[odamex-bug-reporter] [Bug 862] New: SDL Framework version performance conflict

  • From: odamex-bugtracker@xxxxxxxxxx
  • To: odamex-bug-reporter@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
  • Date: Sat, 16 Jun 2012 07:25:34 +0000


             Bug #: 862
           Summary: SDL Framework version performance conflict
    Classification: Unclassified
           Product: Odamex
           Version: 0.6-dev
          Platform: All
        OS/Version: Mac OS
            Status: NEW
          Severity: major
          Priority: P1
         Component: Client
        AssignedTo: odamex-bug-reporter@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
        ReportedBy: mwoodj@xxxxxxxxxxx

When OS X 10.7 Tiger released an API change was introduced that caused a crash
with SDL apps when switching to fullscreen mode or starting in fullscreen mode.
The issue was "resolved" by changing a significant amount of the Mac fullscreen
code in SDL and the changes were released with SDL 1.2.15. Unfortunately the
new code path is not as fast and it pretty much turns Odamex into a slideshow
on older Macs when running in fullscreen. My test platform is a 1.42Ghz G4
PowerPC. While Odamex 0.5.6 (SDL-1.2.14 bundled) runs well in fullscreen on it,
even at 1680x1050, Odamex 0.6.0 (SDL-1.2.15 bundled) is unusable in fullscreen
mode. Simply swapping the old SDL framework into Odamex 0.6.0 makes it perform
the same as the previous versions on this hardware.

I created a thread on the libsdl forums describing the issue. It can be viewed
here: http://forums.libsdl.org/viewtopic.php?t=8196

Short of this issue being resolved by the libsdl guys a decision has to be made
on how to proceed with the Mac releases. Here are some options that I have come
up with:

1) The game "Battle for Wesnoth" (great game) modified the Mac fullscreen code
to use the old code path in OS X 10.6 and earlier and the new code path in
10.7+. I dropped this framework into 0.6.0 and it worked pretty well except for
one issue. Apparently the Wesnoth guys also made a change to the windowed code
that improves framerate but it also can cause Odamex to crash when the
resolution is changed and part of the window ends up off the screen. Changing
resolutions in fullscreen mode is not an issue. Using this framework would be a
bit of a compromise. I could ask the Wesnoth guys for their SDL code and
attempt to fix the crash as well.

2) I can essentially do the same merge between the two versions of the
fullscreen code myself. This is not an immediate solution as there is a lot of
code in the patch that fixed the original crash and there is Objective-C in it
(which I have worked with but am no expert on). It will take me some time to be
able to cleanly produce an acceptable framework. It also has to be considered
that this would not be the official framework and that makes it a troublesome
long term solution.

3) We can start releasing 2 Mac builds. One would be a universal build (ppc,
x86) for 10.4 - 10.6. The second would be for x86 10.7+. I'm not sure if
Sourceforge has the ability to default to a release based on OS version but
that would be the optimal way to handle this solution.

I do not think we should stop supporting 10.4+ or PowerPC in our releases but I
also don't think we should be claiming we support them when the performance is
so bad. The best thing would be for this to be fixed in SDL but I hope we can
come up with an acceptable solution in the meantime.

Configure bugmail: http://odamex.net/bugs/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are the assignee for the bug.

Other related posts:

  • » [odamex-bug-reporter] [Bug 862] New: SDL Framework version performance conflict - odamex-bugtracker