Richard Henninge proposes a variant to Geary's statement. Geary's statement: "The supposition that presuppositions influence a writer's work is a common one and, I suppose, it presupposes the supposition that presupposition is the soul of all knowledge since nothing can be proven -- or so I presume." Henninge's variant proceeds by replacing each occurrence of Geary's 'presuppose' by 'suppose' (and vice versa). The result: The presupposition that suppositions influence a writer's work is a common one and, I presume, it supposes the presupposition that supposition is the soul of all knowledge since nothing can be evidenced--or so I suppose." --- One problem here is in the 'pose' (as in "Henninge proposes"). The Latins (or, rather, Romans) thought it translated Greek, 'thesis'. Thus, anti-thesis, became 'contra-positio'. You have to grant that 'pre-suppose' is LONGER than 'suppose' (cfr. Grice, "Be brief" -- a conversational maxim). I would go further and say that the _sense_ of 'presuppose' INCLUDES that (in a Fregean way) of 'suppose' (cfr. 'coffee-maker' which includes the sense of 'coffee'). The 'sup-' in 'suppose' is possibly otiose, in that one does say, 'he posed an interesting question'. The idea that you do this in a covert way ('under', Roman: 'sub') is gratuitous. There is a temporal sense in 'prae-' (as in 'prae-sub-positio') but this temporal sense can be other than temporal, as when the Romans called the front garden (as opposed to their back garden), 'prae'. "Prae" is what _is_ before in more than just a temporal sense. When L. Helm uses 'presupposition' he is thinking Collingwood. Or not of course. For Collingwood, the KEYWORD in his metaphysics is 'presupposition', since he saw that since a philosopher cannot do science (he was an amateur British Roman archaeologist) he can at least study the presuppositions (of this or that). Helm extends the Collingwoodian sense of 'presupposition' to wonder if Carroll applies as a 'minor' or 'great' figure in what Leavis calls 'the tradition'. Cheers, Speranza ------------------------------------------------------------------ To change your Lit-Ideas settings (subscribe/unsub, vacation on/off, digest on/off), visit www.andreas.com/faq-lit-ideas.html