This stuff is well known Mike. Wahhabism originated in Saudi Arabia in the 18th Century. Salafism came along later. They were both Fundamentalist in nature. Maududi wrote and was very influential in the days before and after Pakistan became an independent nation. The Muslim Brothers, influenced by Wahhabism, were influential about the same time in Egypt. Sayyid Qutb was a Muslim Brother. The Shiite equivalent was just as influential if not more so through the work of Khomeini. Islamism is a (if not the) predominant religious viewpoint in the Middle East. It is not a small fringe belief held by a few radicals. Osama bin Laden is but one follower of the teachings of Sayyid Qutb. Yes, in earlier times Islam was more peaceful, but we don't live in those times. However, you are mistaken in arguing that Islam was more peaceful than Christianity or Judaism. Islam has always been militant. It encountered Judaism and Christianity by conquering nations that held those beliefs. Muslim slaughtered Christians for about 200 years before the first crusade was launched to regain the Holy Lands. Colonization of the Middle East? What are you talking about? Algeria was colonized by the French but that is the only nation in the Middle East that was colonized to the best of my recollection. I hope you aren't saying that Israel was a colony. Do you want to know whom we are fighting when we are fighting back? We are fighting against the Militant Islamists who have declared war against us. You must have noticed that they have been attacking us. Their attacks escalated until 9/11 and then we decided to fight back. You must have missed it. So you think these people who have declared war against us and attacked us are innocent people? That is an interesting viewpoint but difficult to prove. Someone attacking you, your family, your friends or your allies isn't normally going to come across as innocent. Iraq not the enemy? Iraq had a Baathist form of government influenced by Nassar which advocated Pan-Arabism. This was the modern equivalent of the Ummah advocated by Mohammad. The Ummah doesn't have borders. It is one people. Saddam sought to achieve Pan-Arabism. It was his ambition and he pursued it with diligence until he was at last stopped by UN forces in 1991. He was stopped but hadn't given up his dream. And you think Saddam and his Sunni Baathists innocent? One needs a hefty set of blinders to believe that. Baathists and Islamists had roughly the same goals. They disagreed as to who ought to run things. Islamism and its Baathist equivalent is organized murder. It is evil. It wholeheartedly needs to be opposed. Lawrence -----Original Message----- From: lit-ideas-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:lit-ideas-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Mike Geary Sent: Saturday, June 24, 2006 4:23 PM To: lit-ideas@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [lit-ideas] Re: Aren't you glad you no longer have a Hitler problem? LH: >>Read Sayyid Qutb. He has written voluminously. Qutb came to the US and >>studied at a college in Colorado where he developed a negative opinion of >>Americans. They are a decadent people.<< Well, yes, according to his strictures we are. Does that surprise you? So too are we according to Jerry Falwell and Pat Robertson and most the far right Christians. >> But his opinion isn't what modern Leftists would have us believe today. >> 9/11 wasn't a response to anything the US did. It was a response to what >> the US is - a nation of infidels. All infidels must convert or be >> destroyed.<< Sayyid Qutb might believe that, but Islam doesn't. Over the centuries Islam has been far more tolerant of other beliefs than Christianity which has slaughtered and assaulted both Jews and Muslims for over a thousand years. >>There is no other way as far as militant Islam is concerned.<< Bullshit. Until Western nations started colonizing the Middle East there was no problem. STOP THE COLONIZATION OF THE MIDDLE EAST!!! GET IT???? >> As far as some of us in the US are concerned, however, there is another >> way. I know you won't approve, but it's called FIGHTING BACK.<< Fighting back? Fighting whom? People who had nothing to do with the assault on America? That's who we're fighting. Innocent people. This war is a gross injustice. A travesty. A crime against humanity. >> It's tough to do with so many in America routing for America's enemies << The people of Iraq are NOT our enemy. Get that through your thick head. The people of Iraq are NOT our enemy. Al Qaeda is. We gave up that fight 3 years ago to invade Iraq in pursuit of cheap oil. Can't you see that? Iraq has nothing to do with your would-be enemy Sayyid Qutb. Admit it, Lawrence, the Bushies got it all wrong. Admit that 2500 American soldiers have died for a neo-con fantasy, that tens of thousands of Iraqis have died in the name of General Motors. It's all wrong, Lawrence. There's no moral justification for our killing Iraqis. It's murder. It's evil. Amen. Mike Geary Memphis