Hello again, In general I agree about televised or filmed books. I gave up after the third or fourth Harry Potter film, saying to Himself that had I not read the book it would have been difficult to follow the film - it was so condensed and compressed. A colleague said the same about the film of lovely Maeve Binchy's "Circle of Friends". The two exceptions for me are "To Kill a Mocking-Bird", where I saw the film which made me want to read the book. The adaptation made me angry once I knew that in the film the shooting of Tom is by accident, whereas in the book it is deliberate. Likewise, I started watching the "Inspector Wexford" series and that made me want to read the books by Ruth Rendell. I gather that often the problem is that the telly gobbles up the books so fast that often the later episodes and runs of a series are only based loosely on the original characters; this happened to the wonderful "Dalziel and Pascoe", they filmed faster than the brilliant reginal Hill could write, and also "Midsomer Murders". Am not sure but I think Caroline Graham only wrote six books featuring Inspector Barnaby but there are more than 14 series. (What is the plural of series?) Caroline also wrote a glorious crime pastiche called "Murder At Madingley Grange" which I adored. Not recommended for the plane or train unless you want to embarrass yourself with the giggles, and no blood or other gruesome details. Elaine