On Tue, Oct 13, 2009 at 02:47, Ryan Leavengood <leavengood@xxxxxxxxx> wrote: > First, a disclaimer: this is my personal opinion, let anyone confuse > it with my involvement with Haiku, Inc, which among other things is > supposed to protect the Haiku trademark. Also this is a bit long, so > please bear with me. Now on with the show: > <snip> +1 here. > 3. If someone tweaks an existing release of Haiku, they can distribute > that under another name as a Haiku Remix (or whatever we want to call > these.) The system itself can still use Haiku logos and trademarks, > but it must be clearly labeled as a Remix at the download site. There > should also be an alert message at first run indicating it is a Remix > based on a particular Haiku release, and why it was created. People > who create Remixes should be willing to work with the project or > provide suggestions on how we can improve Haiku so that the Remix is > not needed in the future. > My only concern or disagreement is about which settings are permitted to be modified. I think it should be strictly limited to * Locale specific changes, such as Keymap, Fonts. * Accessibility options (not that we have any in place yet) * Settings that target specific hardware, like a netbook: Screen, Mouse/Touchpad However, changing settings that modify the unique feeling of Haiku, should not be permitted: * Tracker : Trash vs Delete, Spatial vs. Single, Disks Icon vs. Volumes (as there are numerous bugs in Disks Icon mode), * Modifier keys (Ctrl vs. Alt). The only exception I could think of is if the alt & ctrl keys are in physical different locations on generic 105/104 keyboards. Another alternative, is what i'm labeling "Customization Packs". A 3rd party takes an official iso/image/vmdk and inserts an archive of sorts into a pre-determined location inside the image file. When an end-user goes to install said image, Installer will display the Customization Pack in the Optional Packages frame. This mechanism could even take precautions to ensure that the system/ and other sensitive folders remains unchanged (aside from possibly updating AboutSystem, replacing haiku_loader, or similar changes). This could encourage 3rd parties to create packs that could then be approved by our developers and possibly included in the the official images. --mmadia