[haiku-doc] Re: Machine translation (was: Re: Wiki for translation/localization teams)
- From: Miguel Zuniga <mzuniga@xxxxxxx>
- To: haiku-doc@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
- Date: Sun, 01 Nov 2009 09:04:41 +0300
Today, Friday 31st, 2009, 3:56p, Sean Healy wrote:
>Double posting this to the development and doc lists
>
>Star's seed wrote:
>> I tested a translation software software to
>> translate the documentation: OmegaT (java / gpl)
>
>Machine translation is nowhere near good enough to provide adequate
>translations
>of arbitrary text. Especially considering that one of the desired target
>languages
>is Hungarian, which doesn't even belong to the same language superfamily as
>English, and is significantly structurally different.
>
>(...)
>
>Essentially, this is a lot of work up front. But IF we can get it all set up,
>and
>IF our doc writers stick to the restrictions, then it's fully automated
>afterward,
>and any >updates to the English docs are immediately reflected in the target
>languages. So it's >either a lot of work up front, or little bits of work every
>time a change is made to keep >the translations up to date.
>
>So it depends on what resources the doc team has, and where it's willing to
>spend
>those resources.
Even though the translation uses "Simple English" (as in
http://simple.wikipedia.org/), Pragmatics play a very important role. The same
word (although simple) can have more than one "plain" meanings, depending on
the context: "save" has two different meanings when in a game or in a word
processor.
This machine-translation had been used by SIL (http://www.sil.org/) in order to
translate documents to many languages. They found out that if you add "Good"
plus "night" you do not get the meaning that "Good night" conveys in many
languages: that intention is not put with those words.
(http://users.elite.net/runner/jennifers/gnight.htm)
Extra consideration must be had in the "value" that "night" has: for example,
evening/night does not consider the same time amounts between Indoeuropean
languages, please, do not expect it to happen in other languages. Also, there
are times when a word is "plain", but it cannot be next to some others: they
convey together rude/pejorative/sexist/unappropriated meanings.
When people translate to a foreign language, we occasionally make mistakes (or
we use phrases that just are not natural although you understand them). You can
tell immediately when we are not native speakers. When you see our messages you
see my point.
Please, give a second (and a third) thought in this matter. It would be a shame
to give a bad impression, even when it has very good intentions. Me think your
consideration will play a better band (as another example).
Thank you.
Miguel Zúñiga
Other related posts:
