> I simply posted a link with information. sorry. I misunderstood. > On the surface the Qld Uni film thesis idea looked distinctly unethical to > me. I've not seen anything to disabuse me of this view It's 'on the surface' with me too, there are some possibly crucial facts I don't know, but still I am amazed the Ethics Committee passed it. > Notwithstanding the fact that it appears that at least one of the two > suspended academics (ackas in the australian vernacular) was an obnoxious > type I got that impression from the Australian links you posted, yes. I still think that 6 months without pay is too high a price to pay > for views expressed robustly and for minor treachery in publishing half > factoids about ones employer in a national newspaper. Here tenure contracts (the few that still exist) contain a 'bringing the university into disrepute' clause, so I could see this or worse happening here. I was once told formally re not even a public offence, not to criticise the university's modular degree policy; the Power That Be who said it also devised the first year course on which I taught, major thinker, J S Mill, major topic, freedom of speech... . > This and the fact that one of the suspended tenured scholars is claimed to > be an unreconstructed marxist Yes, I noticed the 'issues' about that Judy Evans, Cardiff ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html