Bush Welcomes Saudi Proposal on Mideast Peace

  • From: "Muslim News" <editor@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: <submit@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Wed, 27 Feb 2002 22:28:35 -0000

Bush Welcomes Saudi Proposal on Mideast Peace

WASHINGTON, Feb. 26 — President Bush thrust himself into the Mideast
peace effort today, calling Crown Prince Abdullah of Saudi Arabia and
publicly praising his proposal for Israel to withdraw completely from
the West Bank and Gaza in return for full normalization of relations
with all Arab countries.

The administration also said it was growing more enthusiastic about the
prospects of a major Saudi role in the peace effort. Though President
Bush's spokesman, Ari Fleischer, characterized the proposal as short of
a "breakthrough," he said, "The president praised the crown prince's
ideas regarding the full Arab-Israeli normalization once a comprehensive
peace agreement has been reached." 

Some administration officials said they were less impressed by the
content of the Saudi proposal — "It's not a plan, it's a vision," said
one — than by the symbolism of having a leading Arab state, the
caretaker of Islam's most treasured sites, put forward a plan that would
lead to full normalization of relations with Israel.

They cautioned, however, that for decades, successive Israeli
governments have rejected calls for a withdrawal to Israel's pre-1967
borders, and they were unsure how Prime Minister Ariel Sharon would view
a long-term plan at a time of such rapidly intensifying violence.

Palestinian officials have reacted favorably to the Saudi proposal,
which has not been spelled out in detail yet, but Mr. Sharon has made no
public comment. After a meeting with the Israeli leader today, Javier
Solana, head of foreign and security policy for the European Union, said
Mr. Sharon considers the Saudi plan "an interesting idea."

The Palestinian leader, Yasir Arafat, after his meeting today with Mr.
Solana on the Saudi concept, announced, "I cannot say no to Solana's
suggestion," and dispatched his team to Tel Aviv to discuss ways of
lowering the level of violence. 

Mr. Solana said he would travel to Saudi Arabia on Wednesday to meet
with Prince Abdullah, who first put forward his proposal last week. On
Friday, Secretary of State Colin L. Powell initially called the Saudi
statement a "minor development," but on Monday he upgraded it to an
"important step." 

After his return from Asia, Mr. Bush decided there were numerous
advantages in embracing the Saudi vision, if not its still-vague

"This is the first time we've heard any nation in the region talk about
full normalization between Arab nations and Israel at the end of the
peace process," one senior administration official said. "The president
decided that he had to embrace the moment." Other officials and
outsiders noted possible benefits for Mr. Bush.

Embracing the Saudi proposal helps the president counter critics who say
the administration's hands- off approach to the Middle East for much of
its first year only worsened the cycle of violence. 

It also helps to change the subject with the Saudis: Mr. Fleischer said
today that Mr. Bush and Prince Abdullah never discussed what Saudi
Arabia was doing to root out extremists, and never mentioned the
investigation of the Sept. 11 hijackers, 15 of whom were raised in Saudi

Moreover, with Vice President Dick Cheney scheduled to leave for the
Middle East in two weeks to describe the president's reasons for wanting
to oust Saddam Hussein in Iraq, an embrace of the Saudi plan could give
Mr. Bush some diplomatic leverage by softening Saudi objections to
bringing pressure on Mr. Hussein.

American support could also change the tone of the next Arab League
summit meeting, scheduled for March 27 in Beirut, Lebanon, when the
Saudi proposal is likely to be actively debated. That debate may now
drown out criticism of Prime Minister Sharon.

"By legitimating the Saudi initiative, which they had to do, they have
changed the context of this coming month," the Mideast scholar Stephen
P. Cohen said today. 

"It is significant because for all these years, the Arabs have always
been clear in spelling out the territory side of `land for peace,' but
studiously silent on the peace side of `land for peace.' "

Still, the White House made clear today that it would take a long while
for the Saudi proposals to play out. 

"It's important to have a vision for what peace should look like at the
end of the day," Mr. Fleischer said, "but it's a long time until the end
of the day in the Middle East."

He added that the president still believed that it was important for
both sides to follow the "Mitchell process" to bring about peace,
followed by political and territorial talks. The process is named for
its author, the former senator George Mitchell, but it never got beyond
its first stages before street violence cut it short. Mr. Mitchell's
intention was to halt violence on both sides to build enough mutual
confidence to support diplomatic talks between Isarael and the
Palestinian Authority. 

Mr. Bush's entry onto the state came as American-brokered security talks
resumed between Israeli and Palestinian officials in Tel Aviv, with
hopes swelling after Saudi Arabia's surprise proposal. The concept,
which threw the weight of the Saudi kingdom behind Mr. Arafat at a time
when Israel has grounded and humiliated him, heartened the Palestinians,
but Palestinian officials are still waiting to hear from Mr. Sharon.

"His reaction was very positive," said a senior lieutenant of Mr.
Arafat, Nabil Abu Rdeineh. "We support and welcome the Saudi initiative,
and hope it will lead to a breakthrough in the Middle East. The problem
is that we hear nothing from Sharon. We need to hear from the Israeli

Another senior Palestinian official, Saeb Erekat, said, "We believe that
this is the most significant and strategic idea that came from the Arab
world since the convening of the Middle East conference in 1991, and I
really hope that the American administration will concentrate on the
strategic concept of the ideas and not go into the details of any

But Prime Minister Sharon remained wary, and made no public comment on a
plan that revived demands for an Israeli withdrawal far greater than the
Israeli right could agree to, and so threatened to put him on the

After meeting with Mr. Sharon, Mr. Solana said the prime minister
"considers it an interesting idea and he would like to know more about
the content, and he would like to meet anybody from Saudi Arabia,
formally, informally, publicly, discreetly, whatever, to get better
information about this initiative."

Despite Mr. Sharon's reserve, centrist members of his cabinet seemed
heartened by what commentators described as the first concrete peace
signal in 17 months of unmitigated violence.

The defense minister, Binyamin Ben Eliezer, said the plan "should be
looked at positively," according to his spokesman. "It has new elements,
and it should therefore be encouraged and must not be rejected."

On Monday the Israeli president, Moshe Katzav, said he was prepared to
go to Riyadh to discuss the plan, or to welcome Prince Abdullah in
Jerusalem. The plan was also being discussed in Paris between the
Israeli foreign minister, Shimon Peres, who has welcomed it, and
President Jacques Chirac.

From Lebanon came cautious but significant support for the Saudi's
proposal. The foreign minister, Mahmud Hammud, said the ideas "grow out
of concern for long-held Arab positions and the demand for Israeli
withdrawal from all Arab lands."

The importance of Mr. Hammud's statement lay in the fact that Syria
holds effective authority over Lebanon. 

Syria has made no direct comment on the proposals but the Lebanese
response suggested that Damascus could fall in line behind the plan if
one of the conditions was the return of the Golan, which Israel occupied
in 1967.

Source: New York Times

You can choose whether you prefer to receive regular emails or a weekly digest 
by visiting http://www.muslim-news.net

Archive: http://archive.muslim-news.net

You can subscribe by sending an email to request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx with the word 
"subscribe" (without quotes) in the subject line, or by visiting 

You can unsubscribe by sending an email to request@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx with the 
word "unsubscribe" (without quotes) in the subject line, or by visiting 

You are welcome to submit any relevant news story to submit@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

For regular Islamic cultural articles by email, send email to 

Other related posts:

  • » Bush Welcomes Saudi Proposal on Mideast Peace