We've been through this discussion before. You may have missed it before. Summarized is that if we kept on discussing what would be cool, what is "absolutely needed" (as defined by each person on this list) - the discussions would go on, arguments would continue, and nothing would be settled. Every single component of BeOS needs to be replaced. One thing that is absolutely agreeable is that fact. A well defined goal is needed. Now there is the goal, in and of itself. What comes after is on everyone's minds, as we all know that there is more needed in OpenBeOS for its success. And just because the line has been drawn with re-creating BeOS as it existed in R5 doesn't mean that OpenBeOS ends there. There is a future, but one must keep the present close in mind. For those that want to think ahead a bit further, that is the topic of GE. :) Deej > What's the use of resurrecting the BeOS with out providing more > features and applications that other Operating Systems is providing > already. For an end user the most important thing is his/her work > should get done and for that there are many operating systems with > many applications already available. What is that killer thing that > OBOS guys can provide that non of the other Operating systems are > providing right now. Absouletly nothing... Even when BeOS was alive > there wasn't much hope and nobody was ready to invest in writing > applications also.. > > Anil Joy > > >if you have this question, it might be best if you look at > >Atheos or one of the other hundred million OS projects > >that try to create something new. > > > >every year groups of people try to create something new > >and none that i've seen are very notable... > > > >besides, i think the idea as everyone clearly points out here, > >is to first recreate what was, and then extend upon that in > >new cutting edge ways. > > > >besides, quite a few (if not many) of the ideas from BeOS > >are still quite "cutting edge". > > > >-soco > > > > > > > > > -- Donovan Schulteis BeUnited deej@xxxxxxxxxxxx "One OS to rule them all, One OS to find them, One OS to bring them all and in the darkness bind them, In the Land of Redmond where the Shadows lie."