The military of Saudi Arabia. (photo: AP)
Saudis Try Hostage-Taking as Diplomacy
By William Boardman, Reader Supported News
24 June 17
Assault on Qatar gets Trump tweet support, but US government demurs
The Persian Gulf nation of Qatar has been held in a weird kind of hostage
situation since June 5. That's when Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates
(UAE), and a few other countries decided to try to isolate and manipulate
Qatar by cutting diplomatic relations and imposing an embargo and something
of a blockade. A blockade is, by definition, an act of war, but the
blockaders didn't actually declare war, or send troops, or even make a clear
statement of casus belli at the time. Qatar has long been a scapegoat for
hardliners devoted to regional stability on their own terms only.
The hostage-taking, terrorist-supporting nations accused Qatar of supporting
terrorists, expelled Qatari diplomats and Qatari citizens, called their own
nationals home from Qatar, closed Qatar's only border (with Saudi Arabia),
and shut down air and sea routes to the tiny emirate, generally regarded as
a near-absolute, hereditary monarchy with little freedom to begin with.
Qatar is a small country, smaller than the state of Connecticut. Its
military of 11,800 is the second-smallest in the region. Qatar has a
population of roughly 2.6 million, only 300,000 of whom are citizens. The
rest are foreign workers, a quarter of them from India, with other large
contingents from Nepal and Bangladesh. Qatari citizens have the highest per
capita income in the world.
This surprise hostage move was duly reported as the "biggest diplomatic
crisis in years" in the region, as the Saudis acted with Egypt, Bahrain, and
the UAE to de-stabilize the region in response to what they claimed was
Qatar's de-stabilizing of the region. So what kind of crisis is it when a
coalition of dictatorships takes a neighboring state virtual hostage, for no
coherently stated reason, and then takes more than two weeks to present any
hostage demands (never mind how absurd)?
Let's review the bidding here. The region, from Israel to Afghanistan, is
not known for its stability in recent years, decades, centuries, or
millennia. The current period of extreme de-stabilization was touched off by
"I'm a war president" Bush, backed by a supine Congress (except for Rep.
Barbara Lee). The Middle East of the past 14 years is a Republican-led,
bipartisan master disaster that has destroyed millions of lives for nothing
more apparent than the appearance of American "leadership." But the US has
had plenty of help in the worst sense of the word from just about every
other country in the region, except possibly Oman, some of the time. Also
pitching in to spread the carnage have been several NATO allies, as well as
Russia. If that leaves out anyone, don't worry, there's more than enough
blood to go around for every official hand and a good many feet.
The governments holding Qatar hostage now are mad because Qatar had the
effrontery to offer some support to the democratic elements of the Arab
Spring of 2010-2011, when there was some hope to rid the region of the
brutal police states that stabilized the region. Only Tunisia has survived.
Egypt's present military dictatorship is mad at Qatar for supporting the
Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt and elsewhere and sees this hostage taking as a
chance for revenge.
Qatar is not exactly a stalwart defender of political freedom and human
rights, but judged by its enemies, Qatar looks pretty good. And Qatar is
also home to the largest US military base in the region, the Al Udeid Air
Base. That air base runs the bombing campaigns in Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan,
and elsewhere, much to the benefit of the Qatari hostage-takers. Better yet,
Qatar is a member of the Gulf Cooperation Council, the other members of
which are hostage-takers Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Kuwait, and UAE, as well as
Oman. The US air base also runs the bombing campaign in Yemen, where Qatar
is allied with its hostage-takers in the illegal, genocidal war that has
brought Yemen to the verge of mass starvation. Presumably the aggressors
believe that mass death in Yemen will help stabilize the region. The
government of Yemen, housed in Saudi Arabia, is also a titular Qatari
hostage-taker.
During my recent trip to the Middle East I stated that there can no longer
be funding of Radical Ideology. Leaders pointed to Qatar - look!
@realDonaldTrump tweet, June 6, 2017
With mad tweets like that, the president took credit for the hostage-taking,
even as his secretaries of State and Defense would try to distance their
country from the mess. Trump's business history provides a clear basis for
asking whether his decisions with regard to Qatar are shaped by
conflict-of-interest. The Saudis have been doing millions of dollars of
business with Trump for decades. The UAE has paid Trump millions of dollars
for putting his name on golf courses. Qatar has not done business with
Trump.
On June 14, the Defense Dept. signed a $12 billion deal to sell Qatar dozens
of F-15 fighter jets. On the same day, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson
expressed support for the arms deal approved by his department and said the
Saudi-led blockade was creating problems for the US military effort against
ISIS. Asked about the apparent gap between his comments and what Trump had
been tweeting, Tillerson assuaged Congress, "There is no gap between the
President and myself or the State Department on policy,. there is no
daylight between he and I."
On June 20, State Dept. spokesperson Heather Nauert rebuked the Saudi-led
hostage takers:
Now that it has been more than two weeks since the embargo started, we are
mystified that the Gulf states have not released to the Qataris, nor to the
public, the details about the claims they are making toward Qatar.. The more
that time goes by, the more doubt is raised about the actions taken by Saudi
Arabia and the UAE.. At this point, we are left with one simple question:
were the actions really about their concerns regarding Qatar's alleged
support for terrorism? Or were they about the long-simmering grievances
between and among the GCC [Gulf Cooperation Council] countries?
Noticeably absent from State's official view was any mention of Iran, even
though the hostage-takers complained about Qatar's normal engagement with
Iran. President Trump has long joined in demonizing Iran, regardless of the
weight of evidence that Saudi Arabia (for example) has long been a greater
supporter of terrorists than Iran. Iran, like Russia and Turkey, has called
for a peaceful resolution to the hostage-taking.
Turkey has directly supported Qatar diplomatically, militarily, and with
supplies in defiance of the embargo and blockade. Qatar, like Yemen, imports
most of its food. Turkey has an army base in Qatar, with about 150 troops
who train Qataris. Turkey, like Qatar, supported the Muslim Brotherhood
during the Arab Spring and has taken in hundreds of political refugees from
Egypt, which arrested and killed unknown numbers of people opposed to the
military coup. Among the hostage-takers' demands presented June 23 is that
Qatar shut down the Turkish military base.
The demands viewed as a totality amount to a demand that Qatar hand over its
sovereignty to Saudi Arabia and its fellow hostage-takers. The
hostage-takers want Qatar to shut down Al Jazeera, the Qatari news
organization that has been far too truthful about the region. The
hostage-takers want Qatar to break off diplomatic relations with Iran, a
regionally de-stabilizing act that is consistent with the suspected Saudi
desire to bring on a full-scale religious war between Sunni and Shiite
Muslims. Iran is Shiite. Qatar and its hostage-takers are all Sunni.
Given the nexus of contradictions and conflicts of interests surrounding the
Qatar hostage situation, it's no surprise the German foreign minister has
referred to it as the "Trumpification" of regional politics: "Such a
Trumpification of relations with one another is particularly dangerous in a
region that is already rife with crises."
William M. Boardman has over 40 years experience in theatre, radio, TV,
print journalism, and non-fiction, including 20 years in the Vermont
judiciary. He has received honors from Writers Guild of America, Corporation
for Public Broadcasting, Vermont Life magazine, and an Emmy Award nomination
from the Academy of Television Arts and Sciences.
Reader Supported News is the Publication of Origin for this work. Permission
to republish is freely granted with credit and a link back to Reader
Supported News.
e-max.it: your social media marketing partner
