons in
integrity [https://www.facebook.com/raja.gopal.92798/posts/10213590011079604] .
Both Subair and Rahna not only consented to having their photographs
made public, but also had asked us to make their stories known if they will
Thank you, Subair and Rahna. Rest in peace!
UNION HEALTH MINISTRY AMENDS DRACONIAN MCI GUIDELINES
In a major victory for candidates with disabilities aspiring to become
doctors, the Union Health Ministry amended the controversial Medical Council of
India’s (MCI) guidelines debarring admissions to people with specific
disabilities. 75 doctors with disabilities from across the country had
submitted representation to frame new guidelines.
_Read News in DNA:
Dr Satendra Singh, who lead this advocacy group had also filed writ
petition in the Supreme Court appealing to quash these guidelines. The ministry
in its response to the SC query accepted the MCI guidelines with several
amendments benefiting candidates with disabilities. The ministry rejected the
MCI recommendation that learning disability is not quantifiable. Upholding the
assessment guidelines notified earlier by the Ministry of Social Justice, the
Health Ministry allowed people with learning disabilities (dyslexia) of 40% or
more to pursue medical education in disability quota which were earlier not
eligible in previous guidelines.
The Health Ministry acknowledged the representation of ‘Doctors with
disabilities’ on record which cited instances of individual doctors with more
than 80% disability in India (many of these were signatories) who excelled in
their disciplines in spite of the disabilities which would otherwise have been
not allowed by MCI.
Dr Singh said, “It was a major embarrassment to the AIIMS
rehabilitation ‘expert’ who limited the abilities of people with disabilities
up to 80% only. This has been amended now to provide equal level field to such
candidates to excel in medical profession.
_Medical Dialogues has covered the story in detail and can be read at:_
VERY GOOD NEWS: MD PALLIATIVE MEDICINE IN GUJARAT
We are very happy to hear, though from unofficial sources, that Gujarat
Cancer Research Institute (GCRI) in Ahmedabad has been given permission by
Medical Council of India to start MD in Palliative Medicine.
This makes GCRI the third institution in the country to offer this
course, the first being Tata Memorial, Mumbai, and the second being All India
Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi.
Hearty Congratulations to Dr Geeta Joshi, Dr Priti Sanghavi and their
team for this achievement. Best Wishes!
TELENGANA PAVES THE WAY
Our colleague in Vizag, Dr Vidya Viswanath reports: "
“Telangana state has now 8 functional palliative care centres out of 31
planned, one for each district. Each centre consists of 8-10 inpatient /
hospice facility in the government hospital and a dedicated home care service.
Each of these centres are run by full-time staff consisting of one doctor, 5
nurses, one physio, 2 MPHW, 4 helpers and a driver. All of them have done 6
weeks training in PC and are exclusively meant for PC.
How I wish we were still the united state of Andhra Pradesh !!
But let us hope that this stimulus from Telengana will facilitate and
pave the way for well organised palliative care services in Andhra Pradesh too.
Salute to Dr Gayatri and team for making this happen, and setting an
DR Y K HAMIED AMONG 20 GLOBAL INDIANS
Would the world have been the same today if Dr YK Hamied had not made
low-cost HIV medicines available throughout the low-income world?
Would the palliative care scene in India have been the same if he had
not made low-cost oral morphine available in the 1990s?
We are so glad that he has been listed among the 20 global Indians
VACANCY: MEDICAL OFFICER AT AHMEDABAD, GUJARAT
Karunalay Cancer Palliative Care Center, Ahmedabad, Gujarat invites
applications to the post of Medical Officer (with interest in palliative care).
ELIGIBILITY: MBBS. Palliative care training and experience is preferred
but not mandatory.
SALARY: at par with the hospitals in the city, and as per years of
experience post MBBS.
Located in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, for over 6 years, Karunalay Cancer
Palliative Care Center is a specialized center giving supportive care of a
hospital along with the love of a home. It has outpatient facility as well as
10-bed inpatient services. The center is run by Shyam Oncology Foundation, and
provides palliative care free of cost. Visit: www.shyamoncologyfoundation.org
To apply, send detailed CV to: hitesh.dutt1@xxxxxxxxx
For further details, contact: 07926754002; 9898831496
PREPARE TO READ SOMETHING REALLY UGLY!
