Kin, Erich,
Thanks for the great start on architecture!
I have a similar feeling with Erich: Can we add a bit more on novelty.
Specifically, my reading is that the current architecture claims three
"unique" issues:
- First, SDC for coalition forces consists of multiple enclaves and
security is a main issue
- Second, contrast with traditional SDN, the proposed SDC with multiple
enclaves, ... thus forming the hierarchy of control planes
- Third, both control and data planes within an enclave can be fragmented.
I feel that the first two, security and the need of intradomain +
interdomain, might be considered as standard. One
possibility is to shorten the issues a bit and focus more on what we plan
to explore, model and compare.
For 3, could we use a different way to argue: we see novel opportunities in
SDC, e.g., control-plane repair?
Richard
On Sun, Jul 19, 2015 at 1:29 AM, Erich M Nahum <nahum@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Hey Kin,
I think this is a very nice step. I have only a few suggestions.
- In the last paragraph, I would put (2) ahead of (1) in the listing,
since architectures are the focus.
- Also in the last paragraph, I think mentioning UAVs so explicitly is too
specific. I would use something like "mobile resources" or "mobile assets"
with some examples (e.g., UAVs, robots, troops, etc.).
- As I'm seeing in a lot of the writeups, what the innovation is is not
well specified. This is somewhat inherent in such a broad concept as
architectures. Is our "innovation" that we are going to explore, evaluate,
and determine the proper architectures for SDC?
-Erich
From: "Leung, Kin K" <kin.leung@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
To: Erich M Nahum/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, Prithwish Basu <pbasu@xxxxxxx>
Cc: "CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx" <CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx>, Dinesh
Verma/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, "flavio@xxxxxxxxxx" <flavio@xxxxxxxxxx>, Franck
Le/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, ITA Lab/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, "
leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx" <leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx>, "sguha@xxxxxxx"
<sguha@xxxxxxx>, Ting He/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, "towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx" <
towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx>, "yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx" <yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx>,
"Dearlove, Christopher (UK)" <chris.dearlove@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, "
alan.m.cullen@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx" <alan.m.cullen@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: 07/17/2015 08:17 AM
Subject: RE: Invitation: DAIS ITA Project 1: Proposal preparation
-- Toll-free USA: 1-888-426-6840 Toll-free UK: 0800-368-0638 Passcode:
54670842 (Jul 16 10:30 AM EDT)
------------------------------
Dear Erich and colleagues:
Per your suggestion, I have just finished the first draft on SDC
architectures in the attached. As said, I have not done research on SDN
architectures… So, I am not sure if I make sense or if I miss something
important there. As usual, your comments and suggestions are welcome.
Dear Richard, I am sending this to everyone instead of iterating between
us individually because we are running out of time soon and I would like to
solicit comments from all colleagues as quickly as possible. However, your
comments and ideas are particularly appreciated.
I am copying this to our colleagues (Chris Dearlove and Alan Cullen) at
BAE as their ideas about security may be relevant to the third-party
enclaves in the SDC architectures. Their feedback and suggestions are also
welcome.
Thanks.
Regards,
- Kin
*From:* Erich M Nahum [mailto:nahum@xxxxxxxxxx <nahum@xxxxxxxxxx>]
* Sent:* 16 July 2015 14:11
* To:* Prithwish Basu
* Cc:* CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx; Dinesh Verma; flavio@xxxxxxxxxx; Franck Le; ITA
Lab; Leung, Kin K; leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx; sguha@xxxxxxx; Ting He;
towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx; yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx
* Subject:* Re: Invitation: DAIS ITA Project 1: Proposal preparation --
Toll-free USA: 1-888-426-6840 Toll-free UK: 0800-368-0638 Passcode:
54670842 (Jul 16 10:30 AM EDT)
Hey all,
One thing to realize is we have 4 pages for the technical component.
Given our four innovations, that means roughly 1 page per innovation.
References don't count and can be placed at the end.
The template is Times 10 point, so I suggest you work in that font to keep
an eye on space.
-Erich
From: Prithwish Basu <*pbasu@xxxxxxx* <pbasu@xxxxxxx>>
To: Franck Le/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, *CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx*
<CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx>, Dinesh Verma/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, Erich M
Nahum/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, *flavio@xxxxxxxxxx* <flavio@xxxxxxxxxx>, ITA
Lab/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, *kin.leung@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx*
<kin.leung@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, *leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx*
<leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx>, *sguha@xxxxxxx* <sguha@xxxxxxx>, Ting
He/Watson/IBM@IBMUS, *towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx* <towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx>,
*yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx* <yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx>
Date: 07/16/2015 12:09 AM
Subject: Re: Invitation: DAIS ITA Project 1: Proposal preparation
-- Toll-free USA: 1-888-426-6840 Toll-free UK: 0800-368-0638 Passcode:
54670842 (Jul 16 10:30 AM EDT)
------------------------------
Hi Ting, Richard, Don, and others,
Following our discussion during the last telecon and over email, I added
some text to Ting's writeup with track changes on.
I added some material on controlled mobility and fundamental limits. For
the latter, I tried to address the heterogeneity concern raised by ARL in
their review when talking about percolation theory. We may need to iterate
on this text.
Unfortunately, I will have to miss tomorrow's meeting due to a conflict,
so please email me if any text needs updating / harmonization with the
final writeup.
thanks,
-Prithwish
On 7/15/15 8:32 AM, Franck Le wrote:
*Event Invitation*
Title: DAIS ITA Project 1: Proposal preparation -- Toll-free USA:
1-888-426-6840 Toll-free UK: 0800-368-0638 Passcode: 54670842 Location:
When:
July 16, 2015 10:30 AM – 11:30 AM Organizer:
Franck Le/Watson/IBM *<fle@xxxxxxxxxx>* <fle@xxxxxxxxxx>
Description: Comment: Attendees:
Franck Le/Watson/IBM *<fle@xxxxxxxxxx>* <fle@xxxxxxxxxx>
*CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx* <CONWAY@xxxxxxxxxx> Dinesh Verma/Watson/IBM
*<dverma@xxxxxxxxxx>* <dverma@xxxxxxxxxx> Erich M Nahum/Watson/IBM
*<nahum@xxxxxxxxxx>* <nahum@xxxxxxxxxx> *flavio@xxxxxxxxxx*
<flavio@xxxxxxxxxx> ITA Lab/Watson/IBM *<italab@xxxxxxxxxx>*
<italab@xxxxxxxxxx> *kin.leung@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx* <kin.leung@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
*leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx* <leandros.tassiulas@xxxxxxxx>
*pbasu@xxxxxxx* <pbasu@xxxxxxx> *sguha@xxxxxxx* <sguha@xxxxxxx> Ting
He/Watson/IBM *<the@xxxxxxxxxx>* <the@xxxxxxxxxx> *towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx*
<towsley@xxxxxxxxxxxx> *yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx* <yang.r.yang@xxxxxxxx>
[attachment "P1 input - control plane communication - th - pb.docx"
deleted by Erich M Nahum/Watson/IBM] [attachment
"Architectures_SDC_Kin.docx" deleted by Erich M Nahum/Watson/IBM]
