That extradition bill has been withdrawn. But it was used because a Taiwanese
man had murdered his lover and cut her up into pieces, and then escaped to Hong
Kong in order not to be charged with the murder. It had nothing to do with
demonstrations against the mainland government.
The economic inequality has certainly increased in Hong Kong, even more than in
mainland China because Hong Kong still functions under separate rules which
allow international corporations and banks to function as they do in western
countries.
Many different factions, including the US government, are taking advantage of
the people's discontent, for their own purposes. Several observers have
reported that there's a good deal of confusion among the protestors,
particularly the young ones, about the cause of their problems.
Miriam
-----Original Message-----
From: blind-democracy-bounce@xxxxxxxxxxxxx On Behalf Of Roger Loran Bailey
(Redacted sender "rogerbailey81" for DMARC)
Sent: Sunday, September 08, 2019 12:27 PM
To: blind-democracy <blind-democracy@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Subject: [blind-democracy] Report from Hong Kong: The rise and outlook of the
mass struggle
https://socialistaction.org/2019/09/07/report-from-hong-kong-the-rise-and-outlook-of-the-mass-struggle/
Report from Hong Kong: The rise and outlook of the mass struggle
/ 20 hours ago
Sept. 2019 HOng Kong (Athit Perawongmetha:Reuters)By LAM CHI LEUNG
Protests are continuing in Hong Kong, despite the withdrawal of the Extradition
Bill by Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam on Sept. 4. Protesters have raised the
slogan, ???Five key demands, not one less!??? They want direct elections of
Hong Kong leaders, an independent investigation into acts of police brutality,
unconditional release of the detainees, and no more labeling of the protests as
riots.
An earlier article, by Hong Kong revolutionary socialist Lam Chi Leung,
follows:
Warm greetings to comrades around the world! I am grateful for your invitation
to introduce the present situation of Hong Kong???s Anti-Extradition Movement
as well as the contexts under which it emerged. I will also attempt to provide
a simplified analysis of the movement???s internal dynamics and contradictions,
as well as my hopes and advice to the movement as a member of the socialist
left.
At the time of writing (Sunday, Aug. 18), over 1.7 million citizens of Hong
Kong returned to the streets in protest. In face of the police???s directive
that restricted the rally to take place inside a single park, the leading
organizers around Civil Human Rights Front refused to comply, let alone the
ordinary people who stepped into the streets. Both the organizers and the
rank-and-file participants understand that this will be a peaceful
demonstration. They would not storm any government buildings or police
barricades, to block the government from blaming the masses for ???rioting???
and thusly crackdown on the entire movement.
Change in tactics
How is there such a consensus? This is because, in the past one and a half
months, the repression from the government against protesters became ever more
brutal. They allowed the police to launch teargas, pellet rounds, and rubber
bullets at close distance, not to mention the liberal use of the baton. At the
same time, the police unleashed mobsters to attack protesters and ordinary
people on the subway platforms and inside the trains. Some of these elements
even attacked protesters with knives.
Last week, the police disguised as protesters to infiltrate the movement and
provoke adventurist violence. Some mainland Chinese police and state journalist
operatives (many of whom hold both credentials) went to the airport to
deliberately expose their identities to protesters to incite violence, to
create footages of mainland Chinese officials being bullied. The escalation of
the government???s violence and conspiratorial tactics led the protesters to
conclude a need to change tactics. This means halting any confrontations or
surrounding actions in favor of peaceful demonstrations. They hope that by
doing so more people would be attracted to the movement while depriving the
government an excuse to slander the movement and increase repression.
The two phases of movement
The process of the Anti-Extradition movement that erupted since June 9 could be
roughly divided into early and later phases.
The first phase would be between June 9 and July 20. During this phase, there
were mostly peaceful demonstrations (with the two million-strong protest of
June 16 at its height), which also included the besieging of Legislative
Council and government buildings. These resulted in Chief Executive Carrie
Lam???s concession to postpone the extradition bill that fell short of a full
retraction.
