Esteemed colleagues, It was a pleasure meeting some of you next Tuesday, but today I got a letter from a friend asking to learn about fundraising from me. I ended up writing the following, and hope that this is the right forum to discuss things like this online! If not, I would appreciate being pointed to said right forum. Your suggestion to learn how to collect charity effectively by studying texts related to the collection for the daily korbanot is interesting to say the least. I actually happen to have a little experience with fundraising for Jewish causes, and in fact am presently employed by one, but I never heard nor thought to look to this source for instruction. At most, perhaps, for inspiration:-) As a de facto professional fundraiser, I would first say that the very terminology of "collecting" is perhaps still used among the charedim-ultra orthodox, but is an anachronism for others. When your potential pool of givers thinks of his donation as a requirement and as the fundraiser as an agent, simply doing the service of collecting, then it is suitable, I guess. But from my experience, since the palm shakers are many, the potential givers do not consider them as an integral part of the community, a veritable hired hand, so to speak. If no one would "collect," then motivated givers would find the way to get their donation to the organization or individual in need of their choice. Modern fundraisers in my opinion, are not even that, people who have a cause that they are affiliated with and one way or another "raise" funds for that cause. People today, potential donors, are inured to the tens of thousands of causes all vying for their money. I think such modern professionals would either see themselves as "friendraisers," people who catch the attention of people who heretofore knew nothing of the cause, and with their permission educate them about it, raise their awareness about it, and little by little recognize the more interested ones. Then, the professional puts on the hat of the "funraiser," enabling the friend to feel good and associate the cause with social activity and fun. Once these positive experiences and feelings are associated with the cause, the friend will feel an inner urge to accept partial ownership for the cause or any of its projects, and therefore donate to it as surely as he or she would "donate" to their own child's health and wellbeing. At that point, in fact, we come full circle, and the fundraiser truly does go back to being the "collector," the agent of both the donor and the cause to assist the former in getting his or her donation to the latter. If the system that you have been using works for you, then I guess you should continue with it. Not every lemonade stand needs to strive to become The Coca Cola Company. But I think that someone motivated to help both the cause and the world of donors owes it to themselves and to both of the other players to learn the modern theories and methods, keep up with the industry, and always stay real. Thanks, Gidon Ariel Director of Foundations and Special Projects Zichron Menachem 054-5665037 gidon@xxxxxxxxxxx