At 1:48 PM +0100 5/4/04, Alan Roberts wrote: >It's up to the producer to decide how to handle wider formats. They can be >cropped, pan-scanned, or letter-boxed. All options are available. But 14:9 >isn't available as an image shape for delivery in digital TV in the UK, only >16:9 is, and that's what this argument is about, right? Actually, the argument is about the relevance of aspect ratio constrained formats for the future of digital media. IMHO the only relevance is that there will be a limited number of screen aspect ratios produced for consumers due to economies of scale issues. Even this will give way once we can buy seamless image tiles and place them on the wall to form displays that conform to the whims of interior decorators. I had to laugh recently while looking at the latest offerings during our annual parade of homes. It is becoming quite popular to place a display above the fireplace in the Great Rooms in many of the upscale homes we toured. What i could not figure out is why the contractors framed ut these spaces with aspect ratios that are closer to 1:1 than 16:9... To make room for all of the set top boxes? Also, satellite radio appears to be a "must have" for distribution over the structured wiring system, with speakers in rooms throughout the home. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.