[lit-ideas] Bush Tackles Homelessness?

  • From: "Stan Spiegel" <writeforu2@xxxxxxxxxxx>
  • To: <lit-ideas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>, "David Cowen" <Davidcowen@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>, "Margaret Spiegel" <MSpiegel@xxxxxxx>, "Alisa Kay Spiegel" <ASpi1298@xxxxxxx>, "Stan Spiegel" <writeforu2@xxxxxxxxxxx>
  • Date: Tue, 10 Oct 2006 23:40:48 -0400

Did you ever hear of anything more hilarious? The big guy really knows how to 
play the game, doesn't he? 

October 11, 2006
Far From Big City, Hidden Toll of Homelessness 
TRINIDAD, Colo. - As the Bush administration promotes a widely praised 
multibillion-dollar effort to end chronic homelessness in cities like 
Washington and San Francisco, a growing outcry is rising from rural areas that 
worsening problems far away from urban centers are being overlooked.

Rural homelessness has always taken a back seat to the more glaring problems in 
cities. Most studies estimate homeless people in small towns account for about 
9 percent of the 600,000 or so homeless nationwide. But local officials and 
advocates for the homeless in small towns say that economic distress in recent 
years, including closing plants, failing farms, rising housing costs and other 
troubles, has left more people without homes and in greater need of help. 

Real numbers are hard to come by because most rural areas, where homeless 
services often means ad-hoc help from church groups or volunteers, are far 
behind a parade of cities taking head counts. 

"We are concerned that the focus on chronic homelessness may have the 
unintended consequence of shifting services away from families and rural 
communities," said John Parvensky, executive director of the Colorado Coalition 
for the Homeless, one of several groups pushing the federal government to turn 
more attention to rural areas.

Among the homeless here is John Lobato, who offered a tour of his surroundings 
- the abandoned shuttle bus where he sometimes sleeps, the makeshift assortment 
of pallets, mattresses and blankets where he and other men pass time, often 
drinking, and the Purgatoire River, where he bathes. 

Sometimes he takes his medicine for schizophrenia, Mr. Lobato said, sometimes 
not. Sometimes he sobers up for a while, but then the bottle calls.

"I know I need help," he said, before embarking on a search for a liquor fix at 
midday in this isolated town 180 miles south of Denver. "But I don't know where 
to get it."

Until recently, many small towns like Trinidad coped with those who panhandled 
or set up makeshift encampments in the woods with what Lance Cheslock, director 
of La Puente, a shelter in Alamosa, near here, calls "Greyhound therapy." They 
handed out bus tickets. 

"They just send them up to the cities and let them deal with the problem 
there," said Mr. Cheslock, among the advocates pushing for a new way to finance 
rural homeless programs.

The growing visibility of the problem has made some towns reconsider that 
attitude and push for local solutions, although they can be expensive and 

Rural homelessness "doesn't get enough attention," said Philip Mangano, the 
executive director of the United States Interagency Council on Homelessness and 
the Bush administration's chief coordinator of homeless services. But Mr. 
Mangano said the problem had been difficult to assess because rural communities 
by and large had not chronicled their problems with the data-heavy planning 
documents the Housing and Urban Development Department and other federal 
agencies increasingly demand.

"Like any profile of the homeless, there is a lot of anecdote and hearsay, but 
you need data and research to create policy," Mr. Mangano said.

To confront the problem, he cited the examples of Washington and Michigan, 
where every county, many of them rural, has committed to writing a plan to end 

Here in Trinidad, a former old West coal town of 9,000 near the eastern slopes 
of the Sangre de Cristo mountains, people have long struggled through hard 
times. The downtown is pockmarked with shuttered storefronts, but new cafes and 
galleries have opened as the town tries to refashion itself as an artists' 

Interstate 25, dotted with motels of various quality and shopping centers, 
slices through Trinidad, leaving tidy Victorian homes rising on a hill on one 
side and modest ranches, several in disrepair, on the other. 

