My understanding is Trish, that there is to be no off-topic discussions, just books. I think there has been a small amount of confusion recently as we've been moving lists, but this should be all sorted out now. I quite like the idea of an open discussion where we can attach books we are chatting about, but if this is going to cause problems for other members with the volume of emails I'd rather cut it down to just the monthly book rather than have to lose anyone because they were put off by the amount of messages. Shell.