Here's what I'm talking about, wrt a need for a license from the TV networks. Note how in the early, days, before these CATV nets had their own non-OTA content, only the FCC needed to give the okay. I don't see any mention of the CATV system having to obtain permission from the networks? To get the dates about right, proper MVPDs didn't start until the 1970s, mostly late 1970s. Before then, we're talking about relaying FOTA content. So it seems to me that the main "license" to operate had to do with getting FCC approval, and that was only VERY LATE in the game (1965). CATV systems had been operating since the 1950s, with no such restrictions from FCC or anyone else. My claim is that Aereo is similar to THESE systems, or the even less controversial building antenna systems, far more than Aereo would be similar to an MVPD. The FOTA TV broadcast signals are not being used to help lure people into lucrative proprietary walled gardens, as they are in MVPD nets. The TV broadcast signals are used "as is." Bert --------------------------------- http://www.fcc.gov/encyclopedia/evolution-cable-television The Federal Communications Commission first established rules in 1965 for cable systems which received signals by microwave antennas. In 1966, the Commission established rules for all cable systems (whether or not served by microwave). The Supreme Court affirmed the Commission's jurisdiction over cable in United States v. Southwestern Cable Co., 392 U.S. 157 (1968). The Court ruled that "the Commission has reasonably concluded that regulatory authority over CATV is imperative if it is to perform with appropriate effectiveness certain of its responsibilities." The Court found the Commission needed authority over cable systems to assure the preservation of local broadcast service and to effect an equitable distribution of broadcast services among the various regions of the country. In 1972, new rules regarding cable television became effective. These rules required cable television operators to obtain a certificate of compliance from the Commission prior to operating a cable television system or adding a television broadcast signal. The rules applicable to cable operators fell into several broad subject areas -- franchise standards, signal carriage, network program nonduplication and syndicated program exclusivity, nonbroadcast or cablecasting services, cross-ownership, equal employment opportunity, and technical standards. Cable television operators who originated programming were subject to equal time, sponsorship identification and other provisions similar to rules applicable to broadcasters. Cable operators were also required to maintain certain records and to file annual reports with the Commission concerning general statistics, employment, and finances. In succeeding years, the Commission modified or eliminated many of the rules. Among the more significant actions, the Commission deleted most of the franchise standards in 1977, substituted a registration process for the certificate of compliance application process in 1978, and eliminated the distant signal carriage restrictions and syndicated program exclusivity rules in 1980. In 1983, the Commission deleted its requirement that cable operators file financial information. In addition, court actions led to the deletion of pay cable programming rules in 1977. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.