Classification: UNCLASSIFIED Caveats: NONE Hey All Thought I throw some more ideas out there for the 5th Challenge. (1) predict melting temperature Martin S. suggested this and certainly this is a critical property for the DoD community. Brute force approaches are as simple as standard molecular dynamics. Other more accurate methods would require ~1.5 months of coding for a clever grad student. Both the Maginn and dePablo groups are active method developers in this area. This Challenge would test both the model and the method used, which may not be good though. (2) problem exclusively for mesoscale and/or coarse-grain simulation Mesoscale and coarse-grained simulations are becoming more active areas of research so you might gain interest from this community. Possible properties would be the viscosity or density of a high molecular weight polymer, so that a mesoscale or highly coarse-grain approach would be required (and not a molecular scale approach). Mesoscale codes such as dissipative particle dynamics can be downloaded from the Frenkel and Smit text or easily coded from an existing molecular dynamics code. (3) problem for the biological community In the biological community most folks use standard codes but are required to make decisions about choice of forcefield and level of coarse-graining. Again possibilities properties might be density or viscosity. Not sure how other non-simulation approaches would be applicable to these Challenges, perhaps Idea (2) would be a fit. Just some thoughts. John ------------------------------------------ John K. Brennan Weapons and Materials Research Directorate U.S. Army Research Laboratory Aberdeen Proving Ground, MD 21005 phone: 410.306.0678 fax: 410.306.1909 ------------------------------------------ Classification: UNCLASSIFIED Caveats: NONE