This first phase was characterized by the defensive posture of the government
and the masses??? bravery, creativity, and flexibility. For example, as the
police were ready to charge the protesters after the masses encircled the
Legislative Council building, the masses rapidly conducted an orderly retreat
rather than fighting the police. Another example was in early July when the
movement was spreading to other districts outside of Hong Kong island by way of
active organizing of protests.
The second phase is from July 21 up until now. During this phase the government
condoned the mobsters??? attack on protesters; the police also increased the
level of repression. The Hong Kong government refuses to respond to the Five
Demands from the protesters (including the retraction of characterizing the
movement as ???riots,??? the release of arrested protesters, the retraction of
the extradition bill, the responsibility of police brutality, and the formation
of an independent investigation commission into violence).
The CCP regime further accused the movement as a terroristic riot engineered by
the U.S. and Taiwan, even deploying a large number of forces along the Shenzhen
border with Hong Kong as a deterrent to the Hong Kong masses. While the Hong
Kong masses remain unbowed, most protests are approaching the methods of urban
guerrilla tactics. The exploits of preventing people from boarding subways or
airlines as a means to ???civil disobedience,??? or the unwise handling of the
mainland Chinese police provocateur, have inspired internal discussions and
self-reflection within the movement. At the moment the movement is at a
crossroads that can only be advanced with a better strategy.
The deep crisis
How is it that the present mass struggle can last for 11 weeks and counting? We
can attribute to it several main reasons:
First, the Extradition Bill, once passed, anyone who criticizes the Chinese
government, attends Tiananmen commemoration events, or generally support more
democracy in China may be vulnerable to be extradited to mainland China and be
tried. This will significantly infringe on Hong Kongers??? freedom and basic
human rights, it also encroaches upon the CCP???s (Chinese Communist Party???s)
promise for allowing ???Hong Kongers to govern Hong Kong with a high degree of
autonomy??? since Hong Kong???s return to China in 1997. The CCP forbids
democratic elections in Hong Kong but would grant a degree of freedom of speech
and protection of the law. The Extradition bill thus doubtlessly struck a nerve
on the ordinary Hong Kongers.
Second, poverty and social inequality have been exacerbated. Since the
1997 Asian Financial Crisis, the government forcefully pursued neoliberal
policies, commodifying education, health care, and housing.
The monopoly of large capital became especially trenchant, real estate prices
have shot through the roof. Employment for young people became highly
precarious, while wages never catch up to the actual cost of goods, rendering
the youth to see no hope in their future.
In the past 20 years, Hong Kong???s real wages have stagnated, while the
population under the poverty line increased to over 1.37 million, almost one in
five Hong Kongers. The Gini coefficient of Hong Kong, which measures
inequality, has reached 0.539, higher than that of the U.S. and Singapore.
Public housing has decreased, forcing over 220,000 people to live in what???s
called ???sub-divided flats,??? i.e., extremely small subdivided apartment
units. This is the deeper social factor that drove the ferocity of the
Anti-Extradition movement and the large participation of the youth, as well as
their radical measures, winning a degree of understanding of the otherwise
peaceful, nonviolent wage workers. Some youths even have drafted up wills to
prepare for a literal life-and-death struggle. The severity of social
contradictions is self-evident.
Third, in the 20 years since Hong Kong???s return, the elevation of repression
is helping the masses to see that the CCP has no intention of allowing for real
general elections. At the same time, the increasingly authoritarian Xi Jinping
regime, as well as the worsening social conditions, have rapidly driven the
Hong Kong masses away from China in the past 10 years.
Finally, Carrie Lam???s arrogant and snobbish attitude, as well as the
deployment of the police and mobsters against the protesters, have ratcheted up
even more anger of the masses.
Umbrella Movement and Anti-Extradition movement
Perhaps we all recall the 2014 ???Umbrella Movement.??? Although the present
Anti-Extradition movement has not ended, we can still compare the current
experience with that of five years ago.
First, the Umbrella Movement struggled for rights to a general election and in
particular the right to elect the Chief Executive, whereas the Anti-Extradition
movement sought to defend the existing personal freedoms and basic human rights
from further encroachment, making it a defensive struggle.
Second, the Umbrella Movement pursued long-term road occupations, stresses for
a no-retreat ???valiant??? struggle, while the Anti-Extradition movement adopts
more flexible tactics. Protesters don???t stubbornly defend their grounds in
face of police repression and stress the need for a ???smart struggle.???
Third, during the Umbrella Movement, many far-right localists were able to
highjack the attention and support of many youths with their demagogy of
???Hong Kong First,??? rejecting new mainland Chinese immigrants and tourists.
The far-right localists??? influence over the present movement has diminished.
The masses do not all insist on the ???valiant struggles???
championed by the localists, and many have actively sought to win over the
masses of mainland China. The most representative example was the Kowloon
district protest of July 7. Despite some leading organizers themselves tending
towards xenophobic localism, the rank-and-file protesters instead started
distributing flyers in simplified Chinese to tourists, and even started to sing
the Internationale! This shows that not all protesters tend towards localist
ideas.
Backed by foreign forces?
The CCP regime and Carrie Lam have slandered the Anti-Extradition movement as
one backed by foreign forces. Yet the entire movement erupted spontaneously,
with many road blocking and clashes of the youths stressing the
???leaderlessness??? of their actions. The U.S. National Endowment for
Democracy has indeed funded some of the oppositionist parties in Hong Kong, but
the masses are not under these forces???
control. They mostly strategize and decide on slogans via online chat forums or
communication software.
Even the ???Civil Human Rights Front,??? which is composed of over 50
pro-democratic civil societies and parties and largely credited as the
organizer of many demonstrations, has admitted that they can only act as a
platform and does not have the political authority to lead the entire mass
movement. In fact, since the Umbrella Movement, decentralization, lack of
organization, and distrust of the existing political parties and figures have
largely characterized the mass movements in Hong Kong.
Political errors within the movement
Nonetheless, we must identify two primary political errors within the
Anti-Extradition movement, although these tendencies have yet to dominate the
entire movement. The first is the presence of pro-Western imperialist liberals
who have illusions to ask Trump to pressure China into granting more freedoms
in Hong Kong. They merely oppose dictatorship in Hong Kong, but never oppose
the monopoly capitalists, let alone winning workers over to the movement by
proposing economic demands of the working class.
The other was the role of the aforementioned far-right localists, who prettify
the leaderless form of struggle to allow for their adventurist tactics of
storming government buildings without being criticized and disciplined by the
entire mass movement. They brand mainland Chinese people as ???chinks,???
flying British colonial flags. These methods would only help the CCP to
characterize the present movement as one for Hong Kong independence and in turn
use nationalist demagogy to lie to the Chinese masses, exacerbating the divide
between the Hong Kong and mainland Chinese masses. In reality, it is precisely
the illusions and cowardice of the liberals that allowed for a minority of
???valiant???
protesters to pursue unwise adventures and gain increased influence over the
mass movement.
Labor movement and the socialist left
Finally, I would like to discuss the role of the labor movement and the
socialist left within the Anti-Extradition movement.
As we know, Hong Kong has had a history of heroic class struggle. The
Seamen???s Strike of 1922 and the Canton-Hong Kong General Strike of
1925-26 both brought the British imperialists to heel, but both of them
happened almost a century ago. The last attempt at a political strike was in
1967, led by the CCP-controlled Hong Kong Federation of Trade Unions (HKFTU).
After that struggle failed, and as the CCP began to pursue ???Reform and
Opening??? to restore capitalism in China in the 1980s, the HKFTU became an
openly pro-business and pro-capitalist conservative trade union. During the
same time, a trade-union movement independent of the CCP and the KMT began to
emerge, concentrated primarily in education, airline, public transportation,
and social work sectors.
The present movement saw two attempts at political strikes on June 17 and Aug.
5 led by independent trade unions. The first attempt was largely unsuccessful;
the second one involved over 350,000 workers. It is claimed that over a third
of air traffic controllers went on strike, and many flight attendants of Cathay
Pacific and Hong Kong Airline also joined the strike, causing over 200 flights
being canceled. The subway also halted operation for half of the day on the
morning of Aug. 5.