A few weeks ago, we had shared with you the report from Times of India,
describing an ugly face of medicine: Health spending pushed 55 million Indians
into poverty in a year
The World Bank reports show that catastrophic health expenditure
affected more than 80 million families around the world. Rather obviously, the
beneficiary is the healthcare industry.
Now read on; here is something really ugly and frightening:
Harrison’s Principles of Internal Medicine
[https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/article-abstract/1389591] , now in its
20th edition, is a must-read for medical students and young internists. It has
been called “the most recognized book in all of medicine.”
According to a recent study
[https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23294515.2018.1436095] , authors
for Harrison’s received more than $11 million between 2009 and 2013 from makers
of drugs and medical devices — not a penny of which was disclosed to readers.
One author, a physician, during that period received nearly $870,000 in
funding, including for research, according to ProPublica’s Dollars For Docs
database of payments to doctors from drug companies.
Can we help wondering how facts might possibly get distorted? What
would medical students all over the world be learning? Scientific facts, or
their horrible distortions?
MORE ABOUT WITHHOLDING/WITHDRAWING LIFE SUPPORT:
The Supreme Court of India’s verdict on 09 March 2018 provided legal
validity to advance directives, though we did have a few concerns. (_Read: A
welcome verdict; and a few concerns
Close upon the heels of that verdict comes a judgment by a five member
bench of the Supreme Court of UK which says “ Life support can be removed
without courts if doctors and families agree
This is of course relevant only to the UK; but we could not help
observing that it makes a lot of practical sense. This does not rule out the
need to go to court in controversial issues; but makes every day practice
compassionate and fair.
“HIPPOCRATIC” SCREENED IN GUJARAT
The documentary film “ Hippocratic: 18 Experiments in Gently Shaking
” was screened in Karamsad and Ahmedabad, Gujarat on July 7 and on July 8,
The screening at Pramukhswami Medical College, Karamsad, was followed
by an interaction session with Dr M. R. Rajagopal. Dr Bhalendu Vaishnav (HoD,
Medicine), Dr Alpa Patel (HoD, Anesthesia & Pain and Palliative Care Services)
and Dr Priyanaka Srivastava (Consultant Oncologist) were the other panelists
who interacted with the audience. The panel discussion was co-ordinated by Dr
Uday Shankar Singh (HoD, Community Medicine). About 140 participants
participated in the event, including staff and students of the institute,
volunteers, community members and healthcare providers from other institutes.
This event was preceded by two screening sessions for students from
medical, nursing and physiotherapy, and were attended by around 150 students.
Our congratulations and gratitude to Dr Dinesh for organizing these
In Ahmedabad, the screening was organised on July 8, 2018 by The
Gujarat Cancer Society, Gujarat Cancer & Research Institute, GCS Medical
College, Hospital & Research Center.
The program was attended by caregivers, patients, medical students and
palliative care supporters. There was a question-answer session, following the
screening of the film. Eminent oncologists participated in the discussion. It
was a great opportunity for palliative care physicians of Gujarat to meet
pioneers like Dr M T Bhatia and Dr M R Rajagopal.
Kudos to Dr Geeta Joshi, Dr Priti Sanghavi and team, who worked hard to
organize the event and for making it a grand success.
EVEN A SAFETY PIN CAN PALLIATE!
_Sumitha T. S., Project Executive at Pallium India, writes:_
On July 14 and 15, 2018, Vyshnavi (Project Officer, Pallium India) and
I visited Dr Zachariah Mar Theophilos Memorial Palliative Care Unit at
Thadakam, Coimbatore, Tamil Nadu, to observe the services they provide and to
determine how to assist them.
