In looking at the following news story it brings up some questions. As BobMiller and Mark Schubin have related in the testing in Mark's apartment in NY they mention that they taped the antenna to the window or placed it near the TV set. With the STUPID notion that the FCCset in law and the INDUSTRY allowed to happen stations could choose to stay on their ANALOG VHF frequency assignment instead of moving EVERYONE to UHF, as was done in Europe. We can never have a successful DTV off-air system with a mixture of VHF and UHF in the same city. What is the worst problem with 8-VSB? Yes it is multi path. And at what frequency is multi path the worst? Yes it is with the lowest frequency VHF channels. And there are additional technical problems with the LOW VHF channels that has be discussed before. BUT NO I suppose that some stations selected their low frequency VHF channels. CBS with many stations on Channel 2 has announced they would wait for the second round of channel selections and pick another channel. Tribune also said they would select a frequency in the UHF band and not stay on theirlow channel VHF present assignment. Hey Mark you want to put a LOW VHF frequency directional antenna in your living room? Yes folks might be happy to install a small UHF TV band antenna on their roof. Cheap and small. How many want to put up a VHF antenna? Did any broadcaster reading this now on LOW band VHF select this channel for their permanent assignment? MARK: Did all the NY low band stations select a UHF channel so you do not need a low band VHF antenna in your apartment? But WAIT Bert will try to tell us this is NO problem. Regards, Bill Hogan DTV channel election advances[1] Jun 17, 2005 8:00 AM, RF Update e-newsletter The FCC last week advanced the process used to assign television broadcastersto their permanent in-core DTV channel and create a Final DTV Table of Allotments. On June 8, the Media Bureau released an order approving 25 Negotiated ChannelArrangements (NCAs) and rejected 12 others. An NCA lets stations within a market enter into an agreement to elect channels other than their own, provided that every station potentially affected by the move is in agreement. Working to meet a timeline established last summer by commission order, more than 1700 television broadcasters filed their channel preference for final DTV operations by February. Of those stations, 1628 chose to use their existing NTSC or digital channel. Fifty chose to forego the first round in the channel election process. Sixty-two stations participated in 37 NCAs filed with the FCC. Stations that are approved will receive tentative channeldesignations for the channels contained in the agreements; the stations participating in the rejected NCAs reverted to their alternate channel elections and were considered during general Round One conflict analysis. Last week, the commission also sent about 155 letters to stations that elected their NTSC channel for digital operation but an FCC engineering analysis indicated that it would result in impermissible interference. The stations have 60 days to inform the FCC how they will resolve the interference conflict. The commission will complete Round One later this summer and commence Round Two elections in the fall. For more information, visit www.fcc.gov[2]. --- Links --- 1 http://broadcastengineering.com/newsletters/rfupdate/20050617/FCC-channel-election-20050617 2 http://www.fcc.gov ---------------------------------------------------------------------- You can UNSUBSCRIBE from the OpenDTV list in two ways: - Using the UNSUBSCRIBE command in your user configuration settings at FreeLists.org - By sending a message to: opendtv-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word unsubscribe in the subject line.