However, this cannot be classified as a total general strike. Many workers such
as teachers and social workers chose to take a personal holiday instead of
going on strike to avoid management???s retaliation.
Some of the bosses also permitted the workers to take the day off for them to
join the protest.
Right now the independent unions are preparing for a third political strike in
September, the same time that university and high school students plan on
striking. If the political strike can successfully coordinate with the student
actions, then they would deal a serious blow to the ruling class.
The left in Hong Kong remains small and divided, including social-democratic
political organizations, broad-left organizations, and a minority of
revolutionary socialist network. As a revolutionary socialist activist, I have
consistently proposed three demands:
1) The protesters must organize democratic discussions that determine the
tactics of the movement. ???Leaderless??? form of struggle must not be
prettified. Instead, protesters must look towards the Yellow Vests in France
who formed constituent assemblies.
2) While we should continue to press for rallies, demonstrations, and mass
encirclement, we must also avoid storming government buildings, to prevent the
government from using these occasions to escalate repression or even deploying
Chinese troops.
3) The Anti-Extradition movement must connect with the labor and social
movements, wielding political strikes and school walk-outs as weapons, thus
creating a movement independent of the ruling class and controlled by the
working masses. For this, they must propose anti-capitalist social demands to
win over more workers??? participation. They must also support the workers???
struggle in mainland China or mass struggles for rights protection, to foster
more movement against the CCP???s bureaucratic capitalist regime within
mainland China.
We must also foster the solidarity of all workers around the world by calling
for a ???better world.??? Some on the left still hold a ???campist???
view, believing that the CCP regime still represents a progressive force
against Western imperialism or even something along the lines of ???the enemy
of my enemy is my friend.??? These kinds of ???leftists??? do not understand
that the CCP regime today is already a regime of bureaucratic capital against
the workers. They also forget that the left must firmly hold a perspective from
the working class. We must not only fight against US imperialism but also the
various imperialist forces and capitalist exploitation across East Asia. Thank
you!
August 18, 2019
Lam Chi Leung is a revolutionary socialist based in Hong Kong. Photo:
Athit Perawongmetha / Reuters
Share this:
???Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window) ???Click to share on
Facebook (Opens in new window)
September 7, 2019 in China, East Asia. Tags: Hong Kong
Related posts
Hong Kong protesters reject extradition to China
Hong Kong protests demand democracy
Interview: Rising hopes for Puerto Rican independence
Post navigation
??? Cancelled ???squad trip??? to West Bank puts U.S. Israel policy in the
spotlight
Get Involved!
Donate to help support our work
Get email updates
Join Socialist Action
Newspaper Archives
Newspaper Archives Select Month September 2019?? (6) August 2019 (14)
July 2019?? (10) June 2019?? (14) May 2019?? (12) April 2019 (12) March
2019?? (13) February 2019?? (10) January 2019?? (16) December 2018?? (12)
November 2018?? (15) October 2018?? (10) September 2018?? (8) August 2018??
(12) July 2018?? (13) June 2018 (11) May 2018?? (19) April 2018?? (15)
March 2018?? (17) February 2018?? (14) January 2018?? (13) December 2017??
(13) November 2017 (13) October 2017?? (16) September 2017?? (15) August
2017?? (16) July 2017?? (17) June 2017?? (16) May 2017?? (17) April 2017??
(14) March 2017?? (13) February 2017?? (19) January 2017?? (13) December
2016?? (12) November 2016?? (19) October 2016?? (12) September 2016 (10)
August 2016?? (10) July 2016?? (14) June 2016?? (14) May 2016 (9) April
2016?? (12) March 2016?? (14) February 2016?? (8) January 2016?? (11)
December 2015?? (11) November 2015?? (9) October 2015 (8) September 2015??
(10) August 2015?? (7) July 2015?? (13) June 2015?? (9) May 2015?? (10)
April 2015?? (12) March 2015?? (9) February 2015?? (11) January 2015?? (10)
December 2014?? (12) November 2014 (11) October 2014?? (9) September 2014??
