At 11:11 AM -0800 11/24/04, Dale Kelly wrote: >*Not* a legacy issue until such a platform is widely available and can be >implemented and understood (operationally) by the average TV viewer. >However, I do agree that such a system is likely the ultimate solution but >not likely in the near term. When I said legacy issue, I was implying that the CE vendors are desperately holding onto the home entertainment "legacy" that they helped to create. A legacy of components that can be interconnected and controlled using dumb remote controls that depend on "programming the consumer" not the devices. All of the "logic" is inside our heads, not inside the machines. For example, even with a multi-function remote control, you will still need to switch the TV/monitor input manually to the DVD player, and most likely adjust the volume, and possibly the display mode to optimize the presentation. These selections will be much the same, every time you decide to switch from watching TV (cable/DBS/OTA) to the DVD player, Tivo, or VCR. But this "logic" must be programmed into the user, not the devices. My wife and father-in-law still cannot master these simple "programming steps." So when they want to watch a DVD or tape, they call on me to push the buttons... Now imagine having DVD, Tivo, and VCR icons on your "set-top" along with icons for the TV channels you watch most often... Or a system as smart as my Powerbook, that puts the DVD controller and video window up on the screen when I put a DVD movie into the drive... Regards Craig ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.