Thadakam is about an hour away from Coimbatore town; a calm space in
the middle of the forest and the Sahyadri. On our way to Thadakam, I heard Dr
Ani repeatedly warning Shaji, who was driving the car, about elephants which
emerge from the forest at night. Our rooms were so cool we did not even need
Dr Ani is an ENT specialist from Ernakulam and a disciple of Dr
Zachariah Mar Theophilos who was quite known for his humanitarian works. In
his fond memory, she initiated Dr Zachariah Mar Theophilos Memorial Palliative
Care Unit at Thadakam, about a year ago. Dr Ani regularly travels from
Ernakulam to Coimbatore to take care of the patients. The team in Bishop Walsh
Memorial Hospital supports her in all possible ways in this endeavor.
The next morning, we started early for home care with Dr Ani, Shaji, a
volunteer and a nurse.
The first house we visited was in 2 km radius but it was hard to find
even any teashops nearby. There was a woman ironing clothes with traditional
iron box outside the house. Seeing us, she called her mother-in-law. Inside the
house, we saw her 83 year old father-in-law lying on a bed, unable to move
himself but conscious and oriented. After listening to them, we suggested the
use of water bed to prevent bed sores. Fortunately, Reena, the volunteer who
always accompanied this team could arrange water bed the very next day. It was
evident that these parents were worried their children were suffering because
of their illness. For some reason, they were not receiving elderly pension and
that added to their problems.
After giving him medicines, Dr Ani asked the man if he wanted anything.
We all smiled when he replied that he wanted fruit juice.
We moved on to the next house. By this time, Shaji had bought some
breakfast which we gave to the woman who was seated on the floor of the house.
She was struggling to fix her blouse with a safety pin. We helped her fix her
dress with our safety pin, as Dr Ani said, “please give her a pin; that is
palliative care now.” This mother in her early 70s has to crawl on the floor to
move. She had femur fracture, after a fall. One of her sons gives her food.
Finally, Shaji managed to find a shop from where we had strong tea.
Almost all the patients we visited on that day were elderly, some even 100
years old, in similar conditions. Some of them found it difficult to reach
their bathrooms which were commonly built outside, at a distance from the
house. In addition to medicines, some of them were given rice, pillows, sheets,
and a lot of love and time to be listened to.
We saw a polio-afflicted middle aged woman who could walk only with
support, who said that she just wanted to sit in her home and does not want to
go out to see anything. Another patient was a middle aged man, who cried like
anything when he saw us. He sat in a wheelchair and could not move his limbs.
His wife and her parents took care of him. Though regular physiotherapy was
improving his condition, they were not able to afford it. The team then decided
to arrange regular physiotherapy for this patient and some training for his
wife to earn a living.
Let me emphasize here that most of these patients are bed-bound and
home care is the only solution we can offer them. I realized the importance of
home care after visiting these patients who otherwise would have been ignored
due to accessibility, affordability and availability.
We owe a lot to Dr Zachariah Mar Theophilos Memorial Palliative Care
Unit, Dr Ani, Shaji, Reena and the nurse for their incredible work in helping
the patients who would have left this world suffering needlessly, if not for
these caring souls.
FROM BEDSIDE TO FRUIT STAND: A CULTURAL EXPLORATION AT PALLIUM INDIA
Vijayvardhan Kamalumpundi, a student from University of Iowa who
visited India a few months ago, published a narrative about his experience with
Pallium India in Trivandrum. Please read…
DIVERSIFICATION & PARTNERSHIPS IMPROVE MENTAL HEALTH CARE
By Chitra Venkateswaran, IAHPC newsletter
Dr. Chitra Venkateswaran (4th from left), Clinical Director of Mehac
Foundation, with staff.
Learning, as we know, has no end. When we set up the not-for-profit
Mehac Foundation nearly a decade ago, our initial focus was to evolve long-term
care models for mental health based on the widespread community-oriented
palliative care movement in the South Indian State of Kerala. Kerala is known
for its impressive social indices and social awareness, so the initiatives have
We incorporated mental health care pathways in existing palliative care
services and sought to build robust clinical services structures. This past
year, we recorded significant growth not only in our clinical services but in
other, diverse directions, in keeping with the dynamism that stakeholders
demanded from us.
PALLIUM INDIA HAS SHIFTED TO VATTAPPARA
Pallium India has shifted its inpatient / outpatient clinics and
training centre to Vattappara, Thiruvananthapuram.
