In which case, then, no US citizen is allowed under any circumstance to have the Red Dwarf Scripts or associated material in there possession! ------------------------- Mr. Matthew F. Horspool Send me an Electronic Mail to drjaws@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx Add horspool@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx to your MSN contact list Or Visit my web site at http://www.horspool.pwp.blueyonder.co.uk ------------------------- -----Original Message----- From: dectalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx [mailto:dectalk-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Tony Baechler Sent: Wednesday, December 29, 2004 2:45 PM To: dectalk@xxxxxxxxxxxxx Subject: [DECtalk], Re: copyright Hi. Most probably yes. The US copyright law is very clear on this. First, if you just consider the scripts, they are illegal because they are written post-1922. If you consider that the scripts are being done as a public performance, this falls into other copyright laws but would still apply. Public performance would apply in this case because a synthesizer is reading the scripts and playing all the parts. The files are being made available for public download. It is really no different than mp3 music. Note that these laws apply in many European countries as well, but they are more relaxed on sound recordings and such. I know very little of European and Canadian copyright law but my understanding is that since they are primarily for the blind and are not being sold, it's probably legal. You would need to check more fully into local copyright laws to verify this. In one European country, Holland I think, DVDs may be copied and given away as long as they are not sold. Again, further checking would need to be done to verify this. As far as I know, Andre is in Europe so would fall under those laws, not the US laws. At 11:05 AM 12/29/2004 +0000, you wrote: >Going along these lines, does this mean that those in the US that have >Red Dwarf by DECtalk are breaking the law? --- the DECtalk list. To unsubscribe, send a blank message to: dectalk-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx and type unsubscribe in the subject field. Moderators email: shwatscoff@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx this list's homePage, and the unoficial DECtalk page is at, //www.freelists.org/webpage/dectalk --- the DECtalk list. To unsubscribe, send a blank message to: dectalk-request@xxxxxxxxxxxxx and type unsubscribe in the subject field. Moderators email: shwatscoff@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx this list's homePage, and the unoficial DECtalk page is at, //www.freelists.org/webpage/dectalk