(6) August 2014?? (10) July 2014?? (11) June 2014?? (10) May 2014?? (11)
April 2014?? (10) March 2014?? (9) February 2014?? (11) January 2014?? (11)
December 2013 (10) November 2013?? (11) October 2013?? (17) September
2013?? (13) August 2013?? (10) July 2013?? (11) June 2013?? (15) May 2013??
(14) April 2013?? (14) March 2013?? (12) February 2013?? (10) January 2013??
(17) December 2012?? (7) November 2012?? (8) October 2012 (19) September
2012?? (2) August 2012?? (27) July 2012?? (18) June 2012?? (3) May 2012??
(19) April 2012?? (14) March 2012?? (17) February 2012?? (19) January 2012??
(17) December 2011?? (3) November 2011?? (33) October 2011?? (14) September
2011?? (13) August 2011 (34) July 2011?? (24) June 2011?? (19) May 2011??
(19) April 2011 (15) March 2011?? (15) February 2011?? (15) January 2011??
(15) December 2010?? (17) November 2010?? (1) October 2010?? (6) September
2010?? (3) August 2010?? (8) July 2010?? (7) June 2010?? (2) May 2010 (10)
April 2010?? (3) March 2010?? (8) February 2010?? (3) January 2010?? (9)
December 2009?? (6) November 2009?? (5) October 2009?? (16) September 2009??
(3) August 2009?? (2) July 2009?? (5) June 2009?? (2) May 2009?? (7) April
2009?? (6) March 2009?? (16) February 2009?? (9) January 2009?? (10)
December 2008?? (11) November 2008?? (8) October 2008?? (16) September
2008?? (14) August 2008?? (18) July 2008?? (12) June 2008?? (3) May 2008??
(2) April 2008?? (3) March 2008?? (14) February 2008?? (11) January 2008??
(11) December 2007?? (8) November 2007?? (1) July 2007?? (1) June 2007?? (1)
April 2007?? (1) March 2007?? (1) February 2007?? (3) December 2006?? (11)
November 2006 (11) October 2006?? (13) September 2006?? (15) August 2006??
(11) July 2006?? (18) June 2006?? (7) May 2006?? (14) April 2006?? (6) March
2006?? (14) February 2006?? (5) January 2006?? (2) December 2005?? (9)
November 2005?? (8) October 2005?? (13) September 2005 (12) August 2005??
(9) July 2005?? (16) June 2005?? (16) May 2005 (16) April 2005?? (12) March
2005?? (14) February 2005?? (19) January 2005?? (15) December 2004?? (14)
November 2002?? (17) October 2002 (19) September 2002?? (22) August 2002??
(21) July 2002?? (15) May 2002?? (21) April 2002?? (21) February 2002?? (15)
January 2002?? (15) December 2001?? (17) October 2001?? (24) September
2001?? (18) July 2001?? (19) June 2001?? (18) October 2000?? (17) September
2000?? (21) August 2000?? (19) July 2000?? (16) June 2000?? (26) May 2000??
(21) April 2000?? (22) March 2000?? (28) February 2000?? (18) January 2000??
(20) December 1999?? (20) November 1999?? (26) October 1999 (25) September
1999?? (18) August 1999?? (40) July 1999?? (38) June 1999?? (24) May 1999??
(27) April 1999?? (25) March 1999?? (26) February 1999?? (29) January 1999??
(24) July 1998?? (12)
Search
???View socialistactionusa???s profile on Facebook
???View SocialistActUS???s profile on Twitter
???View SocialistActionCT???s profile on YouTube
Subscribe to Our Newspaper
Upcoming Events
No upcoming events
Category Cloud
Actions & Protest Africa Anti-War Arts & Culture Black Liberation Canada
Caribbean Civil Liberties Connecticut Cuba East Asia Economy Education &
Schools Elections Environment Europe Immigration International Labor
Latin America Marxist Theory & History Middle East Palestine Police &
FBI Prisons South Asia Trump / U.S. Government Uncategorized Vote
Socialist Action Women's Liberation
View Calendar
Blog at WordPress.com.
Follow
--
---
Clarence Darrow
??? I have always felt that doubt was the beginning of wisdom, and the fear of
God was the end of wisdom. ???
??? Clarence Darrow,