The new address is:
Pallium India Trust,
_To reach the new location from Vattappara junction (click on the image
_Close to the main entrance of PMS dental College, take a turn to the
left. You will find us in about a hundred meters._
Pallium India has also opened an office for administration and accounts
(donation) at LIC Junction, Pattom, Trivandrum. The address is:
HOUSE NO. 24, SUHUDA MANDIRAM,
SIVAMANGALAM LANE, LIC JUNCTION,
PATTOM PALACE P.O.,
FOR MORE INFORMATION, PLEASE CONTACT BABU ABRAHAM (9746745502) OR
INFORMATION CENTRE (9746745497).
[HTTPS://SMILE.AMAZON.COM/CH/47-4504650] SUPPORT PALLIUM INDIA INC BY SHOPPING
AT AMAZON SMILE! [HTTPS://SMILE.AMAZON.COM/CH/47-4504650]
When you shop at AmazonSmile, Amazon will make a donation to Pallium
Support us every time you shop!
DONATE TO PALLIUM INDIA [HTTP://PALLIUMINDIA.ORG/DONATE]
The money you give will pay for essential free medicines for the poor,
for their travel to the clinic or for schooling of their children, or other
forms of care.
PLEASE GIVE WHATEVER YOU CAN. NO AMOUNT IS TOO SMALL.
To donate, please visit:
http://palliumindiausa.org/ [http://palliumindiausa.org/] (USA)
Write to us: info@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Call us: +91-9746745497 (India) / +1-718-273-8597 (USA)
_ All donations to Pallium India are tax deductible._
UPCOMING EVENTS [HTTP://PALLIUMINDIA.ORG/COURSES/]
* SEP 3, 2018: 6 weeks certificate course in palliative medicine and
nursing (CCPPM, CCPN) at Trivandrum. Register: http://palliumindia.org/courses/
[http://palliumindia.org/courses/] Contact: education@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx /
8589998760. Last date to apply: Aug 21
* NOV 5, 2018: 6 weeks certificate course in palliative medicine and
nursing (CCPPM, CCPN) at Trivandrum. Register: http://palliumindia.org/courses/
[http://palliumindia.org/courses/] Contact: education@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
[mailto:education@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx] / 8589998760. Last date to apply: Oct 23
* DEC 7-8, 2018: 14th World Congress of Bioethics and 7th National
. Venue: St. John’s National Academy of Health Sciences, Bengaluru, Karnataka
560034. Last date to submit abstracts: Sunday, April 8, 2018. Pre-conference
workshop on December 3-4, 2018.
Have Queries? Contact: info@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Find out more about our courses at: HTTP://PALLIUMINDIA.ORG/COURSES/
JOIN OUR FACEBOOK PAGE [HTTPS://WWW.FACEBOOK.COM/PALLIUMINDIA]
Pallium India’s Facebook page has over 8000 Likes.
We regularly post articles related to palliative care from around the
Click here to Like our page [https://www.facebook.com/palliumindia] !
We’re also on Twitter: @palliumindia [https://twitter.com/palliumindia]
PALLIATIVE CARE INFORMATION CENTRE [HTTP://PALLIUMINDIA.ORG/INFO-CENTRE]
Contact Pallium India’s Information Centre (9 am to 12 noon) for
information related to palliative care and about establishments where such
facilities are available in India.
or E-mail: info@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Address: VP 80/13, Golden Hills, Venkode P.O., Vattappara, Thiruvananthapuram
For more details, please visit: http://palliumindia.org/info-centre/
102 not out [https://palliumindia.org/2018/08/102-not-out/]
[https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6580564/] No; it is not about cricket.
This Hindi movie [https://www.imdb.com/title/tt6580564/] is on another
game. The game of life. And of death.
This game teaches you about accepting reality. And making life life;
not a living death. Played by Amitabh Bachchan as a 102 year old man, and Rishi
Kapoor as his 75 year old son.
Whether or not you accept everything the movie tries to convey (you
might feel inclined to give the lead character a lecture on unconditional
love), it does impart some powerful messages. It makes you wish you could
handle life the way the leading character does.
A MUST-SEE, IF YOU ASK US. EVERY SINGLE MINUTE OF IT IS ENJOYABLE.