Hindu Justifies Mass Killings of Muslims in Reprisal Riots

  • From: "Muslim News" <editor@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: <submit@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Wed, 6 Mar 2002 08:44:10 -0000

AHMEDABAD, India — Harish Bhai Bhatt is a jolly-looking man with a round
belly and a bushy mustache that turns up like a smile, but his words
would chill the soul of any Muslim in India.

To receive your Muslim News in Arabic, send an email to
ishtirak@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word "subscribe" in the subject or
body, or visit http://www.muslim-news.net
According to Mr. Bhatt, a firebrand leader of the fundamentalist World
Hindu Council, killing hundreds of innocent Muslims in the past five
days of rioting was necessary. All Muslims had to be taught a lesson
after a Muslim mob burned a train loaded with the council's members,
immolating 58 people. 

"Now, it is the end of toleration," he said, a revolver on his hip. "If
the Muslims do not learn, it will be very harmful for them." 

Mr. Bhatt's words cannot be dismissed as empty threats. The council's
workers are widely thought to have helped instigate the riots that have
killed more than 500 people, mostly Muslims, since Thursday — though
council leaders deny it. 

The council is part of the same Hindu nationalist family as the
Bharatiya Janata Party, which rules this state, Uttar Pradesh, and heads
the national governing coalition. Despite calls from Muslim and secular
political leaders to ban the council and arrest its leaders, senior
party leaders have tried in the last few days to strike a
behind-the-scenes bargain with the council — so far without success. 

Today the council defied Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee's wishes
and vowed that on March 15 its workers will begin building a temple to
Ram, the manly incarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu, on the site of a
mosque demolished by Hindu zealots in the north Indian town of Ayodhya.
The trainload of Hindus attacked by Muslims on Wednesday were returning
from a ceremony that precedes the raising of the temple. 

The council's temple crusade, the most incendiary issue in Hindu-Muslim
relations, has the potential to cause more riots. It also presents the
Bharatiya Janata Party with a moment of reckoning. Will it do as its
secular allies require and stop the council from erecting hand-carved
pillars at Ayodhya on March 15? Or will it waver when confronted with
arresting council members, and even firing on them, as they defy court

The party's second-most-powerful leader, Home Minister L. K. Advani, led
the movement for a temple on the site of the Babri mosque culminating in
its destruction in 1992 and the worst Hindu-Muslim rioting since the
nation was created in 1947. 

The temple crusade was pivotal in the party's rise to power. It
polarized the Hindu-Muslim vote and helped consolidate support from
Hindus, who are usually politically fractured on caste lines. 

Twelve years ago, Mr. Advani defied Prime Minister V. P. Singh and
refused to accept that the temple could be built only if the courts
ordered it or the Muslims agreed to it. 

The party withdrew from Mr. Singh's coalition on this issue, causing his
government to fall. Mr. Singh savored the irony this weekend as he sat
cross-legged in his home in New Delhi. He said he warned party leaders
at the time, "Someday you'll sit in this chair and you'll have to say
the same things." 

Sure enough, on the very day the train burned last week, Mr. Advani told
council leaders that the temple could only be built if the courts
ordered it or the Muslims agreed to it. 

The council's true believers feel a sense of betrayal at Mr. Advani's
shift. Ashutosh Varshney, author of a book about Hindu-Muslim conflict
in India ("Ethnic Conflict and Civic Life," Yale University Press,
2002), said the recent riots were rooted not just in the desire to teach
Muslims a lesson, but in the Hindu right wing's desire "to throw a
challenge to Vajpayee's moderate political stance towards Ayodhya and
Hindu-Muslim relations." 

The Hindu nationalists, tainted by the 1992 riots, had prided themselves
on the relative peace during their years in power. The riots here
shattered that claim. 

The failure of the police here to protect Muslims from rampaging Hindu
mobs has prompted many to charge that the state's chief minister,
Narendra Modi — a hard-core Hindu nationalist — cynically allowed the
riots to happen. 

Alluding to recent election losses by the party, Shabana Azmi, a Muslim
member of Parliament, said, "Modi wants the rioting and arson to
continue because he believes this will consolidate the Hindu vote bank."

The violence has physically scarred this city of 3.5 million, but the
corrosive anger of the Muslims will be even harder to repair. About
3,000 Muslims who fled their homes are living on the cement floors of a
school. These refugees in their own city seethe with rage and grief. 

Mahboob Bee, who sat on the floor holding 6-month-old Afsana on her lap,
said she was separated from her husband, a mutton seller, and their 2-
year-old daughter in the chaos of the mob attack. She has no idea
whether they are alive. 

As word spread that Hindus were trying to destroy the local mosque,
Salima Bano's 18-year-old son ran out of the house toward the action.
Mrs. Bano arrived in time to see him lean to pick up a stone, only to be
hit by a policeman's bullet. 

The battle was so fierce that Mrs. Bano was afraid to take her son to
the hospital. Instead, she took him home, where he bled to death. 

As the surviving residents of Naroda-Patia gathered round to talk, the
men were angriest. Their hands shook and their eyes teared as they
spoke. They said they knew the man who led the mob that attacked them.
His name was Bipin Panchal and he was a local rickshaw salesman and a
World Hindu Council supporter. 

"If there's anybody responsible for this incident is it the police and
Bipin," said Abul Hasan Ansari, whose paintbrush franchise was wiped out
in the fires. 

In different parts of Ahmedabad, Hindu, Muslim and Sikh residents have
said in interviews in recent days that the council and its youth wing,
the Bajrang Dal, had fomented and in some cases led the riots. 

Mr. Bhatt, vice president of the state branch of the World Hindu Council
and all-India vice president of the Bajrang Dal, denied that the groups
participated in the riots, even as he justified the killing. 

He proudly described himself as "the first enemy of Muslims" and posed
with a three-pointed trident — actually a vicious-looking knife — that
each Bajrang Dal member is given. 

Source:  New York Times

You can choose whether you prefer to receive regular emails or a weekly digest 
by visiting http://www.muslim-news.net

Archive: http://archive.muslim-news.net

You can subscribe by sending an email to request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word 
"subscribe" (without quotes) in the subject line, or by visiting 

You can unsubscribe by sending an email to request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx with the 
word "unsubscribe" (without quotes) in the subject line, or by visiting 

You are welcome to submit any relevant news story to submit@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

For regular Islamic cultural articles by email, send email to 

Other related posts:

  • » Hindu Justifies Mass Killings of Muslims in Reprisal Riots