Andy Amago writes: "Living in the new land as if it were the old *is* fantasizing about returning to the old. The problem is that living a fantasy keeps people stuck." Curious and so very 'You are either with us or against us'. I suppose you think Chinese restaurants and cheering for Man. United are bad things? Andy continues: "I wonder how many return and find the ideal they think they left." Very few but that makes my point, not yours. That is, one can't live in the new country as one did in the old so living in the new country requires changes. These changes often make it near impossible to happily return to the old country. Again, Andy: "Your French are like our Texans. A whole 'nother country, still fighting the Alamo. At least on the History Channel." And again, your comments make my point. Few Quebecois would think that they are returning to the ideals of France. I am sure M. Chase can better describe what the French think of the Quebecois. This whole 'fantasizing about the old country' bit strikes me as being part and parcel of the American homogenization of culture. So we return to the curious situation you find yourself in when you, at the same time, think that differences are to be celebrated and rejected. Or perhaps it is that the differences ought to be Americanized like Taco Bell? Either way it seems like a shame because something important is being lost. Sincerely, Phil Enns Toronto, ON ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html