Sandi Espinoza, who directs the Open Door Soup Kitchen, in space borrowed from 
a church, said the organization was serving more meals than ever - families, 
veterans, men just released from prison and a wide assortment of people 
smelling of liquor before noon. Some 85 people come daily for lunch, double the 
number from a few years ago, Ms. Espinoza said.

"We need shelter here," said one wobbly man, who when asked where he sleeps, 
replied, "down under the bridges."

There is no homeless shelter, only a few drug, alcohol or mental illness 
treatment programs for the indigent, and a loose group of church pastors, 
volunteers and other concerned citizens striving to look after people who have 
no home.

"Pastor helps me out," Mr. Lobato said. "The soup kitchen helps me out and 
these guys" - he motioned to his disheveled companions - "help me, too."

A couple of weeks ago, officials here cheered the establishment of a 
"transitional housing unit," a single-family home leased from the government 
for $1 a year where a displaced family can live for a year or so until they get 
back on their feet, the first such project started here. The organizers say 
several families, doubled up with relatives or friends, need a place like that. 

There is nothing for the men living in the tents and shacks that have popped up 
behind the Wal-Mart, near the river. 

To seek more stable solutions, a small group was recently formed. With guidance 
from Becky Vanderslice, an organizer with Housing Justice, a group based in 
Denver, they gathered around a church conference table and discussed problems 
that included the need for rehabilitation programs and families unable to make 
ends meet. 

Finally, said Cary T. Nelson, pastor at First Christian Church, the group 
decided to start with the single-family home. Churches and volunteers will 
subsidize the costs of running the house, a foreclosed property held by the 
local office of the federal Agriculture Department.

They called the house Haven of Hope and have begun searching for a family to 
occupy it. One applicant, Brenda Holguin, said she hoped to move in with at 
least two of her four children, who are living with her estranged husband. A 
domestic dispute has left her homeless, living in a nearby domestic violence 
shelter, and such a house would help set her on a steady path, Ms. Holguin 
said. "Having a house, my family in one place, would give me more self-esteem," 
she said. 

Ms. Espinoza, who runs the soup kitchen, said she was hoping that local 
businesses or churches would step forward with donated space for an emergency 

The National Coalition on Homelessness, an advocacy group, is considering 
mounting an effort to make the Agriculture Department, with its many field 
offices and staff members in rural areas, the lead agency for financing 
homeless programs outside urban areas. The task currently falls to the 
Department of Housing and Urban Development. 

"It should be the department of housing and urban-only development," said 
Michael Stoops, the executive director of the coalition. "We should not give up 
on HUD, but we need to get other federal agencies involved." 

Last year, he said, HUD provided $120 million for 700 projects in rural areas, 
an amount that has remained constant for several years, federal officials said. 

This year, the federal government has increased direct spending on homeless 
programs to about $4 billion, up from $2.9 billion and double the spending of 
five years ago. About 10 percent of that has gone toward a new focus on ending 
chronic homelessness, Mr. Mangano said. 

The approach has fired up hope in Denver, San Francisco, Washington and other 
cities that headway is being made, but it has dismayed advocates in rural 
areas, where grant-writing expertise and the Talmudic knowledge of federal 
regulations are lacking.

Small towns also lack the network of nonprofit organizations and corporations 
that often underwrite efforts.

"The government wants matching funds and the big city funders only fund the big 
cities," said Donna Haddow, a member of the Trinidad-Las Animas County Economic 
Development Board. "There's nothing left by the time we come knocking."

Ms. Vanderslice of Housing Justice said a prominent foundation would not 
finance the new housing program in Trinidad because it had decided to focus 
most of its resources on Denver.

"There is a lot of money to end homelessness in the state," she said. "But a 
lot is going to the Denver metro area because the mayor there has a 10-year 

Here, she added, "they are going on open faith."

The message is ready to be sent with the following file or link attachments:
Shortcut to: 

Note: To protect against computer viruses, e-mail programs may prevent sending 
or receiving certain types of file attachments.  Check your e-mail security 
settings to determine how attachments are handled.

Other related posts: