Torgeir just sent some thoughts on Adam Gopnik and Karl Popper. Over a dozen years ago, Gopnik wrote something about Popper, which originally appeared the April 1 2002, of *The New Yorker.* This is the article to which Torgeir refers. I posted a link to it to whatever list we were then, and commented on some of Gopnik's remarks, which were not entirely about Popper's thought, but also about Popper himself, drawn from conversations between them. Gopnik did not present Popper as an easygoing, tolerant man. This drew a caustic reply from Donal, who sent the list a sharp response, upbraiding both Gopnik, and me; Gopnik for his uninformed bigotry, and me—well, me for my gullibility, if not worse. Here's the link again. http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2002/04/01/the-porcupine Robert Paul