> > If he were as good a teacher as he was a philosopher, I don't think he'd > agree > with your reading of the marginalia. You missed a good opportunity to > clarify > your thought for him and then see what his response would have been. > Sarcasm > and rhetorical questions do not belong in professional feedback to > students on > their work. > I had a professor in a Philosophy course who, at the end of my 25 page essay simply put a 'B' with no comments throughout the entire paper. I went to him and said "Well, how can I get a better mark?" And he said "Write a better paper." My response was "Meaning what, precisely!" I never got any kind of an answer. 19 years later, I still fondly remember him as an obtuse asshole! paul